Putting the 'role' back in role-playing games since 2002.
Donate to Codex
Good Old Games
  • Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.

    "This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.

Arcanum review

Zhirzzh

Scholar
Joined
Nov 24, 2007
Messages
191
I wrote a review of Arcanum on another forum, and thought I would post it here:

As I'm doing an ironman playthrough of Arcanum now, I might as well review it. Minor spoilers up to Tarant (third area). Review may also contain some general concepts that will not be revealed until Dernholm (4th area)

Arcanum: of Steamworks and Magick Obscoura 85/100
Arcanum is my favorite CRPG, but is so flawed that I can't see my way to giving it a higher score.

Arcanum is set in a tolkienesque world undergoing an industrial revolution. Magick and technology have difficulty existing together, as magick breaks and warps natural law and technology reinforces it. Strong magick will cause technology to fail, while complex machinery will make a powerful mage violently ill. Magick had largely dominated technology, with the exception of the Dwarves who keep largely to themselves, but with the introduction of the steam engine by Gilbert Bates (yes, I know, but there is really very little fourth wall breakage in the game) technology begins a rapid accent that soon has the technological city state of Tarant and it's newly founded empire, The Unified Kingdom, reigning ascendant over it's more magickal neighbor Cumbria. While Cumbria is clearly in decline in all areas, Tarant is not so clear cut. Much like the real world at the time, there is a very wide gap between the rich industrialists, who send you to rob eleven tombs so they can outdo their neighbors in pretentious displays of wealth, and the factory workers, poor orcs who are legally prohibited from forming unions. Even your main quest giver in the city, while overall a decent fellow, comments that his workers conditions are almost humane, and will become furious if you press the matter any further. The world is brilliantly realized and is one of the major strong points of the game.

The dialog is exceptionally well written, in a vaguely Victorian style that also acknowledges the fact that the lower classes did not speak in the style of Jane Austen and other writers of the period. While the game does have some one dimensional NPCs this can be forgiven, due to the brilliance of the writing and how well the dialog fits the period. Frequently even said NPCs feel deeper than they actually are, due to the brilliance of the writing.

Upon opening the character creation screen, you will be presented with a great many possibilities. After choosing your name; your race, which will affect your stats and how NPCs react to you; and your background -are you a bookworm, technophobic, autistic, or even an insane asylum escapee?- you will be taken to the stat screen. The game's system unifies attributes, skills, technological disciplines, and magickal collages into a single point based system. Nothing costs more than one point. Throughout the game you will receive 60 skill points for leveling up (one per level, two every fifth), for a total of 65. This system allows you to build very diverse characters, that can do multiple things well or 1 thing incredibly well. There are 8 attributes (starting at 8 and capping at 20), of which, Beauty and Perception will be dump stats in most builds (perception is needed for ranged builds).

There are 16 skills (4 types of skills with 4 skills each) that can only be increased if you meet attribute requirements. Besides raising a skill with your character points, you can also receive training. There are 3 levels of training. There will be several people in each town to give you apprentice training for a modest fee. Only a few people in the game can train you to be an expert, in exchange for a fairly large fee. There is only one master of each skill. While the other levels can be purchased, most masters will only train you in exchange for doing a quest. Each level of training will give you a special power. A repair master can repair broken items, while a melee apprentice gets plus five to the speed of all weapons.

The combat skills are all based on your dexterity and are fairly generic, with the notable exception of throwing which, in a notable departure from tradition, is not only viable but actually a decent way for a technologist to play. The thieving skills, based on dexterity or perception, are completely traditional, although Pick Lock is under a different skill set. The social skills are based on several different attributes. Gambling and Haggle are of questionable use as, by the middle of the game, you will have too much money to be very worried about the prices you're getting on items, and even how many items you can outright win at dice. Heal, while not a bad skill for a player with a large party, is underpowered, both compared to other skills and to magickal healing. Persuasion, by far the most useful, is fairly generic, opening new dialog options. The technological skill set, while the most uniquely organized, consists of largely generic skills, from Pick Lock to Firearms, the only one worth mentioning separately is repair which I will come back to later. It only takes 5 points to max a skill, but you will need a very high rank in the attribute it is based on to do so.

Then we have the Magickal colleges and the technological disciplines. Technological Disciplines are based on combining 2 items to make a new one, and are divided into 16 disciplines such as electricity and chemistry. You can only purchase a level in a discipline if you meet an intelligence requirement and have all previous tiers. Each level you purchase gives you a schematic which will allow you to make an item; it will also give you points in that discipline which will make you less likely to fail when making items using schematics that can be found throughout the game(you can also buy books that will give you points in that discipline). The 32 Magickal Colleges are much more straightforward, spells are divided into tiers, and in order to purchase one you must both have all previous tiers in that collage and a minimum of willpower. There are some balance issues there, but I'll come back to that a bit later.

