That's probably what places like NeoGAF will think when looking at the list... "No Skyrim? List is shit."I see a distinct lack of Skyrim.
On the subject, I'm proud to say that there was not a single vote for Oblivion nor Fallout 3.

That's probably what places like NeoGAF will think when looking at the list... "No Skyrim? List is shit."I see a distinct lack of Skyrim.
There much worse games than Dragon Age: Origins on here.Move Morrowind to third place, remove Dragon Age from the list and replace it with ROA 3. Swap Bloodlines and Divine Divinity. Give The Secret World a pity place in the list of also-rans.
Welcome to RPGs. Alpha Protocol did some really creative things and deserves a spot. Certainly over something like Icewind Dale.It's a good game but it's not the best of anything. I just dislike such a flawed game being on a BEST ALL TIME thing.
I don't really care though.
Damn, I knew I forgot to vote for something.That's probably what places like NeoGAF will think when looking at the list... "No Skyrim? List is shit."I see a distinct lack of Skyrim.
On the subject, I'm proud to say that there was not a single vote for Oblivion nor Fallout 3.![]()
Then make a better RPGI wish Arcanum didn't make the top 5 every damn time. For all its good parts it is just too heavily weighed down with shit. Codex gonna Codex, I guess.
Do it faggot!Then make a better RPGI wish Arcanum didn't make the top 5 every damn time. For all its good parts it is just too heavily weighed down with shit. Codex gonna Codex, I guess.
(speaking of which, I haven't tried your latest build.)
The list has no integrity, stop being a drama queen.It is the best Troika game, and with Bloodlines getting sixth place there isn't much wriggle room there. Thus, Bloodlines's bloated rating threatens the integrity of the entire list.
The list has no integrity, stop being a drama queen.It is the best Troika game, and with Bloodlines getting sixth place there isn't much wriggle room there. Thus, Bloodlines's bloated rating threatens the integrity of the entire list.
It's no Realms of Arkania HD, that's for sure.45% of all voters gave points to Bloodlines
This is not the only weird thing. For example Risen (#52) is clearly superior to IceWind Dale (#22) (in before them apples and oranges), but the list is still a huge improvement over previous ones. Kudos to Felipepepe.Dragon Age beats Ultimas 4, 5, 7 and 7 part 2? *scratches head*
I don't know that derivative necessarily equates to inferior. Just because something is defining in its genre doesn't mean that everything that comes after it is inherently worse. I would have a hard time arguing that Ultima I is better than 7, for example.I have to say that it pains me to see some true genre defining classics overshadowed by newer, arguably derivative games.
As with most dichotomies on this list (KotOR I vs II, PST vs. Everything, etc etc) it depends on whether you're looking more for solid atmosphere and writing, or things being more solid from a 'game' perspective. The Codex tends to fall on the side of the former, but not always (Morrowind > Gothic 2, for example).Seriously... Baldur's Gate II better than Arcanum? Really? No.
This already happened last year: http://www.rpgcodex.net/content.php?id=8869So... The Holy Trinity™ has finally been upset.
Seriously... Baldur's Gate II better than Arcanum? Really? No.