Community RPG Codex GOTY 2023: Results & Cool Graphs

[Zarniwoop]

troll accounts giving it 5/5,

There also a lot of people giving 1/5.

I dint rated ja3 because I dint played.

super low level cap

Lv 12 is not super low. Dark sun ahattered lands had lv cap of 9. Wake of the ravager, 15. Most ad&d games have lv cap before teens.

And in 3e, toee lv cap is 10.

In ravenloft strahd possession + stone prophet, you can only get above 12 if you play with a small 2 team party and import it in the second game. Spelljammer pirates of realmspace? Lv cap = 11.

And bg3 is 5e. 5e dont work in high levels.

It's super low for the amount of content, quests etc. You reach the level cap long before the end, and you can't gain an extra level or 2 to make the final fights easier.

 

[Hellraiser]

JA3 also didn't get ~50 alt/troll accounts giving it 5/5, unlike BG3.

It's closer to 40 TBH considering the earlier posted "votes by users with <100 posts" cherry picking I did. Some are probably legit lurkers and new users, but we also most certainly have ancient alts with higher post counts than 100 around somewhere, which should balance it out, I think. So 40 is my entirely subjective guess on how many of those we had distorting (r00fles) the data.

But considering BG3 had 304 votes total, those 40 5/5 votes by likely (according to my bellyfeels) sock-puppets are still well over 13% of the votes given away to BG3, and almost equal to the 41 1/5 votes BG3 got from all (and not just cherry picked <100 posts maybe alts) users, it's quite obvious the system is crooked in both directions.

 

[Cryomancer]

You reach the level cap long before the end, and you can't gain an extra level or 2 to make the final fights easier.

i agree that you get to lv cap too quickly. Only a nitpick about extra attack. In 5e, after lv 12, you only get a 4th attack at lv 17. 7th tier spells arent that better than 6th. With all powers from gear due not having magic attunement rule and psionic powers from the tadpole, a lv12 bg3 char is imo stronger than a lv 14 p&p 5e char.

What I really wanted in higher levels is the 14tg level ability for necros.

 

[Ladonna]

Thread still delivering.

 

[Owlcat_Eyler]

Thank u for the votes and the fourth place, guys

 

[jackofshadows]

I think this would cause way more butthurt and fun in general if BG3 would've won.

 

[cvv]

Thank u for the votes and the fourth place, guys

Already bought Rogue Trader Voidfarer and waiting for it to be fully patched and reinforced with DLCs, so chop chop!

 

[H. P. Lovecraft's Cat]

proud member of the "voted 1/5 for bg3 despite not having played it" crowd checking in
you're welcome

i know you fuckers would have made it goty if not for us

Same. Good job team!

 

[agris]

It's interesting to see Konjad defending Codex's honor on RPG Watch, and people there just not getting it.

Post link pliz

https://rpgwatch.com/forum/threads/rpg-codex-goty-2023-results.57851/

Of course faggot Mortmal got bullied here, so he went to RPGWatch to cry how awful and toxic and worthless Codex is

Nope, I was replying to HiddenX, who no longer posts here, by the way. That statement is incorrect. People don't love Jagged Alliance 3 here most voters never played it; they hate on BG3. Now I'm not even sure if it's worth trying or if it's another Elex.

This.

People wanted to bully me so they voted for a game they never played and gave it a 1/5.

Results just show again that the codex is a joke nobody takes serious. Hell we never even got a review of the most succesful CRPG ever made.

The results where analyzed in this thread, there is no link between putting 1/5 on BG3 and giving JA3 a good score.

Also that BG3 features divisive content is a valid reason to Vote for it 1/5,

The difference is, JA3 didn't get edgelords who didnt play it giving it 1/5 scores.

Hell JA3 isn't even an RPG. Just more proof this site is a joke that has become completely irrelevant.

Why would anyone give JA3 a 1/5 though anyways? It's not shit, unlike BG3.

Keep coping, this edegelord GOTY won't change the facts.

As another said: “shit’s great, a million flies can’t be wrong” eh?

 

[Swen]

Now for a list that actually matters



Keep crying codex, you're irrelevant

 

[The Wall]

Motherfuckers who love being doggied by bears: 1/5 and 5/5 and every rating in between are all legitimate. Because those ratings are not whether particular game is OBJECTIVELY 1/5 or 5/5. It's about personal, completely subjective perception of fun and beauty someone sees in particular game he played. 100% SUBJECTIVE

Thus. BG3 is 1/5. May anal volcanos of midwits errupt now

 

[Swen]

It's interesting to see Konjad defending Codex's honor on RPG Watch, and people there just not getting it.

Post link pliz

https://rpgwatch.com/forum/threads/rpg-codex-goty-2023-results.57851/

Of course faggot Mortmal got bullied here, so he went to RPGWatch to cry how awful and toxic and worthless Codex is

Nope, I was replying to HiddenX, who no longer posts here, by the way. That statement is incorrect. People don't love Jagged Alliance 3 here most voters never played it; they hate on BG3. Now I'm not even sure if it's worth trying or if it's another Elex.

