My most likely scenario for how A1 will turn into surprise failure is that Bai Jiutian will turn out to have been holding back his qi to bait us into using Wuxiang Qiankun, and then he will simply immediately raise his qi to negate our Wuxiang Qiankun (can't use it on people who have as much qi as you do) at an opportune moment during the sword fight and in that moment when we are caught off-guard, Bai Jiutian fucks us up before we can recover.
The main point is that the moment Bai Jiutian raises his qi, Jing immediately misses his step and stumbles, then BJ fucks us up in that moment while we're off-balance. Mind, getting fucked up by BJ's sword sounds like a terrible idea.Wuxiang Qiankun tries to immitate his moves. If he has higher Qi, we cant immitate him and the battle proceeds as in A2. If he uses it once at a Qi level we can immitate, then we can use it too for some time. It doesnt matter if he uses more Qi on his consequent attacks.
I'm pretty sure A1 is the choice where Jing relies on Wuxiang Qiankun.I dont think WQS can be used against us unless we rely only on the skills we immitate.
The main point is that the moment Bai Jiutian raises his qi, Jing immediately misses his step and stumbles, then BJ fucks us up in that moment while we're off-balance. Mind, getting fucked up by BJ's sword sounds like a terrible idea.Wuxiang Qiankun tries to immitate his moves. If he has higher Qi, we cant immitate him and the battle proceeds as in A2. If he uses it once at a Qi level we can immitate, then we can use it too for some time. It doesnt matter if he uses more Qi on his consequent attacks.
I'm pretty sure A1 is the choice where Jing relies on Wuxiang Qiankun.I dont think WQS can be used against us unless we rely only on the skills we immitate.
The problem isn't that we instantly lose enemy moves. The problem is that while Jing is using Wuxiang Qiankun, he is focusing on mirroring Bai Jiutian. If Bai Jiutian immediately raises his qi, our mirroring will go wrong. In that moment where we botch it, that's all the opening Bai Jiutian needs, assuming that accidentally pushing our Wuxiang Qiankun beyond our level by itself won't mess us up. Sure, afterwards we can probably still copy the moves we saw earlier for a while but there shouldn't be an afterwards since the only time we'd really use Wuxiang Qiankun is during the sword-fight and messing up there = defeat.But with WQ we dont lose enemy moves immediately it happens after a few minutes.
Our Wuxiang Qiankun is at level 1 (complete beginner) right now. I have my doubts about Jing being so capable he would manage to pull back right at the right moment. It's not like Bai Jiutian flips a switch to instantly switch from Low Qi to incompatible High Qi either. He increases his qi and our Wuxiang Qiankun would copy him until that moment where we've gone beyond our abilities. Then, shit happens.Also Jing will FEEL he lost qi feedback and can't copycat anymore - so he should revert to his own repertoire at that moment.
Imagine Jing countering Bai's swordsmanship and tech with Huashan techniques... then he can't because Bai just raised his neigong. That kinda like charging into a gunfight and unloading your pistol at a enemy in body-armor, strong enough to deflect your bullets but not ALL of them... then your gun clicks empty and turns your magazine had half of its ammo dumped away before the fight by your enemy. You're left clutching a big piece of metal and plastic uselessely, your oponent, on the other hand, still has his weapons (gun/knife/hands).
You keep assuming that Jing will somehow fail cleanly. If Jing fails, he will be at least momentarily thrown off balance from misusing his neigong. For one brief moment, Jing's neigong fucks up and that's when Bai Jiutian strikes.
This won't happen when we're in close range because we wouldn't be using Wuxiang Qiankun there (that's when we use our own techs). He'd raise his neigong when we are copying his sword tech.
I think that the information about WQS manual being in Tufan is about as relevant as the information about Xiaoming Jiuyang manual being in China.What do you think, bros?