Putting the 'role' back in role-playing games since 2002.
Donate to Codex
Good Old Games
  • Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.

    "This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.

The Fall of Peter Molyneux

Infinitron

I post news
Staff Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
97,228
Codex Year of the Donut Serpent in the Staglands Dead State Divinity: Original Sin Project: Eternity Torment: Tides of Numenera Wasteland 2 Shadorwun: Hong Kong Divinity: Original Sin 2 A Beautifully Desolate Campaign Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire Pathfinder: Kingmaker Pathfinder: Wrath I'm very into cock and ball torture I helped put crap in Monomyth


:rage:
 
Joined
Dec 17, 2013
Messages
5,103
At this point, he has become a caricature of a scam artist to such a degree that it's hard to even get mad at his latest BS. It's more like, oh look at that cute little Molineaux, what crazy shenanigans is he up to now?
 
Joined
Mar 3, 2010
Messages
8,816
Location
Italy
FUCK OFF!
really, fuck off.
i truly wanted to believe that, then you shattered my hopes and dreams.
fuck off.
 

Zed Duke of Banville

Dungeon Master
Patron
Joined
Oct 3, 2015
Messages
11,756
Powermonger and the Populous series were good games. The last Peter Molyneux game I played was Populous II, a wise decision on my part.
 

LESS T_T

Arcane
Joined
Oct 5, 2012
Messages
13,582
Codex 2014
don't die posted a long interview with him: http://www.nodontdie.com/peter-molyneux/

I quote a part:

You know, the other problem is that -- what you've got to remember is that this is my excuse, if you like. The way I talk to those people is the way I talked this morning to the Godus team in this very room I'm talking in. That's with passion, and it's with belief, and it's excitement. Incredible excitement. I mean, I do have the most amazing job in the world. I mean, David, I get to think of the craziest, maddest, insanest idea and then I get to play it. [Laughs.] I mean, Jesus. How can Inot be incredibly excited?

And yes, I could have and maybe in hindsight I should have. I should have put that excitement put it in a box and I should have crafted it and melded it and gotten the message just right so when I spoke to people in the press it came out in the most politically correct way.

But that's not the way I'm built.

My solution to this is the best solution, I think: It's not to expose people to that excitement, because people will think it's a promise. They do. They think it's a promise of utopia, of gaming utopia.

When I was doing Fable 1, I said this one line early on: "We are making the best RPG game ever." And I said, "Of course, we're making it. Why would we not think we're making the best RPG ever? Why would we even start a project if we thought we were going to be make the tenth best RPG game ever?"

And that headline, "Fable Will be the Best RPG Game Ever" then dominated those headlines for a while and got me into an awful lot of trouble.

I just feel that, you know, I get ridiculously excited about the games I'm working on.

Just today, there's two things I got amazingly excited about. One is about this game I'm working on at the moment called The Trail, and there is Jamie and I -- Jamie's the other designer on the game -- we were in the room, and I was leaping all around the room because we built this new game mechanic. That is the most wonderful experience you could possibly have, is to have that feeling, that sensation. It's hard to describe what it feels like.

It's like true creating something out of nothing, which is wonderful, but I can understand that when people -- when that gets turned onto text on a page or even people hear my voice in a recording, they think, "Oh."

It becomes like a promise.

And when you're dealing with people's anticipations and you're dealing with what they hope and what they expect and what they can't wait to get their hands on -- you always have to exceed people's expectations, but if your voice or your press message has driven their expectations up into the stratosphere, it's very hard to exceed that.

So, you know, I think -- I have to take personal responsibility for the things I've said or the way I've said it. You know, if I just carried on and said, "I'm Peter Molyneux. I do say crazy things. Deal with it."

Then I think people would rightfully probably kill me or something. I don't know. But if I now change my approach and say, "I will talk about things in hindsight when you can play it. But I'm never going to talk about features or games that don't currently exist."

Then I think maybe that's a more responsible way because, very simply put is, you know, people just get tired of hearing this voice drone on about how excited he is about the next game and they're just gonna get tired and bored of it and I can totally understand that.