This.

People wanted to bully me so they voted for a game they never played and gave it a 1/5.

Results just show again that the codex is a joke nobody takes serious. Hell we never even got a review of the most succesful CRPG ever made.

The results where analyzed in this thread, there is no link between putting 1/5 on BG3 and giving JA3 a good score.

Also that BG3 features divisive content is a valid reason to Vote for it 1/5,

The difference is, JA3 didn't get edgelords who didnt play it giving it 1/5 scores.

Hell JA3 isn't even an RPG. Just more proof this site is a joke that has become completely irrelevant.

Why would anyone give JA3 a 1/5 though anyways? It's not shit, unlike BG3.

Keep coping, this edegelord GOTY won't change the facts.

As another said: “shit’s great, a million flies can’t be wrong” eh?

https://goty.gamefa.com/

Tell me who won most GOTY awards

 

[The Wall]

I'm FUCKING PROUD being hated by retarded 111IQ midwits with micropenises, horse & loli porn collections and 0 unique thoughts in their heads. FUCKING PROUD to be part of Shitposting Intelectual Giants. RPG CODEX - Last Stronghold still standing for normalcy and good RPGs

 

[Swen]

Summary of thread:

 

[ArchAngel]

Now for a list that actually matters



Keep crying codex, you're irrelevant

You sound very butthurt. Even with JA3 not being worth it, at least we got to see you act like a baby so it is worth it.

 

[ArchAngel]

It's interesting to see Konjad defending Codex's honor on RPG Watch, and people there just not getting it.

Post link pliz

https://rpgwatch.com/forum/threads/rpg-codex-goty-2023-results.57851/

Of course faggot Mortmal got bullied here, so he went to RPGWatch to cry how awful and toxic and worthless Codex is

Nope, I was replying to HiddenX, who no longer posts here, by the way. That statement is incorrect. People don't love Jagged Alliance 3 here most voters never played it; they hate on BG3. Now I'm not even sure if it's worth trying or if it's another Elex.

This.

People wanted to bully me so they voted for a game they never played and gave it a 1/5.

Results just show again that the codex is a joke nobody takes serious. Hell we never even got a review of the most succesful CRPG ever made.

The results where analyzed in this thread, there is no link between putting 1/5 on BG3 and giving JA3 a good score.

Also that BG3 features divisive content is a valid reason to Vote for it 1/5,

The difference is, JA3 didn't get edgelords who didnt play it giving it 1/5 scores.

Hell JA3 isn't even an RPG. Just more proof this site is a joke that has become completely irrelevant.

Why would anyone give JA3 a 1/5 though anyways? It's not shit, unlike BG3.

Keep coping, this edegelord GOTY won't change the facts.

As another said: “shit’s great, a million flies can’t be wrong” eh?

https://goty.gamefa.com/

Tell me who won most GOTY awards

Sure but it seems Codex GOTY means more to you or you would not be spamming this topic so much lol.

 

[Swen]

It's interesting to see Konjad defending Codex's honor on RPG Watch, and people there just not getting it.

Post link pliz

https://rpgwatch.com/forum/threads/rpg-codex-goty-2023-results.57851/

Of course faggot Mortmal got bullied here, so he went to RPGWatch to cry how awful and toxic and worthless Codex is

Nope, I was replying to HiddenX, who no longer posts here, by the way. That statement is incorrect. People don't love Jagged Alliance 3 here most voters never played it; they hate on BG3. Now I'm not even sure if it's worth trying or if it's another Elex.

This.

People wanted to bully me so they voted for a game they never played and gave it a 1/5.

Results just show again that the codex is a joke nobody takes serious. Hell we never even got a review of the most succesful CRPG ever made.

The results where analyzed in this thread, there is no link between putting 1/5 on BG3 and giving JA3 a good score.

Also that BG3 features divisive content is a valid reason to Vote for it 1/5,

The difference is, JA3 didn't get edgelords who didnt play it giving it 1/5 scores.

Hell JA3 isn't even an RPG. Just more proof this site is a joke that has become completely irrelevant.

Why would anyone give JA3 a 1/5 though anyways? It's not shit, unlike BG3.

Keep coping, this edegelord GOTY won't change the facts.

As another said: “shit’s great, a million flies can’t be wrong” eh?

https://goty.gamefa.com/

Tell me who won most GOTY awards

Sure but it seems Codex GOTY means more to you or you would not be spamming this topic so much lol.

Because it's a retarded result.

If it wasn't for the woke shit you would all be sucking my dick. BG3 is literally the best CRPG ever made.

 

[cvv]

Time to start thinking about moving all this landfill to retardoland.

