Alec: Anyway. I keep wanting to say things like “Wolfenstein is far better than it has any right to be”, but then I question why it doesn’t have that right. Big publisher? Umpteenth sequel? Change of developer? None of those things really matter – it’s just whether someone’s trying to make as a good a gonzo alterna-WW2 shooter as they can.
And they made a pretty damn fine job of it, apart from a couple of tonal misfires and the accursed checkpoints.
Adam: Yep. My favourite FPS in a good while and it’s given me a renewed interest in Wolfenstein as a name and, more importantly, in the studio.
It’s better than I ever expected it to be but that’s bringing my own taste into consideration – I’m a fairly squeamish sort when it comes to making light of history and I don’t enjoy many FPS games at all anymore.
Alec: It’s also one of far too few games which look to Half-Life 2 rather than Modern Warfare for their inspiration. While that’s a watermark it was realistically never going to reach, it pays off – it gives the player much more to do and to plan and experiment with than most contemporary FPSes. (HL2 doing not-Nazis as its Nazis is important to its effectiveness – the bleakness but not the discomfort).
Adam: The actual action reminded me of the combat in F.E.A.R. at times, when it was happening in smaller closed spaces anyhow. That’s a good thing too. It has a solidity that I miss in a lot of games.
Alec: I could have done without quite so many extended torture or evisceration sequences, to be honest. I don’t think it’s just that I’m getting old – again it’s that tonal imbalance, the times when it struggles to reconcile its tonal duality.
Adam: Maybe the Strasse switch-out for Hitler removed some of the discomfort for me. And, yes, the gorier excesses felt unnecessary. The globe-trotting (or Europe-trotting, plus moon and secret underwater magi-science cave) are more Indiana Jones than Inglourious Basterds. It’s high adventure rather than grimdark horror. At its best, at least.
Alec: Anyway, speaking of humanity’s darkest hour, the baby is screaming again so let’s wrap this up.
Adam: Wolfenstein – BETTER THAN IT HAD ANY RIGHT TO BE
Alec: Quite right too.