Putting the 'role' back in role-playing games since 2002.
Donate to Codex
Good Old Games
  • Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.

    "This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.

The women of Caesar's Legion shouldn't have all been slaves

PetrusDisputator

Barely Literate
Joined
Nov 3, 2019
Messages
2
Their choices are fight or die. They're enjoying themselves because any dissenters are dead.
That interpretation is badly supported by the game, though. While Caesar does tell us about decimations and so forth, we never actually get to witness anything like that ourselves. Do we even get to talk to a single legionary who isn't a fanatic? The women, on the other hand are all obviously suffering.

Considering that, and also reading this post by Josh Sawyer, it does seem like there were some writers at Obsidian who didn't understand the Legion's society and just opted for portraying them in the crudest way possible.
 

Roguey

Codex Staff
Staff Member
Sawyerite
Joined
May 29, 2010
Messages
35,811
While Caesar does tell us about decimations and so forth, we never actually get to witness anything like that ourselves. Do we even get to talk to a single legionary who isn't a fanatic? The women, on the other hand are all obviously suffering.

They're all fanatics because the Legion has no place for men who aren't fanatics.
 

Yosharian

Arcane
Joined
May 28, 2018
Messages
9,503
Location
Grand Chien
I never could get motivated enough to play as a Legion character because the Legion is just too evil. From my point of view, a more 'grey' Legion would be much more interesting. However, I'm sure some people do enjoy playing as the Legion and (probably) an evil character, so I'm not sure if it would be better for the Legion to be grey, or to keep them as evil.

Then again, I also found it enjoyable to play through Knights of the Old Republic (the singleplayer RPG, not the MMO) as a Dark Side character, so I guess I'm not averse to evil playthroughs/characters after all?

There's just something about the Legion that's... boring. It's a boring kind of evil. Slavery, subjugation of women, that stuff just doesn't interest me. I can't find anything interesting about that kind of evil.

Blowing up wookies, choking Jedis to death, annihilating groups of people with Force Lightning... that's the kind of evil I can have fun with. I guess genuine, realistic evil is just... not fun?

Anyway, that aside, I read through all the posts and I still don't really understand what the argument is, regarding women in the Legion. Is it that women being more free in the Legion would make it more realistic? More grey? More interesting? I don't quite get it.

It doesn't seem very realistic that any women would want to be involved, by choice, in a society which considers them to be breeding machines that must be made available to whatever man wants them. I mean, sure, some women do choose to become brood mares, but they generally do that when they get to choose which idiot low-IQ male(s) they want to procreate with, and there's usually a hefty incentive in the form of free money from the state per spawn they pop out into the world. So the Legion's slavery approach seems the only realistic one.
 
Last edited:

RK47

collides like two planets pulled by gravity
Patron
Joined
Feb 23, 2006
Messages
28,396
Location
Not Here
Dead State Divinity: Original Sin
I dunno. You have to balance it out a little bit.

Wasn't also said that in Legion territory there are no raiders at all?
They would be a little too positive so they gave something irrational evil to be grey.

It's lazy, but if you want to make grey factions you have to do smth like that.

It wouldn't take much for a Legion quest to involve escorting merchant caravan and then violently butchering any raiders that try to plunder them. After you brutally interrogate them for their camp locations of course. Follow this up with a counter-raid on their camp and slaughtering to the last man and that's Legion's efficiency explained.

You wouldn't need this quest to take place in Mojave. Legion officers can teleport you to 'somewhere in the east' for you to help with the war efforts. NCR quests, in contrast, should involve double-dealing officers who aren't paid enough and try to make do by accepting bribes from raiders or skims caps off shipments with 'administrative fees' and such. There's your contrast.
 
