I must say one, graphics and gameplay feeling in this case are lot better on 50" tv in 4k while playing on Xbox one X. I have very good pc but experience is totally different, only shooting is better on pc, rest all goes for strong Microsoft console. No match. Im happy ive completed this game on my box first. Now im playing on pc [maxed graphics looks just "normal" ] only for mods and multiplayer shootings . But game looks MUCH WORSE than on xoxox [almost all maxed out and on ultra on my pc] , totally different experience, hard to even compare, graphics are just worse , sound is poor too. Games like this or gta only on console. Red dead is not designed to be experienced in corpo slave like posture near the desk, close to screen.
To experience full details of this game and it's nature , you should play on nothing less than 32" and higher plus sitting 3 or 4 metres from big screen in 4k and with fluid framerate. There is no point in playing this game on anything lower than 4k , you will just lost all details and beauty of this game. To fully understand level of details here, you must be able to notice them. And you could not on pc screen, even not on 30" like.
On pc its only shooter in western reality, on xoxox it is live western experience. Period. Im not comparing ps4 version as it looks like shit, but what you can expect from japanese crap for playing overpriced pokemons, go click your fucking starcraft you anime fucks.
This game is designed to be a high quality western movie and watching movies on pc sucks hard. You should play it as real cowboy , with freedom in your pants, glass of whisky in your hand, while watching action on your wall from comfort sofa and yelling on your women to bring more booze quicker while smoking your favorite cigarette .
This is not gaming for those faint of heart which click with eyes glued to to the screen . . . stop jokin. If you are pc working corporate slave, you will never understand games like this, you must be cowboy to play cowboy.
Not to mention pc ultra textures on rocks or body skin hurts eyes, its not even close to xboxox. I think no one will understand this more than other fellows who played this game in best version on the big part of their wall. Pc is not for games like this, this is experience not a game.
Play this for the first time on xbox one x on big, good tv and after that you can tell anything about this game.
Playing it on pc or ps4 is like a sin and it's against american way of life of every cowboy.