Horrifying fate in RPGs - the more horrifying the better!

[Mr. Pink]

 

[ERYFKRAD]

Being muds_animal_friend. Mud is pathetic, and you're his friend.

 

[Goblino]

Being an autistic peasant in the mining colony and getting murdered when you try to make friends with the new guy.

 

[Harold]

As some have mentioned before, MotB has some really good ones.
Below, my favourite two

Spoiler

Your success was an undeniable boon to her - where before, Kaelyn had found only tepid support, now outcasts of all kinds flocked to her banner.

You hunted the creature for many months afterward, cornering One of Many in the Plane of Shadow. It spoke to you with Safiya's voice, pleading for its life, before you struck it down, and sent all of its souls shrieking to the Wall.
By all known accounts, you never took another lover...

 

[muds_animal_friend]

Being muds_animal_friend. Mud is pathetic, and you're his friend.

Even more horrific than that. I chose my user name from a couple of lines in the English translation of Gothic where Mud asks Nameless something along the lines of 'What did they send you to the colony for?' followed by 'Do you like animals too?' in a rather creepy voice.

I suspect Mud ended up in the colony for being a bit too fond of the local livestock.

 

[ERYFKRAD]

Even more horrific than that. I chose my user name from a couple of lines in the English translation of Gothic where Mud asks Nameless something along the lines of 'What did they send you to the colony for?' followed by 'Do you like animals too?' in a rather creepy voice.

I suspect Mud ended up in the colony for being a bit too fond of the local livestock.

I know bro, I know.