Gord said:
Awor Szurkrarz said:
I don't pass it as anything. I'm just saying that dislike for personal use piracy (except for the retarded "I won't buy anything that is available for free" fanatics which are basically the ones that publishers keep talking about in practical sense when they talk about stealing.) is stupid. Like in being objectively stupid. Unless one is filthy rich, that is because then there's no practical difference in abilities to buy goods of culture and experience them.
When one has let's say 50PLN per month to spend on let's say music albums, just buying one album instead of buying one album and downloading let's say another two because the magic copyright god makes it somehow wrong is pretty stupid as there are no practical negative consequences of downloading additional music for anyone and there are big positive practical consequences of doing it.
Ok, this wasn't directed against you, more against those who do try to pass off piracy for some great fight for freedom in the 21st century (which is often as stupid as the "I won't buy anything that is available for free" fanatics, only difference being that they feel entitled to get everything for free).
Now, I understand your arguments, but as I'm probably a moral-fag I still have some problems with it.
Yes, you don't create a loss, but still you acquire something without offering anything in return. Somehow that just doesn't feel completely right to me.
It's a purely abstract problem, not a practical one, though. It comes to a point when a concept (that acquiring something requires offering something) stops being a tool for achieving good (people being able to live from their creations and prosper) and avoiding evil (people losing time and effort or some item for you and receiving nothing in return - note that there's often a confusion between a product and work. Game isn't work and work on gaming wasn't for you, it was for producing a sellable product, therefore one can't say that they did a service to you or made that product for you - the existence of product or work done to create that product isn't connected to your person but to existence of a market for that product.) and becomes a value in itself, without any practical application.
One practical application of the concepts that I talk about (the people whose products is acquired for free gaining from it) is that it alters spending patterns of the person using them in favour of those whose products .
Basically, most of music that I listen to now is because of acquiring unauthorised copies in the past and the same applies to future. Before ability to get music for free from the internets, my music choices were very conservative and they involved buying music from "safe" bands like Metallica, Ramstein or Rage Against the Machine.
I started listening to Cradle of Filth only because of a cassette that I have found in a bargain bin (which I have bought, but it shows a general principle - getting something for free or extremely cheap and then buying more) - later I bought 3 other of their cassettes and a CD - I didn't like it at first, but I started to love it after listening through the cassette and reading the lyrics (mp3s allowed me later to avoid their Nymphetamine album).
I started to listen to Dimmu Borgir because I have found a CD-R with it in a journalism club and I got intrigued by it though I have found it rather tiring. Later I asked my friend to record me that album and I listened it with lyrics and loved it. I bought two their cassettes - since back then I had a rather obnoxious habit of listening to music without headphones, my mother became their fan too. We bought 5 their CDs (after listening to unauthorised copies) during a period of about 2 years. We made an error of buying their latest album without pirating it first and it turned out to be their
album that we have listened to maybe 4 times.
I started to listen to Behemoth because I saw their video at friend's house. I didn't really like it - it just sounded like an aggressive noise. As a form of a joke I decided to listen the whole album when reading lyrics and I have found it awesome - I bought that album on CD (it was much less expensive than the western albums) and then I one their cassette and 4 other CDs and a T-shirt. Luckily I listened to a pirated version of their last album and didn't buy it as it declined significantly.
Another band that I started to listen through piracy was Emperor - I heard someone citing it as their influence and I downloaded one their pirated video. I found it kinda silly and weird, but a few time I played it as a joke at my friends house and it kinda grew on me and I downloaded the album that it was from and listened it with lyrics and loved it. I didn't have money for a CD then, though and there was no cassette, so I have bought their another album on cassette. During following years I have bought three their CDs (which I have pirated before) and 3 CDs from side project of their vocalist and 1 album of their vocalist.
In recent times, a few years ago, one day I have found a band called Massemord (and another one called Zyklon-B which turned out to include the vocalist of the Emperor - I have bought their CD a few months ago) after thinking that there should be misanthropic black metal and searching for it on YouTube. I have found their pirated songs there and then downloaded a few of their albums and listened to them with lyrics and I loved them. I bought their CD (only one because the rest went out of print) and two their vinyls (thanks to ability to download mp3s I don't have to care whenever I have a playing device or not - so I started buying vinyls because they are so big and feel much more exclusive) I also discovered that they are a kind of a band that basically does several project and I downloaded and later bought 3 CDs and 1 vinyl (a vinyl-only release - I wouldn't be able to listen to it and buy it without ) from their Furia project, one CD from their FDS project and 1 CD from their CCSSABA project (this one I have bought blindly). I'm looking forward to buying a vinyl from another project of theirs called Morowe. I have recently found out that there's a new exclusive vinyl release from CCSSABA but I can't buy it because no one bothered to rip it and I don't have a vinyl player.
Thus I have demonstrated the good coming from the practical application of the concepts that I was talking about. Of course it applies to multiple disciplines - movies, comic books, games, etc.
Generally, it allows potential customers to learn of new products, to learn to like new kinds of products, become fans of products before buying them, and discover interesting qualities of products that they wouldn't be able to learn of through official channels. It's like a reverse advertising where the customers looks for new products (as it doesn't carry any risk).
It applies less to books and libraries unless the books have exclusive illustrated/decorated editions, though. Which is pretty ironic taking in account that libraries are completely legal and almost no one calls borrowing books "stealing".