Crooked Bee has this straight. It has a retro-90's dungeon crawl feel, much like the Lands of Lore series after #1, or Ultima Underworld, or multitudes of others.
Considering Diablo had less sophistication, yet is within the RPG genre, it not exactly up for debate what genre Dark Souls fall into.
However, the graphics. Seriously? These look just as shittily drawn as Dark Souls 1, except with MOAR REFLECTION!!11!
The animations are still less fluid than any Source engine game, like Dark Messiah, and considerably less smooth than Alice, which was last gen. Even worse, Alice got panned on its graphics by several prominent gaming magazines, and that is on prior tech consoles.
Also, textures are blotchy, at best, and I can barely tell the wall from stacks of crates in the distance, as both look flat, blocky, and without natural texture, instead substituting a rubber look.
They also ought to work on natural physics! I am betting they still use decals to mark walls that have been scratched, just to cut development costs. Milking it much?
EDIT: Yes, I know. I will probably own this game and love it! Other than that, it looks and feels great.
Salute,
Dawnrazor