I've thought a lot about the game over the past couple of days. Undoubtedly a testament to its strong writing which really is head, shoulders, knees and toes above everything else in games. Seriously, bra-fucking-vo because it's consistently humorous, concise and engaging and conversations are a pleasure to participate in (mostly). Other games have good conversations too, they must have, but I would have to sit and think for a while to find a similar level because this kind of quality is so thin on the ground. The VO is the best I've heard in games. It's actually surreal almost to find yourself enjoying fully VO'd first person conversation because in everything else it's either a chore or just depressing. For a moment back in 2004 the future of writing and acting in games was pretty bright!
I even enjoy the hammy theatrical facial and bodily animations. There's one where they reel back in fright or alarm and it's like, huh, so you can emote with 3d marionettes in a fun and entertaining way, never seen that before.
On the other hand I don't like vampires. I hate the music, that beret wearing cunt can fuck right off because the plaguebearer quest was shit and no I'm not a cammy. I actually want to get militant with nines and Jack but the game won't let me. Deb of night was cool, chunk was funny and this is by far the best game I desperately want to love or even like enough to finish but can't.