You know, I've always -- this is why the Rock, Paper, Shotgun article really hurt a lot. I've always tried to be completely honest with people. It may not come across that way because it can be an over-promise, but I've always tried to be completely honest about what I'm developing and why I'm developing and actually say things which have gotten me into trouble before now.

And you know, I don't want to stop talking about games I have made but I do want to stop talking about games that aren't yet finished.

You're taking the mature approach to this, which is you see it as a learning opportunity and you take ownership for your actions. But, you know, you are not in a vacuum here. Do you think -- even outside of yourself -- are you really saying the audience should be stay as excited and the media has a right to call you a pathological liar?

Well, the media and anyone in today's world has a right to call me anything they want.

[Laughs.]

How much that I take on myself and that influences me after the Rock, Paper, Shotgun article and the associated articles with it, it was a very, very tough time. I'll be absolutely honest with you. And, you know, I did question it for a while. I questioned my past and what I'd done. Of course this is always going to bring you to a place of self-analysis.

But I think the responsible place to do is to use that energy, that creative or negative or what be it, and just make a brilliant game. My revenge, if "revenge" is the right word, is simple: just make a great a game. Because that's the best revenge I could possibly have, is to make Godus into a great game and to make my next game a great game.

Because, at the end, that's the answer to everything, is to use that negativity just to make a unique and better game that I could have made because I can then turn around to people and say, "Okay, my message was wrong. I shouldn't have hyped it, whatever it was, but look at these games. They're good games, they're different, they're original. They're everything I want them to be."

That would, I think, be a wonderful place to be.

I don't mind. Absolutely, I don't mind that if Rock, Paper, Shotgun or Eurogamer or whoever it is turns around and said, "We recreated Peter Molyneux because of our negativity."

Because that's fine.

Because to a certain extent, that's true.

The Trail: Revenge of the Molynuex™
 

insukk

Augur
Patron
Joined
Dec 16, 2011
Messages
327
Codex 2012
And they still don't aknowledge that ol' Pete fucked young guy right in the ass with this Cube/Godus stuff. Also reading him is really tiresome because he is spewing the same nonesense all the time.
 

pippin

Guest
Peter MOlyneux understood the complex mechanics of farts in rpgs. He's the unsung hero of the genre.
 
Joined
Apr 3, 2006
Messages
1,386
My revenge, if "revenge" is the right word, is simple: just make a great a game.
I guess in Pete's world revenge is a dish best served never. InB4 Cleve is is hired as productivity manager for Godus development.
 

Infinitron

I post news
Staff Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
97,228
Codex Year of the Donut Serpent in the Staglands Dead State Divinity: Original Sin Project: Eternity Torment: Tides of Numenera Wasteland 2 Shadorwun: Hong Kong Divinity: Original Sin 2 A Beautifully Desolate Campaign Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire Pathfinder: Kingmaker Pathfinder: Wrath I'm very into cock and ball torture I helped put crap in Monomyth
With the release of Godus Wars, Pete has done a new interview with Eurogamer: http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2016-01-22-it-was-tempting-to-retire

"It was tempting to retire…"
After his self-imposed press exile, Peter Molyneux returns in an exclusive Eurogamer interview.

jpg


Peter Molyneux has changed. He's a new man with a new plan, after what he tells me was the most difficult year of his career.

Almost one year ago, things changed forever for Peter Molyneux, his studio 22cans and his controversial game Godus. In a week he'll never forget, Eurogamer revealed the plight of Bryan Henderson, the Scot who won mobile game Curiosity: What's Inside the Cube? but never received his prize. Then, a couple of days later, PC game website Rock, Paper Shotgunpublished an interview with Molyneux that sent shockwaves throughout the industry. It began with a question: "Do you think that you're a pathological liar?"

