That contradicts what several other sources have stated, which is that advisors will leave if you choose solutions which oppose their viewpoints. Nobody said 'except generals, those guys you can pick whatever'.
The decisions are broken down into +1 Happiness, Neutral, or -1 Happiness results. If you disagree with an adviser using Neutral options then you don't have to worry. It's only when you pick -1 Happiness results too many times that they will leave, and choosing +1 Happiness can balance that out.
And when I say Neutral, I mean "how much the adviser likes that idea" not the Neutral alignment.
I know that, I figured that a CHAOTIC EVIL person is going to disagree with Good/Lawful choices, that's why I'm not using him.
If there are no actual conflicts in the game that's not my fault, and I've got no way of knowing that besides meta-gaming.
Rerongar's card says he is 'hot-headed', that's not the kind of person you want in charge of a fucking Lawful Good kingdom's army. Add that to his CE alignment, there is no way he should be an option.
This discussion began with the assertion that the game gives you no choice on whether or not to use Amiri, because you need her to cover the General advisor position.
First someone said that that wasn't true because of another character (Kassil) who can be a general, but that character's existence in the game is based on an early decision that doesn't give you any indication that he's a general, nor does it provide the character's alignment, or the alignment any of the other options. So that was bullshit.
Now we're saying that is isn't true because it turns out that
actually this Chaotic Evil, hot-headed bastard is perfectly fine as a General for a Lawful Good kingdom. But that's bullshit too, because without meta-gaming, a player would have no idea that this was the case. You can't just change the goalposts and say
'oh well the game says that but actually he's fine, so you're not forced to use Amiri actually'.
So I repeat: the game (depending on story choices that you have no foresight on) forces you to use Amiri, it's not an option, you need her as a General in cases where you didn't pick Kassil and your kingdom is Lawful Good.