Gothic 2 vs Gothic 3

[Orobis]

Gothic 3 vs Skyrim, which is worse and why?

 

[anvi]

Gothic 3. I never thought I would be called upon to think of a game worse than Skyrim, never even thought it would be possible, but it is. Gothic 3. They are the same inane open world crap but Gothic only has 1 class and it plays bad. Skyrim has many classes that all play bad, therefore it wins on quantity alone. It is a close call though because at least Gothic 3 isn't full of stupid NPC's babbling in that ridiculous Scandinavian accent.

 

[Morkar Left]

Gothic 3. I never thought I would be called upon to think of a game worse than Skyrim, never even thought it would be possible, but it is. Gothic 3. They are the same inane open world crap but Gothic only has 1 class and it plays bad. Skyrim has many classes that all play bad, therefore it wins on quantity alone. It is a close call though because at least Gothic 3 isn't full of stupid NPC's babbling in that ridiculous Scandinavian accent.

Are you on dope? At least have the decency to mention Oblivion...

 

[anvi]

Gothic 3. I never thought I would be called upon to think of a game worse than Skyrim, never even thought it would be possible, but it is. Gothic 3. They are the same inane open world crap but Gothic only has 1 class and it plays bad. Skyrim has many classes that all play bad, therefore it wins on quantity alone. It is a close call though because at least Gothic 3 isn't full of stupid NPC's babbling in that ridiculous Scandinavian accent.

Are you on dope? At least have the decency to mention Oblivion...

How is Oblivion relevant to a Skyrim vs Gothic 3 question? Also you are from Germany, your opinion on this is never not going to be biased.

 

[Maggot]

They are the same inane open world crap but Gothic only has 1 class and it plays bad

It's a classless system retard. Gothic has its faults but your complaints are stupid.

 

[Morkar Left]

Oblivion is better than Skyrim?

 

[sullynathan]

lets not kid ourselves here, in the long run Skyrim is better than Oblivion and Gothic 3.

 

[anvi]

They are the same inane open world crap but Gothic only has 1 class and it plays bad

It's a classless system retard. Gothic has its faults but your complaints are stupid.

Classless or not, there is only one build because there isn't content for anything else. Sure you can spend 1000 hours travelling the world to get enough mana regen to cast your 1 mage spell, but that doesn't make you a mage.

 

[anvi]

lets not kid ourselves here, in the long run Skyrim is better than Oblivion and Gothic 3.

You prefer it to Morrowind too, be honest.

 

[sullynathan]

 

[anvi]

 

[Haplo]

True. There are some things Skyrim does better, but Gothic 3 is the better game overall.

 

[anvi]

I also like things that are less popular to be hip.

 

[Junmarko]

Gothic 3 vs Skyrim, which is worse and why?

Skyrim is worse, because it doesn't have unintentional humour on this level.

 

[MrMarbles]

lets not kid ourselves here, in the long run Skyrim is better than Oblivion and Gothic 3.

I figured it was the other way around. The first hour of Skyrim is awesome, then after a while it starts to dawn on you that it is a hiking simulator with almost no depth. The first hour of G3 was painful, but after a while you start to get a feel for it.

Development of combat and magic skills is far superior in G3. That may be part of the lack of appeal, so much of the good stuff in G3 is gated behind hours of gameplay, while Skyrim jizzes the full experience in your face from the get-go. Skyrim does beat Oblivion, no argument there.

 

[sullynathan]

lets not kid ourselves here, in the long run Skyrim is better than Oblivion and Gothic 3.

I figured it was the other way around. The first hour of Skyrim is awesome, then after a while it starts to dawn on you that it is a hiking simulator with almost no depth. The first hour of G3 was painful, but after a while you start to get a feel for it.

Development of combat and magic skills is far superior in G3. That may be part of the lack of appeal, so much of the good stuff in G3 is gated behind hours of gameplay, while Skyrim jizzes the full experience in your face from the get-go. Skyrim does beat Oblivion, no argument there.

I don't think so. Gothic 3's quests are all the same which is a huge disappointment, even though the town liberation thing is cool, it gets to be too much and no longer fun.

 

[anvi]

Skyrim is shit but G3 and Oblivion are worse.

 

[huckc]

Gothic 3 vs Skyrim, which is worse and why?

Skyrim is worse, because it doesn't have unintentional humour on this level.

Should've just went with a howie scream.