Putting the 'role' back in role-playing games since 2002.
Donate to Codex
Good Old Games
  • Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.

    "This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.

From Software Elden Ring - From Software's new game with writing by GRRM

Odoryuk

Educated
Joined
Mar 26, 2024
Messages
804
I can't think of something that is more ill suited to a movie adaptation than a FromSoft game.

If i had to guess the commie fatso got peanuts for the cliff notes he gave FromSoft but after he saw that Elden Ring was a smash hit he wants to cash in to what he thinks is his property even though if you didn't tell me he was involved in the game i wouldn't even know. There's nothing in Elden Ring that Myazaki couldn't come up on his on and in fact it's likely that most of the lore that ended up in the game is his in the first place
I can see a very good small episode count anime based on Déraciné, but their action titles tell the story through gameplay, and that type of storytelling could only be bastardized in a different media. Google Dark Souls comics that were released after Dark Souls 3 for a good laugh.
I think it was largely a marketing push from the publisher, or maybe a personal desire of Miyazaki to collab with Martin.
I think these are the reasons. Miyazaki wanted to collaborate with one of his favorite living artists +Namco Bandai saw it as a good marketing opportunity.
 

Stoned Ape

Savant
Joined
Jan 9, 2018
Messages
905
Location
The belly of the whale
I can't think of something that is more ill suited to a movie adaptation than a FromSoft game.

If i had to guess the commie fatso got peanuts for the cliff notes he gave FromSoft but after he saw that Elden Ring was a smash hit he wants to cash in to what he thinks is his property even though if you didn't tell me he was involved in the game i wouldn't even know. There's nothing in Elden Ring that Myazaki couldn't come up on his on and in fact it's likely that most of the lore that ended up in the game is his in the first place
I can see a very good small episode count anime based on Déraciné, but their action titles tell the story through gameplay, and that type of storytelling could only be bastardized in a different media. Google Dark Souls comics that were released after Dark Souls 3 for a good laugh.
I think it was largely a marketing push from the publisher, or maybe a personal desire of Miyazaki to collab with Martin.
I think these are the reasons. Miyazaki wanted to collaborate with one of his favorite living artists +Namco Bandai saw it as a good marketing opportunity.
They could make a parody TV show/movie like they did with the manga...

Elden-Ring-Manga.jpg
 

Odoryuk

Educated
Joined
Mar 26, 2024
Messages
804

Caim

Arcane
Joined
Aug 1, 2013
Messages
18,061
Location
Dutchland
They could make a parody TV show/movie like they did with the manga...
Ha, I forgot about Elden Ring manga, it was pretty good. Reminds me about a lof of great fan made comics, but official
I think my favourite part was the big reveal of the lore behind Bloodhound Knight Darriwil being a traitor:

Ranni-Fan-Club.jpg
Personally I agree with Darriwil
Darriwil got locked up for being a Touhou fan. Now that's some deep lore.
 

SayMyName

Educated
Joined
Jan 21, 2025
Messages
123
Also this is my speculation, but I think Nightreign might be developed only as part of the deal to purchase back the IP, since it's still being published by Bandai Namco.

Nightreign was in conceptual phase before
https://www.pcgamer.com/elden-rings...-tarkov-for-a-little-multiplayer-inspiration/
In particular
The director told IGN that the game's popularity won't "affect what we are going to create next," and that FromSoft will "keep creating the game that we want to create, and that's our policy"

Fromsoftware don't make games they are absolutely willing to do. It doesn't matter what people want. They have always stepped outside their comfort zone. Making a multiplayer title forces Fromsoftware to improve on some aspects where they struggle. The AI for example has different target priorities in Nightreign to better handle group fighting and is not based purely on closest target vs last aggro.

Furthermore, Elden Ring Nightreign IS an Elden Ring game

tybuqNk.jpeg


TYwZsh5.jpeg


In the CNT you can actually see the Shadow form of those who died and went before the Erdtree and the Scadutree, like the proto giants who spawned from the primordial life brought by the first meteor, and laid the foundation of the Lands Between themselves. They are now wandering aimlessly with a body of tree roots.

zYlSRQ4.jpeg


Limveld is connected to the Lands Between, the Spiraltrees appear as shades, with the Two Fingers growing from the Divine Tower the Ancient Dynasties created to support them as braces.
Miyazaki, like Armored Core 6, was involved in the conceptual phase of the game and the world is likely very coherent to Elden Ring.
If Fromsoftware wanted to recycle assets aggressively, he would reskin them in a bigger fully priced NOT! Elden Ring project that can reuse a lot of assets, instead of straight up embracing heavy lore elements

There's nothing in Elden Ring that Myazaki couldn't come up on his on
Reportedly, what GRRM did was create a very early backstory for the world and some of the characters, then FS took that and greatly altered and twisted it. Most of the iconic elements of the game literally are done by Miyazaki himself. So I think you're totally right. I think it was largely a marketing push from the publisher, or maybe a personal desire of Miyazaki to collab with Martin.
Neither Miyazaki nor Bandai (who had zero creative direction on Elden Ring) need to use GRRM name for marketing. If Miyazaki wanted his stories to get awards, he wouldn't be famous for obscure stories that require investigation and exploration over more common and popular forms of storytelling.
He doesn't care that most people wouldn't notice a small building of Eternal City architecture in the outskirts of Leyndell with heretical Tree iconography indicating the cult of the Sacred Trees started as underground religious movement during the Ancient Dynasties much like Christianity during Rome, or that the Grand Cloister in the Lake of Rot is styled after the Temple of Isis, Goddess of Death who saved her kidnapped brother and sent him to the Realm of the Dead.
No Miyazaki game is going to win any awards for writing or be a selling point, its just his style.
 

As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top Bottom