Arcanoix
Scholar
- Joined
- Dec 12, 2008
- Messages
- 574
Inconsistency 1 -
In the beginning of the game, Geralt has a flashback of his death after Vernon Roche reveals to him that he was killed by a commoner with a pitchfork to the gut. Yennefer also died. In the first game, Zoltan Chivay brings this up and no such flash back occurs. Also Zoltan says (in his original dialogue in the first game) that Yennefer survived.
Inconsistency 2 -
During the First Fight with Letho, the Kingslayer remarks, "I'm a Witcher no more!" However - in the end he refers to himself as a "simple Witcher" who won an audience with the Emperor of Niilfgard. (sp?) Also - his only motivation for killing kings as an agent to the Empire was to bring back the School of the Viper with funding from the Emperor for completing his mission. If he is a Witcher no more, and a Kingslayer who serves himself, why does his only motivation stem from the Witcher school where he came to be? Sounds like "cognitive dissonance" but that's just me.
Inconsistency 3 -
During the first fight with Letho, the Kingslayer laments, "WHY DO YOU HOUND ME?" In the Epilogue Letho remarks, "I knew you wouldn't have stopped until you found me." Then why bother asking during the first fight?
Inconsistency 4 -
In the final conversation with Letho - Geralt remembers sacrificing himself to the Wild Hunt to save Yennefer. Weren't they both killed during that whole separate incident with the racist protesters - err - anti-mutant, anti-elf, anti-dwarf mob?
Inconsistency 5 -
Letho asks Geralt TWICE in the SAME conversation (before the first fight) if he "really [doesn't] remember". WHY ask a question to a man who appears aggravated by something, then during the second incidence of the same question, said man seems all calm and cool and shit? Geralt should have been like, "I said I was SICK OF THAT FUCKING QUESTION PUNK! SLICE!!!"
Inconsistency 6 -
Why is there concept art of the School of the Viper if we never get to go there? Production costs cut it out perhaps? Would've been better and cheaper to just license the Unreal Engine....
Inconsistency 7 -
The mighty Geralt doesn't know how to break through more shrubbery than a lost deer. Seriously, how many passages will be blocked by LEAVES and STICKS in future installments?
Inconsistency 8 -
Letho says in the Epilogue that he knows of only two other Witcher's from the School of the Viper that are on the Path. Wait - the anime flashbacks and shit only showed Serrit and Auckes. If the other 2 Witcher's weren't Kingslayer's like them, then WHO was the first assassin trying to kill Foltest?
Inconsistency 9 -
The assassin from the ending of the first game, upon close inspection, wears a Viper/Snake medallion (I pointed this out 3 or 4 years ago) and yet the snake medallion that Letho wears looks like two snakes coiled into each other.
Inconsistency 10 -
Why don't we ever bump into the other Witcher's from the School of the Wolf? You know, the ones from the first game? Didn't they go to the other Northern Kingdoms? What news from them?
Post your inconsistencies, maybe CDP:R will take a look? I doubt it but still, the questions remain unanswered....
In the beginning of the game, Geralt has a flashback of his death after Vernon Roche reveals to him that he was killed by a commoner with a pitchfork to the gut. Yennefer also died. In the first game, Zoltan Chivay brings this up and no such flash back occurs. Also Zoltan says (in his original dialogue in the first game) that Yennefer survived.
Inconsistency 2 -
During the First Fight with Letho, the Kingslayer remarks, "I'm a Witcher no more!" However - in the end he refers to himself as a "simple Witcher" who won an audience with the Emperor of Niilfgard. (sp?) Also - his only motivation for killing kings as an agent to the Empire was to bring back the School of the Viper with funding from the Emperor for completing his mission. If he is a Witcher no more, and a Kingslayer who serves himself, why does his only motivation stem from the Witcher school where he came to be? Sounds like "cognitive dissonance" but that's just me.
Inconsistency 3 -
During the first fight with Letho, the Kingslayer laments, "WHY DO YOU HOUND ME?" In the Epilogue Letho remarks, "I knew you wouldn't have stopped until you found me." Then why bother asking during the first fight?
Inconsistency 4 -
In the final conversation with Letho - Geralt remembers sacrificing himself to the Wild Hunt to save Yennefer. Weren't they both killed during that whole separate incident with the racist protesters - err - anti-mutant, anti-elf, anti-dwarf mob?
Inconsistency 5 -
Letho asks Geralt TWICE in the SAME conversation (before the first fight) if he "really [doesn't] remember". WHY ask a question to a man who appears aggravated by something, then during the second incidence of the same question, said man seems all calm and cool and shit? Geralt should have been like, "I said I was SICK OF THAT FUCKING QUESTION PUNK! SLICE!!!"
Inconsistency 6 -
Why is there concept art of the School of the Viper if we never get to go there? Production costs cut it out perhaps? Would've been better and cheaper to just license the Unreal Engine....
Inconsistency 7 -
The mighty Geralt doesn't know how to break through more shrubbery than a lost deer. Seriously, how many passages will be blocked by LEAVES and STICKS in future installments?
Inconsistency 8 -
Letho says in the Epilogue that he knows of only two other Witcher's from the School of the Viper that are on the Path. Wait - the anime flashbacks and shit only showed Serrit and Auckes. If the other 2 Witcher's weren't Kingslayer's like them, then WHO was the first assassin trying to kill Foltest?
Inconsistency 9 -
The assassin from the ending of the first game, upon close inspection, wears a Viper/Snake medallion (I pointed this out 3 or 4 years ago) and yet the snake medallion that Letho wears looks like two snakes coiled into each other.
Inconsistency 10 -
Why don't we ever bump into the other Witcher's from the School of the Wolf? You know, the ones from the first game? Didn't they go to the other Northern Kingdoms? What news from them?
Post your inconsistencies, maybe CDP:R will take a look? I doubt it but still, the questions remain unanswered....