Community RPG Codex GOTY 2023: Results & Cool Graphs

[ERYFKRAD]

No downvoting or playing the system = results more acceptable for everyone.

Nix, as long as people's votes aren't hacked it's a legit vote, whether you like it or not.

 

[Strange Fellow]

It's not a free and fair vote unless you allow people to vote unseriously. I'd be delighted to hear what the alternative is.

I just proposed an alternative one post above yours. We use this system every few years for the 'greatest 101' lists.

And what's to stop people from giving 5 points to BG3's closest competitors? There is no such thing as a voting system that can't be gamed.

 

[ERYFKRAD]

There is no such thing as a voting system that can't be gamed

Especially apropos when we're voting about games lmao

 

[Swen]

Funny, how much crying there is for something people supposedly don't care about. Ja3 winning GOTY struck butthurt gold. BG3 wins every other gay reward, but can't take losing out on one specific one - that makes me think this reward is actually much more prestigious than I initially thought.

I even won second place in this rigged edgelord poll, even the haters couldn't push me out of the top 3. Another Codex L

 

[PsihoKekec]

You may not like what was done to the BearSexStimulator, but you must admit that the sheer hilarity of Swen's butthurt meltdown makes it worth it. There are few modern games that trump the entertainment value of post GOTY 2023 drama.

Yes bro, the """award""" that doesn't even get acknowledged by the winners is the only thing that matters.

Holy fck at the cope and delusions. Amazing

Such butthurt, it's like I sneaked into your place and coated your favourite dildo in tabasco sauce. Which I didn't.

Might want to change the lube though.

 

[Swen]

You may not like what was done to the BearSexStimulator, but you must admit that the sheer hilarity of Swen's butthurt meltdown makes it worth it. There are few modern games that trump the entertainment value of post GOTY 2023 drama.

Yes bro, the """award""" that doesn't even get acknowledged by the winners is the only thing that matters.

Holy fck at the cope and delusions. Amazing

Such butthurt, it's like I sneaked into your place and coated your favourite dildo in tabasco sauce. Which I didn't.

Might want to change the lube though.

The only dildo is my dick that your mom uses faggot.

 

[Ladonna]

Funny, how much crying there is for something people supposedly don't care about. Ja3 winning GOTY struck butthurt gold. BG3 wins every other gay reward, but can't take losing out on one specific one - that makes me think this reward is actually much more prestigious than I initially thought.

I even won second place in this rigged edgelord poll, even the haters couldn't push me out of the top 3. Another Codex L

"I"? "me"?

Do you have an identity that isn't tied to Baldur's Gate 3?

 

[Lord_Potato]

It's not a free and fair vote unless you allow people to vote unseriously. I'd be delighted to hear what the alternative is.

I just proposed an alternative one post above yours. We use this system every few years for the 'greatest 101' lists.

And what's to stop people from giving 5 points to BG3's closest competitors? There is no such thing as a voting system that can't be gamed.

Nothing. But such a system makes downvoting impossible.

 

[Strange Fellow]

It's not a free and fair vote unless you allow people to vote unseriously. I'd be delighted to hear what the alternative is.

I just proposed an alternative one post above yours. We use this system every few years for the 'greatest 101' lists.

And what's to stop people from giving 5 points to BG3's closest competitors? There is no such thing as a voting system that can't be gamed.

Nothing. But such a system makes downvoting impossible.

Inflating the score of every other game is effectively the same thing.

 

[Lord_Potato]

And what's to stop people from giving 5 points to BG3's closest competitors? There is no such thing as a voting system that can't be gamed.

Nothing. But such a system makes downvoting impossible.

Inflating the score of every other game is effectively the same thing.

Perhaps, but it's less vile.

 

[Strange Fellow]

Hey, if what you want is to call the strategic voters retards, I'm right with you.

 

[Swen]

The only real "poll" that matter are from people who are confirmed to have played it aka Steam user reviews.


This codex "award" is on par with unconfirmed user reviews from metacritic, complete and utter joke. But somehow the losers here are deluding themselves this "award" matters because BG3 is such a big success and has mind broken them for life.

 

[ERYFKRAD]

The only real "poll" that matter are from people who are confirmed to have played it aka Steam user reviews.


This codex "award" is on par with unconfirmed user reviews from metacritic, complete and utter joke. But somehow the losers here are deluding themselves this "award" matters because BG3 is such a big success and has mind broken them for life.

If it's such a humbug, why are you referring to it so much?

