You could say all the same things about witcher 3 though, and it's right at the top of the chart.
Who gives a fuck. What's next? Skyrim is a good RPG because it sold like hotcakes?
All in all, Skyrim is a better RPG then Witcher 3 which was, is and will be the new cancer killing RPG as we can see that wuthout any doubts CP will be tailored to the same patterns like their most successful game Witcher 4.
I'll bite. How the hell is skyrim a better rpg than witcher 3? Is it because it lets you play as a furry?
Well, it's not a bait at all? and has nothing with "furry" whatever it is.
Skyrim is better because it allows and has a lot of RPG activities - go there, find this, stumble on that etc.
What exactly W3 has except supeb voiced dialogues, superb directed cut-scenes, great songs and music, and very few non-linear quests?
There is nothing interesting in the so called open world which is empty and dull. You can't find there anything interesting becuse you will buy same or even better weapon or armor from a smith in the town.
That's why even crippled Bethesda's RPGs are much more RPG than W3.
I don't touch combat because it equally bad in Skyrim and W3.
More than that - it is obvious for me, that if W3 got prises and awards it will affect all similiar competitors like Bethesda games, so they will go the same path as CDPR went. So it's a cancer.
Yeah, it's a dark times when you forced to say somehtign good about Bethesda's games as RPG because other options even worse.