To be fair he didn't state that other FPS have better AI. On a side note, I think that the bigger problem with making a good AI is design it in order to be fun or engaging. I see the modern shooter (CoD or 1886) and I see an average AI, just functional. Then I play Turok 2 and, despite it being smoke and mirrors, manages to surprise me.I replayed FEAR recently. It's an overrated game. The enemies die about as fast as those in Half-Life 2 and the damage they do is instantly negated by your tower of portable medkits. And then there's bullet-time, the awesum buttan in every game it's ever been in. Repetitive game (especially in terms of scares), all the entertainment comes from its flashiness, which is very cool indeed. But all that shit about teh best AI evar is actually just elaborate animation scripting. It's very good that it's there, but what is the AI even supposed to be doing that's so smart when it's stuck in a cramped hallway and I kill everyone in three seconds? This was on Hard, also.
Care to tell me which FPS have better AI and/or better shooting than F.E.A.R. I'd love to hear it. And I love to hear it cuz I will instantly play that game!!!!
FEAR can be smoke and mirrors too but it just works. Maybe the problem with these games is that today we play in a very aggressive way and AI just can't shine because it just doesn't have a chance. Blood cultists are a bigger challenge but that doesn't mean they have a good AI.