Tacgnol
Shitlord
- Joined
- Oct 12, 2010
- Messages
- 1,871,750
If you want realism that's how it would be though. Having some armor, in general, is advantageous, unless dex fag would either try to run or grapple. And neither armored person would automatically be lame moron with no dex who is not also accurate and skillful.IIRC it was awful for light armour/dex based characters and amazing for martials in medium or heavy armour
A Fighter in AD&D is better at fighting than a Rogue. Because Fighters Fight. And Rogue has different things to do.
You can't shove realism into an RPG where you are unrealisticaly shoved into all situations in similar manner (only fighting).
Oh I agree, just a shame the alt system didn't work out well for both. You can't really fairly run it in a game where people are playing "light" classes.
There was a similar alt rule system for 3.5 iirc, though I think that also had the same issue of being really good for armoured martials and bad for everyone else.