Molyneux had, for years really, come under fire for overpromising and under delivering, but Godus was the straw that broke the camel's back. Godus, a crowdfunded game billed as Populous for the next generation, had in many players' eyes turned out to be the opposite. At best it was a mildly interesting god game that involved way too much clicking. At worst it was a cynical cash grab designed first for the free-to-play, microtransaction fuelled mobile market, with PC consigned to an afterthought.

Then radio silence - and no updates for months on end. 22cans' communication failures, amid growing resentment over Godus and Peter's broken promises, came to a head that week. No longer protected by an army of public relations people from previous employer Microsoft, Molyneux was exposed, and he was beaten to a pulp.

"It was one of the most bruising moments of my life," Molyneux tells me. "My world changed after that interview."

jpg

Godus Wars is the first meaningful update to Godus in months.

We're sat inside a meeting room in 22cans' Guildford office. Through the window I see a sign for Lionhead, the Microsoft-owned creator of Fable. One of its buildings is, literally, a stone's throw away.

"That was the point where I said, this is just not going to work. To be called a pathological liar, which he said at the start... it's just not going to work, because how do you ever gain people's trust and belief after a journalist says that?"

On Friday, 13th February 2015, Molyneux told The Guardian he would not speak to the press again. I remember reading that piece thinking, yeah, right. If I know anything about Peter Molyneux, it's that he loves talking about what he's working on. You see a glint in his eye as he does it. Molyneux's excitement at the potential of his own ideas often over-spills into the dictaphones of gleeful journalists - often to the dismay of the developers who work under the legendary British designer. He has a childlike urge to say things he probably shouldn't, promise features that are, at the time, little more than ideas in his head. He can't help himself.

Well, much to my surprise, Molyneux remained true to his word. He has not gone on the record with any press in almost a year since the RPS interview was published.

"That interview started just like any other interview," Molyneux recalls. "You know, we'd like a word with you about Godus. So the whole of the interview was just a shock. And then afterwards, it was a really tough couple of days.

"You can't afford the luxury of just going in the corner and sobbing a bit because you've got an entire team of people who are just looking at you and saying, right, what does this mean? Does this mean the end of the company? Does it mean the end of you? What does it mean?"

It was indeed the end for some 22cans staff, I understand. Last year the studio endured an exile of sorts as staff grew bored of working on Godus, a game everyone, it seemed, hated. Development felt like a thankless task. People were, understandably, worried about their CVs, about potentially tarnished careers, and left the troubled Molyneux behind. For a studio of fewer than 30 people, it was an uncertain time.

After the RPS interview went live, Molyneux reacted emotionally.

"It was tempting to retire," he reveals. "Many of my counterparts from the late eighties have sat back and retired and left. I had always said this is my life and my passion, other than my family. That was a knife-edge decision."

But Molyneux didn't retire. Instead, he came up with a plan that involved ditching the press and getting back doing what he'd done during the Bullfrog days on games such as Populous and Dungeon Keeper.

"The moment that made the difference to me was when I said, what am I going to do with all this extra time? And how am I going to solve this problem, if I think of this as a problem rather than emotionally react to it, which is the tempting thing to do? The solution to the problem is to do a great game rather than talk about doing a great game. Let's put those two things together. That countered any childish feelings of saying, oh fuck it then I'm not going to do anything again.

"I recognise those in myself. I recognise when I put that phone down I felt like giving up. Whenever you have one of those big reactions to anything in life, it is always that child inside of you who comes up and says, well, fuck it then.

"I had the chance to stand back and I tried to get to the core of what that journalist was saying, which was, you're over promising and under delivering. What's the solution? Here, a year later, is the solution."

jpg

The solution is Godus Wars, a real-time strategy spin on the original Godus that's out now on Steam as an Early Access title. It's a free update for Godus owners, but you can buy it separately (for £10.99 you get Godus and Godus Wars). Right now, Godus Wars is a basic, player versus computer mode that charges you with conquering the world and battling rival gods for control over continents. Like so many games right now, a card system is included. Cards are used for God Powers, but you need to build up Belief as you're playing to use them.

