I never said Fallout 4 is better than Skyrim. I'm saying it's not a shooter, because it's not.
In shooters, the focus is always on the combat. If you're not fighting, you're leading up to a fight or recovering from one. In shooters, there are generally very few areas you can walk in without being harassed almost immediately. In games like Fallout 4 and Skyrim, you can wander around (if you're relatively careful) for hours, just collecting shit, looking at shit, talking to dumb NPC's, and completing "quests". Does that sound like a shooter to you?
Some of the examples you provided are not strictly shooters, such as STALKER. Even the Far Cry series blurs the lines.
It's not just me saying Fallout 4 is a shooter. Read any of the 10/10 reviews by users on metacritic.
Common positives from Page 1 only:
The gun modding system is by far the best addition to the series
Gun play is vastly improved to give the game a good weapon handling feeling
The gun-play is nice the graphics are good
Every gun has a unique feeling and purpose and everything functions so fluidly
Guns n' more bullets: Shooting is more playable
Your guns no longer break
Gunplay is great and makes combat in the wasteland feel very visceral
The gunplay feels nice and tight
The gun-play has improved a ton, and you don't need to rely as heavily on V.A.T.S. Some might argue that it's dumbed down and is Call of Duty shooting.
In my limited time playing it and discussions with others - I don't think it is better than the previous incarnations as hiking simulators. I don't know if the map is smaller or if Bethesda packed more stuff in. Part of the enjoyment of F3 and New Vegas and even Skyrim was to walk on to that next mountain, road or town. It takes a while. You get time to ponder and reflect stuff. Real life or even in-game ponderings. Time to look at your character and plan what to do.
I think Bethesda dumbed this crap down to accommodate console retards who only know how to aim and shoot. There is no time for musings. No thinking time. There is no lone traveler here.
Apart from the DIRE modding aspect and the unexplained Sim Farm - isn't the rest of your time just shooting stuff?
Saying all that, I still want to buy this game. Maybe when it is fixed by Bethesda or the excellent modders. Maybe buy it when it is five pounds like New Vegas is now.
I could not stop playing the previous incarnations.
This one - I just like reading posts from people that like it - and trying to understand why.