Guys, calm your tits.
It's not news until Infinitron posts about it. When that happens, we can freak out.
It's not news until Infinitron posts about it. When that happens, we can freak out.
-
Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.
"This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.
From Software Elden Ring - From Software's new game with writing by GRRM
- Thread starter HoboForEternity
- Start date
Ivan
Arcane
Going to wait for official trailer. I want to feel the chills of an impending FROMSOFTWARE production
I just realized that this game might be Fromsoft's attempt at making their own Witcher 3, complete with colorful visuals, horse riding and shitty open world
Maybe it was they that bought the CDproject code on the deepweb.
Dark Souls 4 but open world® let's goooooo
I'll call it right now : this is the game of FromSoft fall from grace. Quote me later.
When it comes to game design today, open world is a flaw, not a feature.
I'll call it right now : this is the game of FromSoft fall from grace. Quote me later.
Pleonasm, my friend. That's the main issue with all series that went open world : at best it didn't change shit, at worst it sabotaged the game design.
When it comes to game design today, open world is a flaw, not a feature.
I wouldn't put it past From Software to be innovative and fresh-thinking with this as they were with the DS line. Higher chance of that than with most devs. All hope is not entirely lost.
But more likely, yes - it'll be their decline.
But more likely, yes - it'll be their decline.
DaS III was their decline.
ER is their chance to do something... different.
ER is their chance to do something... different.
Can it really be since Sekiro was one of their best games ?
Silverfish
Arbiter
- Joined
- Dec 4, 2019
- Messages
- 3,186
There's different kinds of decline, though. Dark Souls 3 wasn't From's Fallout 3, but it was their Brotherhood of Steel.
meanwhileInPoland
Arcane
- Joined
- Feb 13, 2011
- Messages
- 2,234
seems like stealth is confirmed as well. apparently those couple seconds long clips are from an year old trailer that got canned as FS thought it makes the game look too much like Dark Souls.
edit. 2nd one
cant see shit here
ITZ HABBENING
https://www.reddit.com/r/Eldenring/.../?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3
Last edited:
Implying there's such thing as "too much like Dark Souls".
To be honest after Bloodborne and Sekiro, going back to Dark Souls mechanically seems like a step backwards that I don't want to take and the only thing that seems to be different is the open world structure where you have mounted traversal and combat to accommodate the grander scale. If this is another victim of the open world of nothingness, it's really gonna suck because the level design in From Soft games are great.
I actually tend to like open world games, but it seems like it would be a pretty bad fit for a Souls-like if that's what they've been making.
On the other hand, if they made their set piece environments except scaled up so you could visit each part of the giant castles in places like Boletaria and Lordran, etc. that might be pretty cool. It would probably come at the cost of making everything less grand though. Part of why those things work is that they span into the background as these impossibly huge structures or as buildings on top of decrepit past buildings, etc. So once it's all traversible it breaks the illusion of how vast everything is.
On the other hand, if they made their set piece environments except scaled up so you could visit each part of the giant castles in places like Boletaria and Lordran, etc. that might be pretty cool. It would probably come at the cost of making everything less grand though. Part of why those things work is that they span into the background as these impossibly huge structures or as buildings on top of decrepit past buildings, etc. So once it's all traversible it breaks the illusion of how vast everything is.
Child of Malkav
Erudite
Guys, it's coming, it wasn't just a mass hallucination. It's real and it's here.
"Open world" is one of those things that you might think you want, but wiser developers shouldn't let you have (like God Mode. as an extreme and obvious example).
Unless it's a sim or an MMO. Although an MMO necessarily has to be quite "compressed" (with lots of "things" happening in close proximity) so although it might feel like a vritual world, it never truly feels like an open world.
A sim can be much less compressed, but at that point there's a cost/benefit trade-off with story. If you've got a story, then a simulationist open world is pointless to spend time on, and if you're making a proper simulationist open world, you probably won't have any time or energy or money left over to make a good story.
The perfect combination would in fact be a vast, simulationist type of open world with a story threading through it, with tons of procedural generation of dungeons and side-quests, which is kind of what Daggerfall tried to do. But I don't think tech is up to it even now. It would require really clever AI that's hyper-aware of, and can parse the contextual meaning of, player choices, so that it could channel you to the story in any number of potential ways on the fly, plus extremely sophisticated procedural generation. And for a bonus, procedurally generated intelligent responsese from NPCs with (for an added bonus) really top class text-to-speech based on top class actors' voices. Still another - what, 10, 20 years off?
Unless it's a sim or an MMO. Although an MMO necessarily has to be quite "compressed" (with lots of "things" happening in close proximity) so although it might feel like a vritual world, it never truly feels like an open world.
A sim can be much less compressed, but at that point there's a cost/benefit trade-off with story. If you've got a story, then a simulationist open world is pointless to spend time on, and if you're making a proper simulationist open world, you probably won't have any time or energy or money left over to make a good story.
The perfect combination would in fact be a vast, simulationist type of open world with a story threading through it, with tons of procedural generation of dungeons and side-quests, which is kind of what Daggerfall tried to do. But I don't think tech is up to it even now. It would require really clever AI that's hyper-aware of, and can parse the contextual meaning of, player choices, so that it could channel you to the story in any number of potential ways on the fly, plus extremely sophisticated procedural generation. And for a bonus, procedurally generated intelligent responsese from NPCs with (for an added bonus) really top class text-to-speech based on top class actors' voices. Still another - what, 10, 20 years off?
Hope there's something we're missing like the trick weapons or combat arts because the windup for those attacks look pretty damn slow. The rolls are slow looking too. Pretty hard to get excited for this after playing stuff like The Surge 2, Nioh, Sekiro and Bloodborne.
Last edited:
Miyazaki plz take my money
No, that's exactly how it should be. Dark Souls 3 going Bloodborne was one of the worst decisions FROM ever made.
Ivan
Arcane
MUST RESIST TEMPTATION
Ivan
Arcane
DS3 was a victory lap. It was the Metroid Prime 3 of the Souls series.
Sekrio has FromSoft's best boss fights.
Child of Malkav
Erudite
Yeah well it's not like we play these games for their atmosphere.
- Joined
- Apr 16, 2012
- Messages
- 9,008
As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.