The idea is Godus Wars paves the way for multiplayer, which will then lead to the God of Gods feature that, Molyneux promised, would feature Bryan Henderson. Henderson, by the way, is one of the deities in Godus Wars. You'll encounter him late game.

Molyneux worked as a coder and designer on Godus Wars, a shift in role enabled by last year's arrival of new CEO Simon Phillips. Phillips takes care of the business side of things, leaving Molyneux to get his hands dirty with programming.

All this, then, after the RPS interview.

"My strategy is this: you can't say anything to prove I'm not a liar," Molyneux says. "The only thing I can do is hunker down and strip myself back to what I really am, which is someone who just loves what he does with a passion that is often misinterpreted by people. And to stop being a spokesman, stop being a person journalists phone up when there's a new piece of hardware out, or when there's a new monetisation technique out, and just be a programmer and a designer. That happened within that 24 hour period after that interview.

"After a couple of days I came up with this simple strategy: I would just be a coder and a designer, and I would talk to the press perhaps about something I had done and had released, but not talk to the press about what I am doing, because that is clearly not working, and redefine my relationship with those people."

Molyneux's new approach was inspired by Bill Gates. Molyneux tells me of a meeting he attended, while working for Microsoft, in which Gates, frustrated at a lack of progress on a piece of software, declared he would go home and fix the problem himself that night.

"I use that all the time," Molyneux says with a smirk. During the development of Godus Wars Molyneux fixed the occasional bug, tweaked design and added his own personal touch to this and that. For example, spin the Godus Wars globe too fast and you'll hear your followers scream. That was Molyneux. Win a continent and your deity will shoot lasers out of its eyes, destroying the enemy god. That, too, was Molyneux.

jpg

The Godus Wars globe.

I've played Godus Wars for an hour or so. Early game, at least, it's an incredibly simple experience, with little depth to it. You begin by creating a base, building up Belief as your little people construct huts and, on higher ground, more elaborate buildings. You pump out archer units as you sculpt the land, dragging the mouse cursor to flatten or raise the landscape. All the while your computer-controlled opponent is doing the same thing. Eventually you create enough units to form an army, and attack.

This plays out amid the collection of cards. You gain a new card with each victory, building a deck of God Powers you can pick from before battles. I can see the potential, here, for a somewhat interesting layer of strategy: you're limited to taking four cards into battle, so at higher difficulty you'll need to pick your loadout carefully.

Then there's the tombola, which spins once the player and the computer have declared their hand before a match. The tombola adds a modifier. Examples I saw include cheaper God Powers, more expensive God Powers, and, most interesting of all, no sculpting.

Sculpting is key. Early game, I did little more than flatten land so my followers could create more buildings, thus generating more Belief. But higher ground gives armies an advantage over enemies positioned on lower ground, so late game you'll be creating hilltops on the fly in order to get an edge in combat, and messing with the land your enemy's troops march on.

Godus Wars is brutally simple, but it's a step in the right direction for a game most had suspected 22cans had abandoned. And, Molyneux insists, Godus Wars is PC first. There's no mobile version in active development, he says. Is it all too little, too late? Perhaps. But in a sign Molyneux might have learned his lesson, he's realistic when describing Godus Wars' ambition. More realistic than I've ever known him to be about anything he's ever worked on.

"Is it like a Call of Duty 3? No, it's not. It's a pure and simple game. For me, I find RTS' impenetrable at the moment. They're tweaked toward an audience which is hyper RTS. This is just pure and simple. You make a fucking big army and you go out and just fuck the other side. There's a pleasure and a delight in that and that is multiplied by the Powers.

"It's not designed or meant to be the next StarCraft 3. But it is something which is pure and simple, and I think in that simplicity and purity it is unique, especially when you have the sculpting. Later on in the game that becomes much more strategic and important when you can put units on top of hills and they defend those hills. It's charming and interesting.

"This is obviously something that's not a little patch. It's a game-changing update. I think it's addictive enough just to have that thought, I'll just do one more map, I'll just get one more card, I'll just beat this one continent.