Self-Ejected

RNGsus

Self-Ejected
Joined
Apr 29, 2011
Messages
8,106
Wait, I thought any choice but Mr House was evil.
Not evil, but stupid. Who would fight for somebody else and get disposed off on the first opportunity, like it happend with the previous commander. Or in the best case getting a small monetary compensation for the "honorable" service by putting your life in danger.
Serving Mr House and later disposing him off was the only logical course of action. As some roman maniac, who liked beeing surranded by fatty healthy looking sleek heads that sleep at night than by lean and hungry man, said: "I would rather be first in a village than second in Rome."
F:NV would have been an other game if you could take over the Legion or become a dictator of the NCR. Then perhaps most people here would choose the Legion or at least seriously think about it (your own slaves, booze and guns).
My only complete plays were Mr House or bumping him off. We were the only two people in wasteland with any sense. (Benny's idea, true, but he was unlucky.)
 

Trashos

Arcane
Joined
Dec 28, 2015
Messages
3,413
t doesn't seem very realistic that any women would want to be involved, by choice, in a society which considers them to be breeding machines that must be made available to whatever man wants them.

Well, I have asked for evidence that this is what's going on, and I have been given none. I am waiting patiently. I have not seen it or remember it myself (but then again, I am not a Legion player).

Then we can discuss if such a strategy even makes sense for the Legion or if there are any such historic precedents. Without ever having seriously thought about it, my view was that the Legion was getting the soldiers they needed from the tribes they conquered. Now Roguey here and Josh (in Tumblr) are saying that Caesar's plan about women is that they should give him as many soldiers as possible in... 15+ years. I don't know, I am not sure that it sounds like a logical plan or that the Legion actually needed such a plan.

However, I am all open ears to hear how this argument is supported in-game and historically.

In short, you are taking it for granted that this the Legion's plan, while I am asking "Is this really the Legion's plan?" and "Why did this have to be the Legion's plan?".
 

Egosphere

Arcane
Joined
Jan 25, 2018
Messages
1,909
Location
Hibernia
You're misunderstanding life expectancy.

Child mortality rate drives down life expectancy, but that doesn't mean most people would literally live into their early/mid 20s. The result was that lots of people die young, but if they survive they live an expected life, even if it's just into their 50s or 60s.

Yes, but Rome had obligatory military service for men that suppressed their life expectancy even further. Only ~45% survived to finish it. What I was getting at was the differential in life expectancy, even though, as you've stated, child mortality was the great equalizer.

Edit: also the slave population didn't live nearly as long. They made up a sizeable % Rome
 
Last edited:

Drakortha

Liturgist
Joined
Jan 23, 2016
Messages
1,664
Location
Terra Australis
Speaking of Legion and NV (and women), I've been working on a new movie the past week that includes all 3.



It's largely incomplete (full video will be 6+ minutes long) but as you can see women can totally be warriors (or assassins) for the Legion. Just needs some imagination..
 

Endemic

Arcane
Joined
Jul 16, 2012
Messages
4,327
Yes, but Rome had obligatory military service for men that suppressed their life expectancy even further. Only ~45% survived to finish it.

That's why it took the Legion literal years to recover from the first assault on the Dam (Joshua Graham was punished for that failure).

Edward Sallow as Caesar isn't oblivious to the fact his faction isn't the same as the Rome we know.

ncr1ztk3f.png


He then goes on to compare himself to the historical Caesar:

ncr234kte.png


It wouldn't take much for a Legion quest to involve escorting merchant caravan and then violently butchering any raiders that try to plunder them. After you brutally interrogate them for their camp locations of course. Follow this up with a counter-raid on their camp and slaughtering to the last man and that's Legion's efficiency explained.

You wouldn't need this quest to take place in Mojave. Legion officers can teleport you to 'somewhere in the east' for you to help with the war efforts. NCR quests, in contrast, should involve double-dealing officers who aren't paid enough and try to make do by accepting bribes from raiders or skims caps off shipments with 'administrative fees' and such. There's your contrast.

