Taka-Haradin puolipeikko
Filthy Kalinite
- Joined
- Apr 24, 2015
- Messages
- 19,246
felipepepe 's Codex's Best RPG vote has ended.
As people who have paid attention to voting system know; it used point buy system of 25 points that could be distributed, single game could get 5 points max per voting account. This naturally means that some of us had to make somewhat hard choices on which games to give votes to, whether it was because there were those 5 games which you wanted to be as well situated on final list as well as possible or you ran out of points after listing 25 "most" deserving games.
This is the thread where people can tell which RPG's didn't make quite the cut to the vote.
Here's mine last 5 6 that I considered:
-Dungeon Master; it was actually on my original post, but I changed it for Eye of the Beholder. Mainly because EotB is the game that first pops into my mind when I think of late 80's -early 90's blobber
-Underrail; mainly cut just because there weren't enough points. Annoyance on end game and DLC (that I'm still waiting) may have played a role.
-Betrayal at Krondor
-Baldur's Gate 1; I simply consider the sequel better, mainly because more interesting magic and UI improvements.
-Shadowrun: Dragonfall DC; Nice campaign to play through once, but I've never had any desire to re-play it.
-Nethack; I think it deserves to be voted on top 70 or however large that list will be, but I considered open world type roguelikes ADOM and Caves of Qud to be above a "mere" dungeon crawler.
edit.
-mentioned Nethack.
As people who have paid attention to voting system know; it used point buy system of 25 points that could be distributed, single game could get 5 points max per voting account. This naturally means that some of us had to make somewhat hard choices on which games to give votes to, whether it was because there were those 5 games which you wanted to be as well situated on final list as well as possible or you ran out of points after listing 25 "most" deserving games.
This is the thread where people can tell which RPG's didn't make quite the cut to the vote.
Maybe to analyze why or so that others could blame them that their favorite game got a bad result
Here's mine last
-Dungeon Master; it was actually on my original post, but I changed it for Eye of the Beholder. Mainly because EotB is the game that first pops into my mind when I think of late 80's -early 90's blobber
-Underrail; mainly cut just because there weren't enough points. Annoyance on end game and DLC (that I'm still waiting) may have played a role.
-Betrayal at Krondor
-Baldur's Gate 1; I simply consider the sequel better, mainly because more interesting magic and UI improvements.
-Shadowrun: Dragonfall DC; Nice campaign to play through once, but I've never had any desire to re-play it.
-Nethack; I think it deserves to be voted on top 70 or however large that list will be, but I considered open world type roguelikes ADOM and Caves of Qud to be above a "mere" dungeon crawler.
edit.
-mentioned Nethack.
Last edited: