Alternative RPG Codex GOTY 2015 VOTE!

[Plane Escapee]

Underrail: 10
Age of Decadence: 10
Dead State: Reanimated: 8
Serpent in the Staglands : 8
Wasteland 2: Director's Cut: 7 (would have given it 7½, it's tedious parts prevent rounding up to 8)
Shadowrun: Hong Kong: 7
Hard West: 7
Legends of Eisenwald: 6 (would have have given it 6½ but enjoyed it less overall than Hard West and Wasteland 2)
Pillars of Eternity: 6 (art, Grieving Mother and CYOA elements saves it from being a 5)
The Quest: 5
ICY: 5
State of Decay: YOSE Day One Edition: 4
Sword Coast Legends: 4 (haven't tried game-master mode or multiplayer, maybe it wold have bumped it up to a 5)
Sunless Sea: 3

 

[dr. one]

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin: 10 (rounded up from 9.5)
Age of Decadence: 9 (rounded up from 8.5)
Divinity: Original Sin - EE: 8
Pillars of Eternity: 8
Underrail: 7
Undertale: 7
The Witcher 3: 7
Wasteland 2 - DC: 6
Shadowrun: Hong Kong: 6

 

[Kalin]

Age of Decadence: 10
Underrail: 10
Serpent in the Staglands: 9

 

[flyingjohn]

Japanese related games:

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin: 10
Legend of Heroes: Trail in the Sky SC: 8
Ys VI: The Ark of Napishtim : 8
Way of the Samurai 4 : 8
Final Fantasy XIII - Lightning Returns: 7
Dragon Quest Heroes : 7
Tales of Zestiria : 5

Western related games:

Underrail : 10
Invisible, Inc : 9
Sanctuary RPG: Black Edition : 8
Divinity: Original Sin - Enhanced Editon: 8
Wasteland 2: Director's Cut : 8
Age of Decadence : 8
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt : 8

 

[Jimmious]

PoE with 1 and 2 ... Codex

PoE 8
D:OS EE 9
WL2:DC 8
Dead State Reanimated 6
Underrail 6
Witcher 3 7
Hard West 5
Fallout 4 2
Invisible Inc 7
Mordheim 8



Can't remember more now

 

[Urbanolo]

Age of Decadence: 10
Underrail: 8
Legends of Eisenwald: 8
Serpent in the Staglands: 7
Telepath Tactics: 7
Pillars of Eternity: 7
Shadowrun HK: 6
Blackguards 2: 3
Witcher 3: 3
Undertale: 2
Fallout 4: 1

 

[Wintermute]

Underrail 9
Serpent in the Staglands 8

Have not played AOD, POE yet. Will not play the rest.

 

[Werdna's Revenge]

Age of Decadence: 9
Witcher 3: 9
Undertale: 8
Crypt of the NecroDancer: 6
Wave of Darkness: 5
Hard West: 5

I really need to play Underrail.

 

[Jacob]

Haven't played many of the 2015 release, since I'm still trying to finish the classics I haven't played...

Pillars : 7
Lightning Returns : 5
Way of the Samurai 4 : 9 (I happen to love the CYOA story and the weird weeaboo stuff)
Shadowrun Hong Kong : 7
Ys VI Ark of Napishtim : 8 (I actually haven't played the Steam release, but voted anyway)
Fallout 4 : 5

 

[MediantSamuel]

Age of Decadence: 9 - Nothing's perfect, even this masterpiece.
Underrail: 8 - Thoroughly enjoyed my time with Underrail but a few complaints and a poor end game mean this isn't my favourite.
Witcher 3: 7 - I actually really liked Witcher 3, especially the first DLC which had a better main story than the base game.
Shadowrun HK: 6 - I really do like Shadowrun's setting but the combat is so bland and unsatisfying.
Pillars of Eternity: 3 - I actually plowed through and finished PoE but I kind of hated almost every minute of it.

 

[Neanderthal]

Ant played much modern stuff fraid to say:

Age of Decadence - 8
Blackguards 2 - 3
Dead State Reanimated - 5
Div OS EE - 7
Hard West - 6
Pillars of Eternity - 5
Witcher 3 - 7

Reckon 10 is impossible like any kind o perfection, so best o best is a 9 in my eye.

