Seven
Erudite
It looks to me like the next inevitable level of realism. That's what's not impressive. No one seems to be experimenting with non-photorealistic rendering past cel-shading.
If someone made a game that looked cartoonish (comic book-style crosshashes and perspectives, not cel shaded) or like an oil painting, that would impressive. Damn impressive.
There are quite a few games that have that cartoonish look to it. Personally, the best early example is Grim Fandango. I don't believe that the move to that cartoonish look is the next evolution because it's been done and done well in the past and many times since then.