 

[The Wall]

Thank u for the votes and the fourth place, guys

You don't have to be WOKE to be succesfull. I'll show it to you with my games and publishing house. First I'm gonna mod Rogue Trader and make it more immersive. Starting with re-introducing only two Human sexes that exist: Codexian BIGDICK male and RPG Watch sex-slave female. Also all blackies that make no sense in setting gotta go. I'm the good guy, you're the ones infected by retarded ideology. Hope your heads get better soon

HYPERNORMALISATION is hellofa mind weapon and drug. We gotta HYPERNORMALIZE beautiful and good RPGs. I think that's precisely what we're doing, boyz

 

[PsihoKekec]

I would like to thank the makers of BG3 for giving us such quality forum drama.

 

[jaekl]

It's interesting to see Konjad defending Codex's honor on RPG Watch, and people there just not getting it.

Post link pliz

https://rpgwatch.com/forum/threads/rpg-codex-goty-2023-results.57851/

Of course faggot Mortmal got bullied here, so he went to RPGWatch to cry how awful and toxic and worthless Codex is

Nope, I was replying to HiddenX, who no longer posts here, by the way. That statement is incorrect. People don't love Jagged Alliance 3 here most voters never played it; they hate on BG3. Now I'm not even sure if it's worth trying or if it's another Elex.

This.

People wanted to bully me so they voted for a game they never played and gave it a 1/5.

Results just show again that the codex is a joke nobody takes serious. Hell we never even got a review of the most succesful CRPG ever made.

The results where analyzed in this thread, there is no link between putting 1/5 on BG3 and giving JA3 a good score.

Also that BG3 features divisive content is a valid reason to Vote for it 1/5,

The difference is, JA3 didn't get edgelords who didnt play it giving it 1/5 scores.

Hell JA3 isn't even an RPG. Just more proof this site is a joke that has become completely irrelevant.

Why would anyone give JA3 a 1/5 though anyways? It's not shit, unlike BG3.

Keep coping, this edegelord GOTY won't change the facts.

As another said: “shit’s great, a million flies can’t be wrong” eh?

https://goty.gamefa.com/

Tell me who won most GOTY awards

Sure but it seems Codex GOTY means more to you or you would not be spamming this topic so much lol.

Because it's a retarded result.

If it wasn't for the woke shit you would all be sucking my dick. BG3 is literally the best CRPG ever made.

If it wasn't for larian decorating the corpse of an ip that someone else made, it would just be original sin 3 and no one would care about it at all.

 

[ArchAngel]

It's interesting to see Konjad defending Codex's honor on RPG Watch, and people there just not getting it.

Post link pliz

https://rpgwatch.com/forum/threads/rpg-codex-goty-2023-results.57851/

Of course faggot Mortmal got bullied here, so he went to RPGWatch to cry how awful and toxic and worthless Codex is

Nope, I was replying to HiddenX, who no longer posts here, by the way. That statement is incorrect. People don't love Jagged Alliance 3 here most voters never played it; they hate on BG3. Now I'm not even sure if it's worth trying or if it's another Elex.

This.

People wanted to bully me so they voted for a game they never played and gave it a 1/5.

Results just show again that the codex is a joke nobody takes serious. Hell we never even got a review of the most succesful CRPG ever made.

The results where analyzed in this thread, there is no link between putting 1/5 on BG3 and giving JA3 a good score.

Also that BG3 features divisive content is a valid reason to Vote for it 1/5,

The difference is, JA3 didn't get edgelords who didnt play it giving it 1/5 scores.

Hell JA3 isn't even an RPG. Just more proof this site is a joke that has become completely irrelevant.

Why would anyone give JA3 a 1/5 though anyways? It's not shit, unlike BG3.

Keep coping, this edegelord GOTY won't change the facts.

As another said: “shit’s great, a million flies can’t be wrong” eh?

https://goty.gamefa.com/

Tell me who won most GOTY awards

Sure but it seems Codex GOTY means more to you or you would not be spamming this topic so much lol.

Because it's a retarded result.

If it wasn't for the woke shit you would all be sucking my dick. BG3 is literally the best CRPG ever made.

I do not know about others but I quit DOS1 half way, never bother to play DOS2, read even before release BG3 is just DOS with DnD coat of paint and then when it released I tried to watch some streams but both VO and character of companions was bad and irritating so that was enough for me. The woke shit was just extra.

 

[AwesomeButton]

Now for a list that actually matters



Keep crying codex, you're irrelevant

I watched this two days ago and considered posting it.

I'm far from the edgiest user on this forum nowadays, but this is brain cancer material distilled in video format. Could have named it "The ultimate casual gaymer perspective" if he was self-aware enough.

Watch at your own risk.

 

[BosanskiSeljak]

Yeah..people like to big up MortismalGaming, I've even seen it here but he has the most banal, milquetoast casual takes consistently.

I've watched a few, he got me with his stupid "after 100%", and not once has he said something insightful.

 

[AwesomeButton]

Yeah..people like to big up MortismalGaming, I've even seen it here but he has the most banal, milquetoast casual takes consistently.

I've watched a few, he got me with his stupid "after 100%", and not once has he said something insightful.

One wonders what does he consider "100%-ing" an RPG. All the achievements?

I'm quite sure he is one of the crowd who think "c" in cRPG stands for "classic".