Visit our sponsors! (or click here and disable ads)
Realism vs. What Designers Care About
Editorial - posted by VentilatorOfDoom on Sat 28 August 2010, 11:54:25Tags: Obsidian Entertainment
..., Verisimilitude, and the Responsibility of Expectations. Obsidian's Nathaniel Chapman ponders the issue.
Something that seems to frequently come up when discussing the design of a game system is whether or not some aspect of that system adheres to reality. Or, more precisely, whether the outcomes of that system accurately simulate the results that the person making the argument expects, based on their particular interpretation of reality.
Generally, these arguments come from players, or from non-designers, or less experienced designers, and will take the form of, "But XXXX isn't realistic!" or "Realistically, YYYY should happen instead". And, frequently, experienced game designers will turn around and say "Who cares?" and merrily go on their way designing an "unrealistic" system.
I wanted to give a quick explanation of why this is, explain what role I see realism as having in game design, and then provide a bit of a defense of "realism" as it relates to something I call the "responsibility of expectations" that is placed on any game design.
Spotted at: RPGWatch