At the start of the game you are in the zeppelin, IFS Zephyr, traveling over a mountain range. The zeppelin is shot at by mysterious flying craft piloted by ogres, and crashes in a mountain range. You and a gnome are the only survivors, but the gnome is clearly not long for this world. The dying gnome gives you a ring bearing the imprint of P. Schuler & Sons. He tells you to, “Find the boy”, to tell him that, “they had no choice” and that, horrible things were done to them. At this point he dies, and your first party member, Virgil, comes along. Apparently the zeppelin crash and your survival of it appears to fulfill a Panarii prophecy, which would make you a reincarnation of the elf Nasrudin, and would also set you up for a climatic showdown with the forces of evil. After fruitlessly searching the crash site for survivors; you attempt to leave the canyon. While leaving, you are confronted by an elf asking about the crash. Virgil will tell you that he believes that the elf’s motives are less than pure. Virgil’s judgment in this matter is at least mildly compromised, as he is somewhat racist (you won’t know that at this part of the game unless you play a race he doesn’t like), although there are no signs that he is prejudiced against elves. Virgil will ask to be allowed to handle the conversation. If you let him he’ll scare the elf off; if you don’t you’ll have to fight the elf. If you kill the elf and search the body you will find an amulet of the Molochean hand. After speculating about why they want to kill you, you can move on to the first town: Shrouded Hills. While the plot sounds very cliché now, it gets much better. I can't describe it too much without giving things away, though I can say that one of the major mysteries of the game is whether you actually are Nasrudin’s reincarnation.

While the games story follows a very linear path, you can take a vast multitude of paths to get there. There are multiple solutions to every major quest until around the last third of the game. For example, in the first town in the game, you need to clear a gate of thieves to cross a bridge. If you’re a combat character, you can simply kill them. If you’re a fighter who isn't as strong but is charismatic, you can get a half ogre named Sog Mead Mug to join your party and help you kill the thieves. If you’re intelligent and persuasive you can even convince him that you represent a thief’s guild, not only will he leave, he'll give you 200 gold in reparations for violating your territory. You can even skip the last boss fight, if your have maxed Intelligence and Persuasion. While in Fallout, which was also known for this, you simply demonstrated a simple flaw in the boss's plan; in Arcanum, you can engage in a philosophical debate with the boss, and convince him that his plan is morally wrong.

You control only your own character, but can accumulate a party that you can give orders to. You may have one part member for every 4 charisma points you have, and may have an additional follower if you have an expert rank in persuasion. Summoning mages can also summon a familiar, as well as various monsters that will behave as party members until you dismiss them. Unless you are a persuasion master, characters that have opposing moral alignments to yours won't join you. Party members will follow you everywhere. You can tell them to wait, but they will eventually get tired of waiting, and go back to where you first found them. You can give party members orders, but they will not always be entirely responsive depending on how interested they are in whatever they are doing. Party members can also use their skills out of combat, if they are of a higher level than yours (IE: Vigil can pick locks). Party members can be revived if they die, but if you're in the wilderness and don't have the skill/item to revive them, you won't be able to find them again.

The magick and technology dynamic, while one of the best elements of the world, is a major flaw in the game itself. Your technological vs. your magickal aptitude is rated on a scale of 100 to -100 with 100 being purely technologically oriented and -100 being purely magical (the same is done for your morality). The higher you alignment in favor of one, the better you will be at doing things associated with it (casting spells, using magickal swords, and firing guns). This penalizes technological characters more than magickal ones, as it will stop them from gaining the benefits of enchanted weapons.

While the technological skills are balanced so that no one discipline is better than another, the same is not true of magick. Some magickal colleges are much better than others, and the good ones are much better than the technological skills. The first skill in necromancy (harm) is wildly overpowered compared to the rest of the collage for example. However this power difference is somewhat canceled out by places Tarant, where magickally oriented characters have to walk all the way through the city while technologists can simply take the subway. Technology also has one in game saving grace: Grenades.

Grenades in Arcanum are incredibly powerful. They do a large amount of damage over a wide area, and somewhat inexplicably will not damage your party (they will however damage friendly NPCs). There are several types of grenades, from stun grenades to pure explosive. They can be made by following schematics in the explosive discipline of technology, although the last level in the discipline gives you a schematic for dynamite rather than a grenade. This very well may be the best way to play a technologist. He will be fairly weak early in the game, having to rely on Molotov cocktails and the three grenades you can find early in the game, while you raise your throwing skill. In the mid to late game though, he will be very powerful, with the size of your inventory being the major limitation. As with all technologists, you will want to have several party members to carry your vast store of items.

