Sykar
Arcane
Well, at least SHE gets a trial. You know, real justice. You'd deny that of everyone else in town. Eh, it's a game and as such, you only get two choices, but look at what happens if you do side with the town: then you see her true evil side. She curses everyone! Is killing her the lesser evil, or the greater evil?
A guy rapes a girl and she kills herself (iirc). Should I murder him, without trial? He doesn't deny it, but he is repentant.
Odo or whatever may or may not have killed his brother (but I never really gathered all that much evidence on this one) should he die too? Maybe the Witch *was* controlling him with that puppet? From Geralt's standpoint, Odo was on the bubble leaning towards full exoneration. There was a drinking contest with Odo or something that I am still not certain I did right, because I didn't find anything from that. Either way, I guess he deserves to die too.
The Reverend I did find evidence of his crimes, but again, killing him would lead to chaos. He is a respected leader and all.
I'll be honest: I was so negligent with my investigation of all three "prime evils" in town, technically from Geralt's standpoint, she was probably the most guilty of all. Either way, the town ends up a barren wasteland so there really isn't all that much C&C here. I was hoping by killing her, I'd save the children of the village and it's regular Joe citizens. No such luck.
Are you kidding me?! Trial? By these cowards who gang up on one god damn woman? Who are the main reason the Beast got lose in the first place?
Odo? Exoneration? Did you actually pay attention what happened? Do you know what an Echniops is? Did you not take the hint with the dog mourning it's dead and buried master?
Killing him would lead to chaos? Says who? You think they can't find a quack who can spout religious nonsense all day long? Rofl
Yeah, YOU were negligent and helped rapists, murderers and two faced liars to get their way and bury their sin. Grats.