holla_cabezas_de_mierda
Arcane
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2006
- Messages
- 3,023
The competiton between Deadfire and Kingmaker might get interesting.I wonder how would Sword Coast Legends be perceived on the Codex if the devs had Avellone write a minor character...
I wouldn't be posting about this game if I hadn't verified that it wasn't like Sword Coast Legends.
Look at the videos man, it's plainly obvious that they're making what is effectively a Pathfinder total conversion of Pillars of Eternity.
Not only has Kingmaker MCA while Deadfire has not.
PoE uses preprocessed backgrounds and I always found Obsidian's argument flawed that this is more economic. The rationale is that the artists can add more detail, but if you look at the workflow they still start out with a 3D model of the scene and have to go through an entire preprocessing pipeline. The argument hinges mostly on whether the finishing touches of the artists and the added detail is worth the effort, which never has been proven.
On the other hand Kingmaker uses persistent 3D modelling in the game and if you look at the videos on IGN, which contain a good mix of indoor and outdoor areas, the level of detail is perfectly good for a game of this type. The devs at Owlcat have ten years experience with tools for the generation of landscapes which combine handcrafted and procedural elements. If I am not mistaken, they also have a large library of 3D assets for the bestiary.
It might end up in a competition who can build the more rich and rewarding game. PoE fell short in so many areas, including encounter design and the weak stronghold features, the lacklustre mega-dungeon is a major missed opportunity, Twin Elms is scaled down. It is not far fetched that these elements just lacked some more work, which is essentially a budget and efficiency issue.
If Kingmaker raises a comparative amount of funds, we may be in for a real treat, hopefully.
Whether it will be great though may depend on other issues, like whether MCA will have enough freedom to establish a process to do the lore of Pathfinder justice.
I dont think they will raise as much funding, but I would be happy to be wrong.