The game also features a realistic, and annoying, repair system. All weapons and armor have a rating that will decrease when you are critically hit (for armor); critically fail (for weapons); or hit something hard, like a rock monster (also for weapons). When their rating hits zero, the weapon will break, and can only be repaired by a repair master. Most early weapons and armor have a low rating, and will break after just a few critical failures/hits making the early game a trip from one NPC that can repair to the next. You can repair items yourself, if you have the repair skill, but if you aren't a master, the item will lose some of it's maximum rating. This means that after a few do it yourself repairs the item's rating will be so low, that it will break the next time it's damaged. As broken items can't be repaired (unless you master the repair skill) this means you still have to visit the NPCs that can repair. If you have a maxed repair skill and put the effort into getting repair mastery; you can repair items (even broken ones) without losing maximum rating. This requires not only the skill points to raise repair but also the immense effort of getting mastery in a skill. You can't even use the repair skill until you get mastery, unless you're willing to reduce the max rating of your items.

The game has two other major flaws (apparently it is also buggy, but I've only had one minor bug, so I can't comment on that). The last third of the game is very linear, forcing you into a good or evil path, both of which must be played in a linier way, with no alternate way to get through quests. Probably worst of all though, is the combat. There are 3 combat modes: Real Time, Turn based, and a version of turn based with some animations cut out.

All combat modes share some features. Characters have both health and fatigue, and most weapons will deal damage to both. Spells use fatigue -as does attacking when you don't have enough AP- and as such, if you aren't careful, you could be knocked unconscious, after spending your fatigue on spells.

Real Time moves at approximately 3 times the speed it should. Melee characters do fairly well, but have little control of combat, Mages can't cast quickly enough, gun using technologists though, have the worst time. Guns don't actually fire at targets. They fire at the squares the targets stand on; meaning that any movement of the target will cause them to miss. Grenade users can't throw grenades quickly enough, but the large blast radius means that it's still possible to hit with them. If they start fights with a couple of stun grenades, they can get through the game with a minimum of pain.

The turn based modes, which use an AP system, are better. Melee characters will have a very easy time, although they will critically fail around half the time at the start of the game (if played in Hard mode); Mages are ludicrously overpowered; ranged fighters are still almost useless, as enemies will close with you in one turn 99% of the time; and grenade users will be very strong, being somehow able to throw a half-dozen grenades, which seem to detonate instantly, a turn. Of course, doing lots of things in a turn is traditional in turn based games, but it somehow feels ridiculous when throwing grenades. I prefer the system Fallout employed, in which they would explode while your enemy was taking his turn.

Overall, combat is very easy. It falls into a standard RPG trap; that is, you get stronger faster than the enemies you fight. While hard mode is indeed fairly hard early on, it's not much harder than normal by the end. Melee characters have a hard time early in the game, critically failing left and right in hard mode, but you fail less and less as your hit chance gets higher, until you get melee mastery, at which point you can't critically fail at all. Mages will only be able to cast a few spells at a time near the start of the game, but by the end of the game they will have enough Fatigue and Fatigue restoring potions to cast continuously, no matter how long the battle is. Gunslingers are underpowered at every stage of the game, but life does get simpler for them once they get an elephant gun. Other types of technologists, including grenade users, initially have a hard time collecting all the items they need to make items, but by late game will have an immense stockpile.

Even factoring in all of the games many flaws, Arcanum is still not only my favorite CRPG, but also probably my favorite game. It has an incredible story that, while beginning as a traditional role playing epic, chosen one and all; evolves into much more. The story is brought to life by the exceptional dialog, which gives life to the characters. Despite the linear plot and all the effort dedicated to bringing the characters to life, the game moves in a very nonlinear fashion, with many ways to complete quests. Due to its many flaws however, I can only give the game an 85 out of 100.
 

aboyd

Liturgist
Joined
Oct 28, 2004
Messages
843
Location
USA
Thanks for posting this. It doesn't reveal anything new to me, but I've played Arcanum a lot of times (never finishing, IIRC). It must have taken some effort to get it all put together so nicely.
 

Severian Silk

Guest
I shouldn't have started reading it. There were spoilers.
 

Zhirzzh

Scholar
Joined
Nov 24, 2007
Messages
191
Assnuggets said:
I shouldn't have started reading it. There were spoilers.

Not really, all events I spoil, are from the first 20 min of the game, and all the history can be pieced together in Tarant. Which I mentioned. I can black the whole thing though, if you'd like.

