Yeah, except drawing his attention to us and the abilities that we shouldn't have is giving information we don't want to give away.
Now, who is there to say what abilities we should or should not have? It is unusual, yes, but that is not a crime in itself.
Given what you've said in the bold I don't understand why you still want to work with this guy when alternatives are available.
Because I deem him a better alternative?
I honestly was surprised that you are voting for this choice at all, given that it grants us no benefits other then calming our conscience, and that the risk it entails lies completely with us and not with the objects of the ritual.
Your secrets won't do you any good if you are dead. If the Guard is the one who can help us survive this, then he is the one I will be working with. Since the spell requires highly experienced mages, and barely a week have passed since we've mastered Heal (and the other girls don't even know it yet), I figured he would be our best bet.