Dark Souls is a jrpg? I thought it is a western style rpg made by a japanese game studio. Now I probably can say hamburger made in Japan is japanese food or Rendang made in Japan might also be considered japanese food.
I would say that it is natural for the human mind to generalise and then near-instantly decide and disciminate based upon that generalisation ("Fast" thinking), just as naturally as it is to then rationalise and realise that that generalisation has "problems" and that it might be better to be more specific ("slow thinking"), leading to slicing and dicing in a slightly different (although not "necessarily definitively better") way.
The problems we then have is that if everything is unique, then nothing can be categorised, and hence in a moment of choice, we find cannot make a quick decision, as we cannot discriminate between choices "in time", good or evil or even just aesthetic taste of likes and dislikes. This inevitably leads to...
"You died"