 

[DDZ]

Serpents in the Stagland - 5.5

 

[meanwhileInPoland]

Lol first page and people already give 1 or 10 to AoD and PoE

Why so extreme?
AoD 2
PoE 2
Underrail 2
Undertale 2
Twicher3 2

SRHK 9
SitS 9
DS2SotFS 9
SunlessSea 9
WayoftheSamurai4 9

 

[Slimu]

Based on the list made by felipepepe for the poll:

Dead State: Reanimated - 6
Divinity: Original Sin - Enhanced Editon - 9
Wasteland 2: Director's Cut - 9
Invisible, Inc - 8
Legends of Eisenwald - 8
Telepath Tactics - 8
Age of Decadence - 10
Serpent in the Staglands - 8
Sunless Sea - 7
Crypt of the necrodancer - 8 (not sure if really an RPG)

 

[Zorba the Hutt]

Thanks for setting this up.

Age of Decadence: 9
Underrail: 8
Serpent in the Staglands: 7
Shadowrun HK: 6
Pillars of Eternity: 3
Sword Coast Legends: 1
Undertale: 1

 

[Arthandas]

Original Sin EE: 10
Scholar of the First Sin: 9
Undertale: 9
ADOM: 9*
Dragon's Dogma DA: 8
Lightning Returns: 8
AoD: 5

*It got tiles and many other improvements so it should be listed along other 2015 remasters.

 

[Daedalos]

RPGs
Underrail: 9
Age of Decadence: 8
Pillars of Eternity: 5
Shadowrun Hong Kong: 3
Fallout 4: 2
UnderTale - 1

Tacticool:
Invisible Inc.: 7
Hard West: 6
Satellite Reign:5

Enhanced/Remakes

WL2DC - 8
D:OS:EE - 7

 

[Delterius]

Age of Decadence: 10
Underrail: 8
Serpent in the Staglands: 7
Witcher 3: 7
Pillars of Eternity: 4
Sword Coast Legends: 3
Undertale: 9

 

[Castanova]

Dota 2: 10
AoD: 6
PoE: 5
Divinity: 7

 

[Immortal]

Witcher 3: 10
Underrail: 9
Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin: 8
Shadowrun HK: 7
Divinity: Original Sin (Enhanced Edition): 7
Dragon's Dogma DA: 6
Wasteland 2 DC: 6
Serpent in the Staglands: 6
Pillars of Eternity: 5
Blackguards 2: 2
Sword Coast Legends: 1
Fallout 4: 1

INB4 Toro realizes what a pain in the ass this will be.

 

[Gicusan]

Age of Decadence: 9
Witcher 3: 8.5
Underrail: 8
Hard West: 7.5
Shadowrun HK: 7.5
Legends of Eisenwald: 7
Blackguards 2: 7
Pillars of Eternity: 5
Dead State - 5
Fallout 4: 4.5

Remakes. Good but dont count them.
WL2DC - 8
D:OS:EE - 9

 

[Correct_Carlo]

Age of Decadence: 10
Avernum 2 Remake: 8
Pillars of Eternity: 7
Witcher 3: 9

Darks Souls 2 Scholar Edition (on its own merits, 9. As a remake it didn't add much, though)

 

[markec]

Underrail: 10
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt: 8
Legends of Eisenwald: 7
Dead State: Reanimated: 7
Divinity: Original Sin - Enhanced Editon: 7
Age of Decadence: 7
Dex: 6
Shadowrun: Hong Kong: 6
Wasteland 2: Director's Cut: 5
Fallout 4: 4
Pillars of Eternity: 3
Blackguards 2: 3

 

[Berekän]

Divinity: Original Sin - Enhanced Edition: 9
Witcher 3: 9
Chaos Reborn: 8
Pillars of Eternity: 7
Undertale: 6
Chroma Squad: 6
Legends of Eisenwald: 5
Sunless Sea: 5
State of Decay: YOSE Day One Edition: 4

I keep slacking off, not playing the ones I must.

 

[Daedalos]

Sure why not. (Remakes/Re-editions needs their own section like felipepepe's poll, the standards by which they should be judged is different from normal releases imho)

Undertale: 10 (Not necessarily without any flaws but I wouldn't change a single thing about it)
Invisible Inc.: 10 (Best stealth squad game ever made, also generally one of the best tactical squad games ever made).
Age of Decadence: 9
Chaos Reborn: 9
Way of the Samurai 4: 8
Hard West: 8
Crypt of the Necrodancer: 8
Telepath Tactics: 7
Shadowrun Hong Kong: 7
Witcher 3: 6
Dex: 6
Satellite Reign:6
Underrail: 5
Hand of Fate: 5
Pillars of Eternity: 4
Fallout 4: 4
Blackguards 2: 3
Heroes of Might and Magic VII: 3

Underrail 5, but undertail a perfect 10?

I would pay money to have you banned from this forum!