Okay, regarding the challenge: Master Zhang has told us that we've got a year to prove that we're the best pugilist of our generation, and after the Fire Cult challenge we'll have six months remaining. However, this entire challenge depends entirely on Zhang's completely random whims; if we arrive in Maniac Island with an Emperor in tow, the man might be so insanely impressed by the deed that he might impart some new techniques and probably change the goals he set up for us initially. That being said, he'll probably change the goal to be something like "kill all the other greats, including me, with your hands tied in three years time for the Huashan summit" but it seems like there would be one hell of a reward in store for us from our Master if we somehow manage to pull off the insane task of kidnapping the Emperor and leaving him on Maniac Island. Which we won't, but on to that later.
We've arguably become progressively weaker since we started ZJ's challenge. We know that the representatives of other schools from our generation are either generally on par with our abilities, or exceed them. Most of our time has been spent recovering from our various follies.
Okay, so how will focusing entirely on improving our stealth abilities help that? If you want to keep up with our competition in terms of fighting skills, then it's best to focus on actually fighting. As for the other representatives, the only guy out there significantly better than us is BJ. Of course, over this time, you're right; Guo Fu and Yunzi could have surpassed us since we missed out on the opportunity to focus ourselves entirely on training, however I think that you're overestimating things slightly. That being said, I think it's usually smarter to overestimate competition than it is to underestimate it.
On the the choice: as fun as the 1C choice is, I just can't go with something that crazy and with that little margin for error. Yeah, it's important to plan for success, but we
will fuck this up, I'm telling you. I think I should remind everybody that we came up with this while intoxicated:
“I did think you were the sort that did anything that moved. Certainly the chambermaids were full of assorted tales as proof. Are those girls that unattractive to you? I thought they were rather fetching, myself.” Shun grins as he downs another cup of wine, his lips loosened by the drink.
I've had a lot of ideas that sounded great while I was drunk too! Something tells me that a sober Shun would have told us that this was a dumb idea. Plus, we're Shun's only real friend; that, combined with the fact that he doesn't actually want to kill his father, is making him look for a way out of the dilemma he's facing. Forget about it, you can't have things a 100% perfect and there is just way too much riding on this mission to try and make it even harder than it has to be.
However, knowing that this is Codex, a lot of people will be voting for Operation Immortal, even though it's (probably) going to be a disaster. If we do go for this, we have to forget about the challenge and set our skills towards completing this mission and facing this massive obstacle in front of us. For this mission, the main things we'll need are stealth and the ability to sniff out traps somehow. With one eye, that is going to be hard - even Yoriwaka's PER boost only gets us to 7, and we have absolutely no knowledge of traps whatsoever ourselves. Not being seen by anyone doesn't mean shit if you trigger a bunch of pressure plates on your way to the Emperor's chambers and end up dying.
But that's where our animal friends come in. The Emperor's chambers are bound to be extremely well-guarded, and if we have enough skill to be able to use some animals as decoys, we can make up for our complete lack of knowledge of traps and our mediocre PER stat. I just think that there are going to be more dangers around than simply being detected by the wrong people.
treave, would we be able to command animals in such a way?
BBA > CAB