funkbutter said:
Maybe I've never played a game with meaningfull choices, could you cite an example of a meaningfull choice from another game you've played such as Arcanum, which you mentioned earlier so I have a frame of reference please?
I'll do you one better: I'll cite you two choices your character can make, one detailing moral consequence and the other, game consequence:
In Planescape: Torment, you meet an old and decrepit man, who misses his daughter very very much. He asks you to find his daughter and tell him how she's been. Should you take the quest, you'll find that his daughter has become a prostitute and living a morally degrading life. You return to the old man, and he asks with great anticipation what news you've brought.
You can:
A. Lie and tell him you never found his daughter
B. Lie and tell him his daughter is doing just fine
C. Tell the truth about his daughter.
Depending on which choice you picked, the old man will react in a very emotionally impacting manner, illustrating consequences of a moral decision.
Another decision in Planescape: Torment comes when you come down to the pillar of skulls in baator. You may ask the pillar one question which it must answer, but to do so, you must sacrifice something of your own, be it your party members, a permanent portion of yourself (denoted by a heavy permanent stat and hp loss), or an item of great power. Depending on what choice you make, the gameplay becomes heavily altered changed for the rest of the game. (The powerful item isn't something silly like a sword or anything, but an item which lets you access a large part of the gameworld).
Yet another decision in Planescape: Torment comes when you meet a cult of undead who worship the silent king. If you should choose to investigate, you'll find out that their silent king, is, in fact, dead, and you have the choice of taking the place of this demogogue. Should you choose to do so, it counts as an alternate ending of the game. This is a good example of a decision that impacts plot.
Morrowind had no choices of this sort.