"But I'm not portraying this as the greatest game of all time. It's charming. It's lovely. I loved playing it. I loved working on it. And that's what it is."

Peter, you've changed, I say.

"We haven't talked about The Trail yet!"

The new Molyneux will only talk to the press about something people can play there and then, he insists. Our interview takes place a week before 22cans releases Godus Wars. I'm playing it. It's out now. The new Molyneux is off to a good start.

jpg

Bryan Henderson still hasn't received any money from 22cans.

But what of Bryan Henderson, the god who Peter Molyneux forgot? Worryingly, he still has yet to receive any money from 22cans, which maintains the Scot's role as God of Gods will have to wait until the feature is released. But, Molyneux says, with the release of Godus Wars, there is now a clear path to multiplayer and Bryan's involvement in the game. There is no timeframe for all this happening, however. 22cans won't even commit to a 2016 launch when I press.

Henderson tells me that after Eurogamer's article was published last year, 22cans started emailing him with updates on Godus. They, perhaps, went a little bit overboard.

"It was every week," Bryan tells me over Skype. "And they were giving me so much information I didn't even need. It was like they were responding to how little they gave me before, and put it to the complete opposite extreme, and gave me all this information and updates every week. I said, just tell me what I need to know when you feel like you need to tell me."

During this time 22cans asked Bryan whether he'd be interested in making music for an upcoming documentary on the studio. He politely declined, citing mounting college work.

Then, four months of silence, until last month, when 22cans got in touch with Bryan again to reveal the upcoming launch of Godus Wars. He gave his blessing to appear in the game as a deity. The impression I get from Bryan, though, is one of indifference.

"I'm just going to be completely straight," he says. "To be perfectly honest, I'm almost past the point of caring about this whole thing, you know? It's just been a complete balls up, to be frank. I'm just going to ask them, how many of you are actually still passionate about this? I'd rather they did it with interest in it, or just didn't do it all all, you know? But we'll see when I talk to them."

So, how serious is 22cans about Godus now? 11 people have worked on Godus Wars, I'm told, which is a higher number than I expected. Molyneux, having familiarised himself with the game engine Unity, got stuck in alongside testers and designers and all the rest. Molyneux sounds committed to the game. There is a plan: Godus Wars first, then multiplayer, then God of Gods. The whole thing will need to make a certain amount of money for 22cans to continue development, as you'd expect, but, apparently, this "threshold" is low enough as to be realistic. We're talking tens of thousands of sales, here, not hundreds of thousands.

jpg

Godus Wars development continues alongside The Trail, 22cans' next game.

And then there's The Trail, 22cans' next game, which Molyneux won't talk about until he can show it.

"If they offer me a role in this game, I'm just going be like, no, come on," Bryan says with a laugh.

But, if 22cans offers Bryan a lump sum and calls Godus quits, he'd take it - despite losing out on being the God of Gods.

"I'm not crazy in love with the game anyway," he says. "And I don't think a lot of people are. If they wanted to do it that way, I wouldn't mind. Why not?"

Molyneux and 22cans is well aware of the negativity surrounding Godus. It knows it faces an uphill battle to regain customers' trust after the events of last year. The brutal truth is that Molyneux's reputation may never fully recover from the beating it suffered last year.

But now, Molyneux looks and sounds in a much better place now than he was a year ago.

"In one sense that event happening has made me a far happier person really, because not being exposed to the public, getting all that time back and just realising I didn't have to say, okay, the coding part of my life is over now, it's done, has been incredibly liberating," he says.

"I can now do the most ridiculous things. It's almost as if I feel like the time before was like painting a picture with one hand tied behind your back. You can paint the picture, but you often need both your hands to paint the picture. Now I feel the hand is untied."

Was that week in 2015, then, a good thing?

"I think it was a good thing, and I think it was destined to happen," Molyneux says.

