Decline The new Thiaf game is MASSIVE decline - Eidos Forum Refugee Camp

I stand correct. The game is unplayable. Controls are fucked up, movement is weird, dialogues are stupid, levels are small, loading is permanent ... and it's basically a failure from every point of view.

This is without any exaggeration. It's probably one of the worst franchise rape ever and the entire studio should be closed.

 

And that is one of the things I really like about old Thief and even Dishonored. Both have that short sound effect/melody that plays when you get spotted. It's subtle and appropriate. But this horrid thing in nuThief is ugh...

 

It's not 1998 anymore, guys.

Clearly.

 

The heightened footfall sounds are for player feedback, not to simulate reality to the nth degree. I've snuck up on/past people in Timberland boots on various kinds of surfaces, little to no sound, but weight distribution is my feedback on whether I will succeed or not, and that kind of tangible feedback doesn't exist in games yet. Player feedback, ie game design, comes before realism.

If you spent a lot of your life in the wild, your feet would become like leather, just like indigenous peoples who live in rainforests. Some people, even moderns, rock climb barefoot. Shoes are a man-made solution to man-made problems (cities, glass, square edges). Garret is a soft-footed city boy and his profession dictates that he need be able to flee quickly over any terrain, so he has to make the compromise of foot protection over optimal silence. But let's not worship at the altar of modern innovation to make a point. There have been track teams in Mexico that run miles over bad terrain in nothing but hand-made straw sandals. We don't need modern fibers for nature.

 

What I mean is, there are many instances of NPC getting suspicious/investigating when you make e.g. sound crossing an hallway close to them, while they are fine with other NPCs (guards, servants) doing the same. Of course that's obvious gameification, but it might have been avoided if they e.g. call out regardless who passes, but are satisfied when the patrolling guard announces his presence by responding (probably using a password or such).
Then again, maybe that is the reason why they like to mutter so much while walking around...

 

movement sounds were a fun mechanic, regardless if it made sense or not. And it worked two ways, because while you had to take care what surface you were walking on, guards' footseps also added an element of tension, when lockpicking or carrying a body. It's very tense to hear a guard walking about, but not know where he is or if you'll run into him

 

Any good FMs yet?

 

I read about the ending branching before I played the game, and only played through it once ghosting every level to keep the 'chaos' score down. Apparently I got the best possible experience doing this. Alright game, but kind of sad that a console-influenced hack & slash version of Thief is the pinnacle of the genre these days.

 

Thiaf guard AI in action

 

Ugh it seems I mistook that for the sound that plays when you enter certain locations/parts of the level in Thief. There is no music when you get spotted.
It's about time I replayed those games.

So what I wanted to say is: I liked the subtle sound effect when entering certain locations in old Thief and a similar sound effect which plays in Dishonored when spotted.

 

So Thiaf guard AI is supposed to pretend it's black?

 

I had so much to live for... until I saw this video.

 

To be fair, guards will not follow you into pools even in old thief.

 

So someone compare this to what Squeenix did to the Hitman and DX franchises with Derpsalution and HR. Are we talking about the same levels of derpiness/mainstreaming?

 

I still don't get why the fuck is he walking with arms in front of him.

The problem with H:A is the same as with, I don't know, Hitman movie or first Judge Dredd movie - they tried to make it feel like Hitman is a hero. And then you had to punch Danny Trejo's insert in the world, so... yeah, fuck it.

 

Just add the mask and goth makeup and you've got nuCarrot

 

Human Revolution at least had a massive amount of fanservice and was set in the same universe. Thi4f shares nothing in common with the earlier games besides a handful of recycled character names.

 

More like



GARRETT CONFIRMED FOR ORLOK, 11/10.

 

What else if not yet another reference to a timeless classic. As if lack of jumping is not enough. BROS THE GAME IS A FUCKING TIME MACHINE TO 1993!

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hRtypnPFxJ0

My magnum opus.

 

Removing the floor from underneath something tends to result in it plummeting the fuck down.

Turns out the stealth genre isn't that much different.

That you can be told apart from guards by footsteps alone.

The day I will be able to fool guards with footstep noise by larping their knocked out buddy...

Actually this, but both Thief and Thiaf are city games.

 

Human Revolution was a well designed game with a decent story, really good world design and solid art direction, plus though it had its problems was still a good tribute to the original games.

I haven't played Thief but it seems like it doesn't really check most of those boxes. It kinda just looks dreary and boring to me, and this poor AI, weak story, and downplaying of actual thievery and stealth doesn't exactly make me interested to try it out.

 

The game seems to be doing well in Wapan.