Not to be that guy, but I think that first and foremost developers are annoyed of being defrauded of money by publishers, not that creativity constraints don't matter.If it was just character portraits probably, but "Ranger icons used to display your party location on the world map"? Whatever that means, it sounds a little more advanced.Isn't that like getting some additional .bmp files in the portraits directory of an Infinity Engine game?
Besides, it's the concept of they doing that that bothers me, we just gave them shitloads of money to get rid of publishers and their annoying exclusives/DLC shit-marketing, yet the developers themselves happily do the same thing...
MCA has actually written for some Star Wars comic books.
Thank you for explaining why novella from Avellone isn't something that gives me a stiffy and the game itself is.a genius video game writer like Chris Avellone.
You know what the best thing about MCA novella is?
We can do a "comparison LP" with Gaider's crap.
Opening lines:
Gaider: "run Maric!" And run he did.
Avellone: something something.
I don't "dismiss" him. I just don't feel like paying another $15 in advance to read something which may be good or may not be or even may be excellent but still not enjoyable for me, as I'm not too much into reading books, especially video game related novellas. And there's not too much suggesting it could be excellent as MCA is pretty much unproven as a novella writer. If he writes an excellent novella, good for him - and then maybe I'll try to obtain it.I think dismissing Avellone with *video game writer* already without even a novel out to judge is premature to say the least. So far he has delievered good stuff. I believe the novel will be pretty good too.
Why am I being unfair? I don't say it'll surely be crap, no. His name just isn't enough for me to put out more monies, because - what you said - he's unproven on this field. And it's no freebie, it's a deal - you give us another 15 bucks, we give you Avellone's novella. I'm certain most pledges were made for a deal, not for a cause.Ok but you're being unfair on MCA. He has never claimed to be a novelist, and he hasn't written any novels. What he's doing here is a nice little freebie for people who've invested in the game.
Your loss my friend, your loss :pAnyway I'm excited with the game and just the game. Reading game related novellas or fapping to MCA's autograph on collectors' boxed copy just isn't my thing. I love his games and that's where I'm willing to invest my money.
Why am I being unfair? I don't say it'll surely be crap, no. His name just isn't enough for me to put out more monies, because - what you said - he's unproven on this field. And it's no freebie, it's a deal - you give us another 15 bucks, we give you Avellone's novella. I'm certain most pledges were made for a deal, not for a cause.Ok but you're being unfair on MCA. He has never claimed to be a novelist, and he hasn't written any novels. What he's doing here is a nice little freebie for people who've invested in the game.
I don't "dismiss" him. I just don't feel like paying another $15 in advance to read something which may be good or may not be or even may be excellent but still not enjoyable for me, as I'm not too much into reading books, especially video game related novellas. And there's not too much suggesting it could be excellent as MCA is pretty much unproven as a novella writer. If he writes an excellent novella, good for him - and then maybe I'll try to obtain it.I think dismissing Avellone with *video game writer* already without even a novel out to judge is premature to say the least. So far he has delievered good stuff. I believe the novel will be pretty good too.
Anyway I'm excited with the game and just the game. Reading game related novellas or fapping to MCA's autograph on collectors' boxed copy just isn't my thing. I love his games and that's where I'm willing to invest my money.
Why am I being unfair? I don't say it'll surely be crap, no. His name just isn't enough for me to put out more monies, because - what you said - he's unproven on this field. And it's no freebie, it's a deal - you give us another 15 bucks, we give you Avellone's novella. I'm certain most pledges were made for a deal, not for a cause.Ok but you're being unfair on MCA. He has never claimed to be a novelist, and he hasn't written any novels. What he's doing here is a nice little freebie for people who've invested in the game.
Funny you referenced to this topic, even if it's hardly related to what I said about reading books, because what I said there about story and it's role in cRPGs is a perfect explanation why I don't jizz myself about a novella from video game writing genius, MCA. Story in a book is something completely different than story in a game - and so it's values lie in different areas.
Let's say blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed. And I'm just doubtful one.I haven't made any claims about Chris Avellone's skills at writing novels or novellas, although judging by the quality of his writing in games like Torment and Fallout: New Vegas, I think it is fair to see it is more likely to be good than bad.
Funny you referenced to this topic, even if it's hardly related to what I said about reading books, because what I said there about story and it's role in cRPGs is a perfect explanation why I don't jizz myself about a novella from video game writing genius, MCA. Story in a book is something completely different than story in a game - and so it's values lie in different areas.
Let's say blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed. And I'm just doubtful one.I haven't made any claims about Chris Avellone's skills at writing novels or novellas, although judging by the quality of his writing in games like Torment and Fallout: New Vegas, I think it is fair to see it is more likely to be good than bad.
Wrong. I presume novella is not meant to be crucial to get the setting of Wasteland, I presume it will be something extra for guys who are excited about the setting, not just the game itself. Setting is a tool to enrich the gaming experience, so the game should have as much setting content as it's needed to fulfil this objective. So no reason to care about the novella as long as the game is done properly.Funny you referenced to this topic, even if it's hardly related to what I said about reading books, because what I said there about story and it's role in cRPGs is a perfect explanation why I don't jizz myself about a novella from video game writing genius, MCA. Story in a book is something completely different than story in a game - and so it's values lie in different areas.
Let's say blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed. And I'm just doubtful one.I haven't made any claims about Chris Avellone's skills at writing novels or novellas, although judging by the quality of his writing in games like Torment and Fallout: New Vegas, I think it is fair to see it is more likely to be good than bad.
So according to your logic, the people, places, and lore described in PnP rpg books is irrelevant to the stories told in those games. Also, If the written word helps give context to a setting, what difference does it make if the words are coded into the game itself? A huge percentage of the original Wasteland was conveyed through a companion book. Are those written descriptions also irrelevant? The biggest difference I see is when the story is forced down your face in the game itself, player choices tends to get diminished to Biowhorian levels. At least now we can begin to understand your true nature, Stelcio.
Every medium stands on it's own terms. So do games.
Usually Gundam games are shovelware, and this has been told to me by a guy that regularly buys all of them.I disagree. For example, my avatar is a character from an anime series called Mobile Suit Gundam. Whenever I play a Gundam video game, I'm going to choose that particular character. This is because he is magnificent in the cartoon, which better establishes the setting than the video game by itself could. The game alone might be good or bad .
Usually Gundam games are shovelware, and this has been told to me by a guy that regularly buys all of them.I disagree. For example, my avatar is a character from an anime series called Mobile Suit Gundam. Whenever I play a Gundam video game, I'm going to choose that particular character. This is because he is magnificent in the cartoon, which better establishes the setting than the video game by itself could. The game alone might be good or bad .
Usually Gundam games are shovelware, and this has been told to me by a guy that regularly buys all of them.I disagree. For example, my avatar is a character from an anime series called Mobile Suit Gundam. Whenever I play a Gundam video game, I'm going to choose that particular character. This is because he is magnificent in the cartoon, which better establishes the setting than the video game by itself could. The game alone might be good or bad .