Underrail in general has ok crafting. Not great but ok. It adds something to the game. The decision to make a crafting focused vs some crafting vs no crafting is relevant to your character. The fact that there are some (too few in my opinion) items that require the same components forces you to make some choices - but as i said, it could be made better. In addition components having quality makes it so that you are still interested in finding the same components more times that you need to make one of every needed non-consumable item. Overall it is engaging enough to make the game better, not worse. At worst i wouldn't say that it "sucks" but is average. I guess it is one the "1%".