I agree, I would have liked to see more quests like that on the Legion route. There are corrupt and deeply flawed individuals in the NCR (Colonel Moore for example), but there are also enough "good" people within it that Caesar's opinion is suspect. The Courier can intervene to fix a lot of NCR problems in the Mojave, but the same doesn't apply for Caesar's Legion.
 

overly excitable young man

Guest
Imagine having the gall to be a perfectly healthy and fertile woman after a nuclear apocalypse, the Legion was not only right but also morally superior to them with every consecutive rape, the women trying to hide their previous reproductive capacity from the world, selfishly and without remorse
Isn't that just Fury Road?
 

Mark Richard

Arcane
Joined
Mar 14, 2016
Messages
1,192
While both the NCR and Caesar's Legion are at a similar stage of expansion and face the same make-or-break crisis in New Vegas, only the NCR have two previous games of backstory. We witnessed the NCR's conception (and even had a hand in it), and its rise to power in Fallout 1 & 2. Caesar's Legion had one game to distinguish themselves and most of the related content was cut due to time constraints. It's tricky to make any strong argument one way or the other as we're left trying to piece together the writers' intentions from games media interviews. Maybe Caesar's Legion really are supposed to be as unequivocally bad as they appear in-game. An Obsidian Fallout sequel held deep within Legion-occupied territory would've presented an opportunity to show them in a more nuanced light.
 

Roguey

Codex Staff
Staff Member
Sawyerite
Joined
May 29, 2010
Messages
35,811
Well, I have asked for evidence that this is what's going on, and I have been given none. I am waiting patiently. I have not seen it or remember it myself (but then again, I am not a Legion player).

Boone talking about his wife:
Yeah. What they do to women... that's worse than death. There was no choice in what I did.

Canyon Runner at Cottonwood Cove:
It's a weak bunch, to be honest. I'd rather have extra currency to buy supplies or better captures off traders.

There's a boy, too old to be trained as a Legionary. Normally they have to die, but he's too frail to make trouble.

The old woman's dried up, but she could keep house or do gardening - if she can learn to keep her mouth shut.

The girl's the only one of real value, young enough to breed, not hideous to look at. What's your offer for the lot?

Then we can discuss if such a strategy even makes sense for the Legion or if there are any such historic precedents. Without ever having seriously thought about it, my view was that the Legion was getting the soldiers they needed from the tribes they conquered. Now Roguey here and Josh (in Tumblr) are saying that Caesar's plan about women is that they should give him as many soldiers as possible in... 15+ years. I don't know, I am not sure that it sounds like a logical plan or that the Legion actually needed such a plan.

What happens to the Boomers if you ignore them on the Legion path:
The Boomers defended themselves against many attacks from the Legion, but they eventually fell to the Legion's superior numbers. The Legion enslaved the Boomers and erased any memory of their existence from the wasteland.

The Legion wins battles by overwhelming their opponents through superior numbers, for that you need a lot of people.
 

Nerevar

N'wah
Patron
Repressed Homosexual
Joined
Jul 10, 2017
Messages
1,131
Location
Balmora
Make the Codex Great Again! Pathfinder: Wrath
People thought the Legion was evil? They seemed like the good guys compared to the NCR, can't think of a single redeeming quality about the NCR.
 

overly excitable young man

Guest
Some people would even kill their own brother for their sick rome fetish.
 

Trashos

Arcane
Joined
Dec 28, 2015
Messages
3,413
Roguey,

There are three main issues:

1) The Legion are presented in the game as rapists. Josh and you are saying that there was actually a logical plan behind the rapes. The first issue is: Is the logical plan behind the rapes presented WITHIN the game? Because if it isn't, then the Legion were left to look like mere rapists and whatever plan is only in Josh's head.

2) Now let's assume the first issue does not exist. WHY is this the Legion's plan? History (and Roman history too) is full of desperate expansive wars, when have we seen someone try to enlarge their army through rape? Is Caesar copying someone or is he innovating?