Edit: some history may not be clear until you reach Dernholm. I've edited the post to reflect that.
 

Andhaira

Arcane
Joined
Nov 25, 2007
Messages
1,869,015
I agree about the combat, that was what ruined arcanum for me. I was one of those who had been looking for the game since it was announced, and regularaly haunted the sierra boards, and once they shut down moved to the arcanum inn forums over at the vault.

One really annoying thing for me was that enemies could close in on you on one turn, nearly every time. So you really had to keep your hp's bumpbed if you played a physically weak character such as a mage.

I do hope there is a sequel though. The world was very interesting.
 

Hümmelgümpf

Arbiter
Joined
Jun 17, 2007
Messages
2,949
Location
St. Petersburg, Russia
If I'm not mistaken Troika was planning to develop a sequel. It was meant to be called "Journey to the Centre of Arcanum" and utilize Source engine, but... Everyone knows how Troika ended.
 

Andhaira

Arcane
Joined
Nov 25, 2007
Messages
1,869,015
Yeah but no fault but their own. I am sad certainly, I wanted them to be successful. But they kept making buggy, buggy games. And the bugs were gamestopping at times.

Arcanum, TOEE, etc.

Their compadres over at Obsidian also continue this trend to this very day:

KOTOR 2 for intance.

Basically all the former balck isle emplpyee's have a penchant for delveloping buggy and sometimes unfinished game.s Thmain reason for this is that they usually bite of more than they can chew; they are very passionate, and so want to pack as much as possible into their games that they forgoe realistic deadlines.
 

Longshanks

Augur
Joined
Jul 28, 2004
Messages
897
Location
Australia.
I know that VtmB was initially supposed to be an Arcanum sequel, it was going to be FPP as well, wasn't it?

One problem I have with Arcanum is it's length and number of "boring bits", this means that despite it being one of my favourites, I've only played it twice (played Fallout around a dozen). Bad combat is not a problem for me (wasn't bad enough to affect my enjoyment), the amount of combat in some areas did.

There are some rough edges, but few games match its level of roleplaying, possibly the best game I've played in terms of C&C, especially through dialogue and multiple ways to approach quests.

About bugs, I don't care about them, they are almost always fixed within a month or two, I'm able to wait. Obviously, it is better for a game to have few bugs than many, but my opinion of a game is not affected by bugs. If a game's great but buggy, give it a month or so and it'll just be great, a game which is mediocre with few bugs will always be mediocre.

I completely disagree that Troika failed as a company (certainly did not fail as developers) because their games were buggy, even though I understand that many don't share my views on bugs.
 

Keldorn

Scholar
Joined
Jun 28, 2007
Messages
867
Isometric glory *abounds* within this magnificently hallowed pixelated realm-fragment.

We have no need to quibble and quarrel over said imperfections and mere mechanical matters, for the transcendental vision and ubiquitous pith is never a squib, it is instead, *true art*.

Never a day goes by for old Keldorn, where he does not ruminate and cerebrally salivate over prospects of playing games with the epic uncanniness of Arcanum. However, since the corporate doctrine explicitly states that profit is an unyielding priority over humanistic enlightenment, I shall either simply have to wait in vain : rotting in the retro-gamer's corner, without any form of a dunce cap, I might add, OR, endeavour to replay the great games of gargantuan gratification.


I, Keldorn, shall choose the latter, and, as well, shall thank thee for this thread.
 

Keldorn

Scholar
Joined
Jun 28, 2007
Messages
867
1eyedking said:
Now I know where thesaurus.com gets its hits from.


Now now, isn't your cyclopsian perspective a tad constrictive ?

I have never visited said site, and I never shall, as I have no need.



However, you *should*, you likely *have*, you indeed *require* and you likely *shall*.
 

MF

The Boar Studio
Patron
Developer
Joined
Dec 8, 2002
Messages
911
Location
Amsterdam
Keldorn said:
1eyedking said:
Now I know where thesaurus.com gets its hits from.


Now now, isn't your cyclopsian perspective a tad constrictive ?

I have never visited said site, and I never shall, as I have no need.



However, you *should*, you likely *have*, you indeed *require* and you likely *shall*.

* Shall and its past tense form should denote simple futurity in the first person.
* Will and its past tense form would denote simple futurity in the second and third persons.

And you *fail*. No weaseling out either, modal future does not apply. Especially because you used the world 'likely'.
 

Dark Elf

Erudite
Joined
Mar 3, 2004
Messages
1,617
Location
Sweden
Throughout the game you will receive 60 skill points for leveling up (one per level, two every fifth), for a total of 65.