 

[Swen]

The only real "poll" that matter are from people who are confirmed to have played it aka Steam user reviews.


This codex "award" is on par with unconfirmed user reviews from metacritic, complete and utter joke. But somehow the losers here are deluding themselves this "award" matters because BG3 is such a big success and has mind broken them for life.

If it's such a humbug, why are you referring to it so much?

Because some retards here actually believe this is some kind of presitigious award when it's a joke. It's literal pure cope by losers with pent up anger of BG3 being so successful.

 

[Lord_Potato]

I think 'prestigious' is an old meme in regard to RPG Codex. Don't worry about it too much

 

[Dadd]

I would worry about it a lot

 

[Dadd]

You may laugh but name me RPG awards more prestigious than RPGCODEX GOTY in 2024

 

[Lord_Potato]

You may laugh but name me RPG awards more prestigious than RPGCODEX GOTY in 2024

 

[Hellraiser]

You may laugh but name me RPG awards more prestigious than RPGCODEX GOTY in 2024

Well, those certainly give the codex a run for its money as far as competing for the top spot of the most gay awards goes.

 

[H. P. Lovecraft's Cat]

Console exclusive games that get ported to PC a year or later down the road should be eligible for GOTY in the year they were ported over. Also console games that can be emulated should count. My hot take.

 

[Lord of Riva]

LOl, even members of the JA3 steam forums see that our voting was rigged

That was a mod not a developer. Doesn't help that he does not understand how our polls work.

Lord of Riva I see you created a similar topic on the JA3 steam forum. Can't believe the same butthurt BG3 fans are there too lol. "WE CAN'T ACCEPT THIS OUTCOME". Anyway, you deserve a few Steam awards for your bravery

Yeah they are so "not Butthurt" they are following me around on steam, this shit is hilarious.

https://steamcommunity.com/app/1084160

LOL nobody gives a fck about your fake "award" faggots.

Codex delusions destroyed once again, :D

I like how an award by the actual target audience is less valid than an award specifically created to award games with gay inclusion. That makes total sense.

The only real "poll" that matter are from people who are confirmed to have played it aka Steam user reviews.


This codex "award" is on par with unconfirmed user reviews from metacritic, complete and utter joke. But somehow the losers here are deluding themselves this "award" matters because BG3 is such a big success and has mind broken them for life.

There are no other stores than steam around, a very reasonable proposition.

 

[Lord of Riva]

Console exclusive games that get ported to PC a year or later down the road should be eligible for GOTY in the year they were ported over. Also console games that can be emulated should count. My hot take.

I have no opinion on the first, I fail to see why it is problematic to have ports in. However games that are able to be emulated would be bound by emulator development, which is incredibly odd. Especially since a lot of games are "playable" but not well emulated at all, some even for decades.

 

[Nifft Batuff]

The seething continues. Good, good

someone asked before for a qualifier on how the ja3/bg3 shills voted on each others gayme... well... .. .
are you ready!?

so, our hypotheses will be that bg3 cucks were butthurt and voted ja3 down
how do we prove this? well, the simplest methodology will be taking users who have both games rated and
calculate the difference between the ratings and then average that delta out, no weighing
eg: shill rating bg 5 and ja 1 has a delta of 4 and avr of 4 cause he is alone

AND THE RESULTS AAAAAAAAAAAAAARE!

BG3 BUTTHURT COEFFICIENT OF ONLY 1.37 !

JA3 BUTTHURT HYPERPARAMETER OF 2.17 !!!

So, there are more JA3 cucks that downvoted BG3 than vice versa?

 

[Lord of Riva]

So, there are more JA3 cucks that downvoted BG3 than vice versa?

They have finally found an angle, let's just ignore that the JA3 votes are completely organic.

 

[Swen]

The seething continues. Good, good

someone asked before for a qualifier on how the ja3/bg3 shills voted on each others gayme... well... .. .
are you ready!?

so, our hypotheses will be that bg3 cucks were butthurt and voted ja3 down
how do we prove this? well, the simplest methodology will be taking users who have both games rated and
calculate the difference between the ratings and then average that delta out, no weighing
eg: shill rating bg 5 and ja 1 has a delta of 4 and avr of 4 cause he is alone

AND THE RESULTS AAAAAAAAAAAAAARE!

BG3 BUTTHURT COEFFICIENT OF ONLY 1.37 !

JA3 BUTTHURT HYPERPARAMETER OF 2.17 !!!

So, there are more JA3 cucks that downvoted BG3 than vice versa?

Of course, it's all rigged.