3) Now let's assume that the two issues above do not exist, and that enlarging an army through rape actually makes practical sense. Out of all the possible plans for Caesar, why was the rape plan CHOSEN by the narrative designers? He is not the first one who is having an expansive war and needs numbers, there must be other plans too.
 
Last edited:

Twiglard

Poland Stronk
Patron
Staff Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2014
Messages
7,238
Location
Poland
Strap Yourselves In Codex Year of the Donut
Obsidian tried to portray their main factions as the grey and the greyish evil. I don't really know why they do that instead of straightup having grey vs grey.

Also, why do I have to shoot up House just to let BOS live. FFS.
 

overly excitable young man

Guest
The things you actually see in the game show the legion just as another raider gang larping as legionaires.
So i don't think that the whole rape stuff doesn't make sense.
If we would see their society it would be another matter.
 

vota DC

Augur
Joined
Aug 23, 2016
Messages
2,269
Frumentarius.
Legion could employ older women for that, they would do a great job because nobody would suspect them. The problem could be travel between wild places, ncr land or even worse Independent lands aren't that patrolled.
 

AW8

Arcane
Joined
Mar 1, 2013
Messages
1,852
Location
North of Poland
Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire
No Legion character references "a wife back home" in non-Legion runs. All it would take is one of the Legion characters to say such a thing, but there is none of it.
Since they're an army of slaves used to wage constant war, marriage would be a completely nonsensical thing for Legionnaires. At most, they're ordered to knock up some female slaves every once in a while before they're sent back into the field.

That's not how it works. There are men happy being Legionaries. We meet several in the game. We meet no women who are happy being with the Legion.
Of course the Legionnaires are happy, they've been brainwashed since birth to worship Caesar and know no other life.

I have discussed previously that the apparent misogynism portrayed in the game has nothing to do with the core Legion system, it was totally unnecessary, bad world building, not roman-like, an inconsistent gameplay device when the PC is female, and I believe it was done on purpose to undermine Caesar's system. Very disappointing moment in a favorite game with otherwise impressive world building.
Yes, there is a problem with some writers going too far with the misogyny angle making Legionnaires come off as undisciplined jocks. I think Sawyer even agreed with this when replying to a Tumblr question.
There is also the well-known problem of the game being slightly overscoped for the development period, which caused them to cut the planned non-frontier Legion areas which would have showed safe towns where men and women live their lives without being disturbed by their strange guardians.

But you keep refering to the Legion as soldiers and not slaves, which is simply wrong. A soldier may be conscripted into an army for a time, but the idea isn't that he or she will stay a soldier for the rest of their life.
A Legionnaire on the other hand, and let's make it clear that the Legion only consists of men, is chosen for the Legion at a young age. No one joins by choice. And no one quits the Legion, the only way out is death. Why?
Because the Legion is entirely made up of slaves. Beginning to end, Caesar owns them.

Female slaves in Legion territory are mostly used for breeding, but there are other uses. In the Fort you meet Siri who because of her previous medical training works as a healer, and Ranger Stella who due to her prowess at killing works as a gladiator.
None of these are happy about their lot in life because they are recent captures, but there should logically be women who've been raised since childhood to worship Caesar and would be happy to spread their legs for his cause. I don't think any are in the game though - again, the Legion was a victim of overscoping/not negotiating for a longer development time.

But while slavery is practiced in Caesar's territories and his army is entirely made up of them, there are free people living there as well (remember that Caesar controls four gigantic states). As the game doesn't take place there, I think the only one we meet is Dale Barton who hails from Arizona. He paints Legion territory as very safe, and that's how it logically should be for its subjects, allies and non-aligned visitors like the Courier (male or female).
The Legion are not savages. They are clearly the most disciplined faction in the entire game, and follows orders without question. If they're ordered to protect visitors they will do so until their last breath. If higher-ups believe visitors are NCR spies and order their Legionnaires to gangrape, enslave and crucify them, they will follow that order without blinking. They are extreme, and behave more like machines than men. A military officer's dream.
 

As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top Bottom