circ said:
Good for you, thinking 15 bucks a month for a loot simulator and prepubescant kids spamming you with LOL LOL KILL ITZ LOL! is good value for money.
Metro said:
Yeesh said:
And gives you 90+ hours of play in the same timeframe.
That contention is as subjective as the ones you deride me for making. Given the four to six month gaps in between content (and sometimes even longer) the bulk of that ~25 hours a week is probably going to be straight up loot grinding -- having played WoW I know countless hours are chewed up just sitting around in a capital city, checking the Auction House or waiting for a group/trying to find something to do (whereas for most single player games you just hit the ground running without the prep/busy work). And yes, some people find that fun, although when you have to pay to run the same dungeons over and over and over again I do call its value into question.
What I mean by the multiple $50 AAA reference is that if you're the type of person who regularly expends that much on gaming then obviously WoW will seem like a bargain. Compared to other gaming choices? Not so much. Is that opinion. Of course. So is most of the stuff on here -- it's a forum.
Let me see if I can make this clear. Value is a separate question. If you don't like a game, if you don't like a movie, if you don't like a dinner entree, if you don't any sort of experience that people charge money for, then you don't like it. That's great, don't play it, don't watch it, don't eat it. That doesn't make it a bad value. That just means you don't like it.
Obviously if you don't like WoW, then it doesn't matter if the game is free or if it costs $1000 per month. You still won't like it. BUT the value proposition in those two cases is wildly different, yes? And the value proposition needs to be measured for people who do like it, right? Because people who don't like it will just say unintelligent bullshit like "That game's a bad value even though it's free because it sucks". Good for you for having an opinion, but like the vegetarian discussing steak, you're really not in a position to judge. Your personal evaluation of enjoyment per dollar can never be anything other than 0. So if you can't see past that to evaluate the value to people who might actually enjoy the game, you (apparently) are incapable of contributing anything but empty bullshit to the discussion.
A green energy person might not want to buy a Hummer SUV for $1. That doesn't mean you would credit his opinion that at that price the vehicle is a bad deal. A graphics whore might say a Spiderweb game provides 0 hours of gameplay because he wouldn't play a game that looks like that. A man who doesn't like asian chicks says an asian model is ugly because she has slanty eyes and her skin isn't white enough. These people are you. That's your level of discourse. It's not just having your own opinion, for which I deride no one, it's assuming that your preference is somehow tied in to a universal truth about entertainment that 11 million paying customers are missing.
So yeah, I prefer to judge the value of a game by gaming hours per dollar. It's neutral, and it's sensible, and it's real. It's not a "contention".
Speaking to Metro, I accept that not every minute of WoW is a blast. But neither is any other game. I actually loved checking the auction house because I liked making (totally imaginary) money, but yeah sometimes you sat around waiting for this or that. But other games have downtime too, especially deep, non-linear games of the sort we like here. And to my knowledge, no one has ever been forced at gunpoint to play WoW. Having a subscription doesn't stop you from playing other games, doesn't stop you from doing anything else if you're not having enough fun in WoW. They let you log off anywhere. And if you only like playing new content, you can cancel said subscription when you get bored, and Blizzard saves all your characters indefinitely. So they don't blackmail you into playing more than you want to. There's really no basis for saying people don't get their money's worth out of WoW.