"When you've got someone sticking his head up over the parapet, it's fine. But then you could see my relationship with the press just getting worse and worse and worse. You can talk all the press all you like, but talk about things you've done, not things you're going to do, because that doesn't work.

"Last year was a horrible year. Going through all that shit. If you want to look at the view from the top of the mountain you've got to climb it. The harder the climb, the better the view."

Some will baulk at all of this, of course, at the new Molyneux, at Godus Wars and 22cans and everything it stands for. And, I'm sure, some will call Molyneux a liar once again for breaking his promise not to talk with press ever again. I can see the comments now, and I put them to Molyneux.

"I've always talked to the press as a designer, and I think fundamentally that is a bit of a problem," he explains.

"A lot of the time the press are used to talking to people who really, carefully think through everything they say and probably have rehearsed it and gone through it with a fine-tooth comb to check for things. Whereas with me it just comes out. Sometimes it comes out with what I'm thinking at that particular moment. And sometimes it comes out about something I've been thinking about for a long time. That form of interview I really feel has had its day. It's certainly had its day for me. And so the idea of me hyping up a game, or talking about a game before it's available to the public, I just don't think it's going to work ever again.

"This interview does not mean me being back in the press," he counters. "I don't have time to be honest with you. I'd much rather keep hunkered down."

And yet, the old Molyneux, the one that got him into so much trouble in the first place, the one that talks about acorns and trees and dogs and connected worlds and what's inside the cube, is still there, bursting to get out, fighting against an almost uncontrollable urge to shout from the rooftops: I'm going to change the world with my video games!

"We're working on another project called The Trail," Molyneux says. "I'm not going to talk about that at all because this whole thing about me over-promising got so caustic that it actually worked as a negative. My shoulders are fairly broad and you can send me death threats or whatever you like. It's the team that hurt me more than anything else - the feelings people had here when they saw the press.

"We're not talking about The Trail at all. I'll only talk about it when it's released," he says.

You have announced it though, I counter.

"If I talked about it you would see exactly the person you recognised. I would be promising you, I would be shouting about it. When we launch it in whatever guise we launch it, I'll happily talk about it. It's almost an impossible urge for me... I did some coding on The Trail as well..."
 

Bumvelcrow

Somewhat interesting
Patron
Dumbfuck
Joined
Nov 17, 2012
Messages
1,867,060
Location
Over the hills and far away
Codex 2013 Codex 2014 Make the Codex Great Again! Strap Yourselves In
With the release of Godus Wars, Pete has done a new interview with Eurogamer: http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2016-01-22-it-was-tempting-to-retire

He has a lot of baggage to get rid of, doesn't he? But it sounds like he's off to a good start. Shutting up and designing games is the best way of restoring some of his shredded reputation, and I will always have a soft spot for Populous.

I would love for a repeat interview with RPS once The Trail is released just to clear the air and see if he's really learned his lesson.

This Godus fiasco was just the culmination of years of snake oil selling and there were a lot of people eager to see him fall.
 

taxalot

I'm a spicy fellow.
Patron
Joined
Oct 28, 2010
Messages
9,613
Location
Your wallet.
Codex 2013 PC RPG Website of the Year, 2015
Incredibly, Peter Molineux couldn't hold his promise of retiring either.

Is he a pathological liar or what :smug:
 

Zarniwoop

TESTOSTERONIC As Fuck™
Patron
Joined
Nov 29, 2010
Messages
18,646
Shadorwun: Hong Kong
Truly a master prankster. If he ever gets bored sitting on his piles of ill-gotten gains, he could always become a Codex admin.
 

Dux

Arcane
Joined
May 26, 2016
Messages
635
Location
Sweden
The whole thing about smacking your pet around in B&W was a bit odd. I never really thought about it back in the day but now it's a little disturbing. I mean you are basically kicking the living shit out of it just to teach it how to behave. Is this perchance a window into warped psyche of one Peter Molyneux? Who really gives a shit at this point.

It was fun casting fireballs at the peasants, though, and flinging unkillable hermits across the map.
 

As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top Bottom