You actually get 64 points, since between level 1 and level 50 you level up 49 times.

Sorry, couldn't resist. :D
 

Keldorn

Scholar
Joined
Jun 28, 2007
Messages
867
MF said:
Keldorn said:
1eyedking said:
Now I know where thesaurus.com gets its hits from.


Now now, isn't your cyclopsian perspective a tad constrictive ?

I have never visited said site, and I never shall, as I have no need.



However, you *should*, you likely *have*, you indeed *require* and you likely *shall*.

* Shall and its past tense form should denote simple futurity in the first person.
* Will and its past tense form would denote simple futurity in the second and third persons.

And you *fail*. No weaseling out either, modal future does not apply. Especially because you used the world 'likely'.

I have anarchistic grammatical tendencies. Ivonics.

My points still stand. They will, they should, they can, they do, they need to, they want to, they have to, they like to, they love to, they.....


..... succeed at .......


.....SUCCESS.
 

Keldorn

Scholar
Joined
Jun 28, 2007
Messages
867
Au naturel said:
Arcanum is the best CRPG ever. It really is that simple. For every choice, a reaction and something different down the line.


Success.


In isometric, artistically ambient glory.
 

Jasede

Arcane
Patron
Joined
Jan 4, 2005
Messages
24,793
Insert Title Here RPG Wokedex Codex Year of the Donut I'm very into cock and ball torture
It's very good. It's no Wizardry 8, but of course that's a different genre; Arcanum is definitely the best "Codex" CRPG I know, way better than the good, but a bit overrated Fallout.
 

Volourn

Pretty Princess
Pretty Princess Glory to Ukraine
Joined
Mar 10, 2003
Messages
24,939
Arcanum is a very good game. One of my favorites that often has a place in my top 10. I actually enjoy the combat for the most part (use turn base usually all the time except inc ases where I know the enemy is no match).

The music is awesome. The role-playing is very good. The character system is underappreciated. the characters are solid though not great, and the writing can range from good to great.

Best ever, though? Nah. Not quite.
 

made

Arcane
Joined
Dec 18, 2006
Messages
5,130
Location
Germany
Aw, not the 100/100 score I expected, but a fair review nonetheless. Good description of the game's flaws and strong points.
 

Texas Red

Whiner
Joined
Sep 9, 2006
Messages
7,044
I really want to finish Arcanum a second time but the unpolished quests(largely from Dernholm and that vassal city) keep me from doing it.

How dumb is it for a king to ask a random foreigner to fetch him his taxes on his behalf?!

Thinking back, I really love that many NPCs, even those insignificant, had some sort of a characteristic that set them apart.
 

Relayer71

Liturgist
Joined
Dec 23, 2006
Messages
538
Location
NYC
I gave this game a bit of a half-assed playthrough years ago (didn't finish it) and I blame that on the combat and some interface issues which annoyed the hell out of me - and STILL I thought there were many positive things about the game such as the original music, basic game world concept, quests, etc.

Lately though, I've had this strong desire to play it but I can't find one of the discs and can't find this in stores anywhere anymore :(
 

Texas Red

Whiner
Joined
Sep 9, 2006
Messages
7,044
Its available through the torrents. Hmm, strange. 3 or so years ago when I wanted to get Arcanum, no torrents even existed. Now, after a quick look, there is one with over 100 seeders. Wonder what the heck caused this renewal of interest.
 

JarlFrank

I like Thief THIS much
Patron
Joined
Jan 4, 2007
Messages
33,473
Location
KA.DINGIR.RA.KI
Steve gets a Kidney but I don't even get a tag.
The Walkin' Dude said:
Its available through the torrents. Hmm, strange. 3 or so years ago when I wanted to get Arcanum, no torrents even existed. Now, after a quick look, there is one with over 100 seeders. Wonder what the heck caused this renewal of interest.

Nostalgia?
Arcanum being a better game than most of the newer stuff?
People wanting to spread the Holy Faith of Troika Studios?
The same reason why the original Fallouts have so many seeders?
Plain curiosity?
Who knows?
 

Shagnak

Shagadelic
Joined
Sep 6, 2003
Messages
4,638
Location
Arse of the world, New Zealand
Relayer71 said:
Lately though, I've had this strong desire to play it but I can't find one of the discs and can't find this in stores anywhere anymore :(
Funny, I've seen it all over the place down here in nowhere land as a budget release (approx 1/5th the price of a new game). There's a shop around the corner that has it in its bin of "budget games well past their sell-by", so it may be even cheaper than that.
 

ixg

Erudite
Joined
Jan 20, 2006
Messages
2,078
Location
Scary...
Because it's a good game?
 

As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top Bottom