Putting the 'role' back in role-playing games since 2002.
Donate to Codex
Good Old Games
  • Welcome to rpgcodex.net, a site dedicated to discussing computer based role-playing games in a free and open fashion. We're less strict than other forums, but please refer to the rules.

    "This message is awaiting moderator approval": All new users must pass through our moderation queue before they will be able to post normally. Until your account has "passed" your posts will only be visible to yourself (and moderators) until they are approved. Give us a week to get around to approving / deleting / ignoring your mundane opinion on crap before hassling us about it. Once you have passed the moderation period (think of it as a test), you will be able to post normally, just like all the other retards.

KickStarter Stoneshard - open world roguelike RPG - now available on Early Access

Sykar

Arcane
Joined
Dec 2, 2014
Messages
11,297
Location
Turn right after Alpha Centauri
So when will we get an update in relation to new skill sets? Would love to see more than geomancy and pyromancy for example for casters.
 

Abu Antar

Turn-based Poster
Patron
Joined
Jan 19, 2014
Messages
13,581
Enjoy the Revolution! Another revolution around the sun that is. Shadorwun: Hong Kong Divinity: Original Sin 2 Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire Pathfinder: Wrath I'm very into cock and ball torture I helped put crap in Monomyth
All Events > Stoneshard Events >

Devlog: Changes to the Leveling System
eb0f31b02582278904b34abb4576a1e13cf85087.png


Hello everyone!

In today’s devlog we’ll tell you about changes to the leveling system that will be introduced with the City of Gold update.

ATTRIBUTES

As we observed choices made by players when building their characters, we found out the following things:

  • Players rarely spread points between multiple Attributes - both stat points gained upon leveling up are usually invested into a single Attribute to receive a more noticeable increase in power.
  • Primary Attributes affect too many secondary stats: it’s difficult to keep track of them for most players, and leveling usually comes down to focusing on 1 or 2 build-defining stats.
  • Some primary Attributes are way too important for certain archetypes while being pretty much ignored by others.

That’s why we decided to revise our old Attributes system:

  • All Attributes are now
    capped at 30 points
    .
  • Each Attribute governs only
    two secondary stats
    .
  • You only gain
    one stat point
    upon leveling up, but its impact is now much more noticeable.
  • Each primary Attribute now also has
    thresholds
    - upon reaching them your character will receive a powerful bonus to 3 additional stats. Each Attribute has 4 thresholds that you can reach - 15, 20, 25, and 30 points.

    We noticed that many players enjoy investing into Perception for much-desired Bonus Range breakpoints - it’s one of the reasons why we’re introducing a similar twist to other Attributes, making leveling more engaging and providing players with goals to pursue.
  • The bonuses to characters’ starting Attributes were reduced.

cdc18be7bd3c9a65572a4e9115f1ee3834eaf648.png

Full Size Image


All these changes will require you to put more thought into building your characters - many important stats are only increased upon reaching an Attribute threshold, so you’ll have a lot of things to consider: shall you put your precious SP into Vitality to gain bonus Health? Perhaps it’s more worthwhile to invest into Perception for Accuracy and Crit Chance? Or maybe the best course of action is to continue pushing Strength, hoping that its bonus Damage will offset the characters’ shortcomings? The decision is yours to make.

LEARNING ABILITIES

We closely monitor our community’s feedback, and it’s apparent that many players consider the existing treatise system to be way too restrictive and irritating. Unsurprisingly, many people try to circumvent it by resetting traders’ stock or even by editing save files. It’s not the most desirable outcome, so that’s why we’re also making important changes to another key mechanic - how Abilities are learned.

19247c5f7d4ab82d781ad7c7615e7249dc613ae4.png

Full Size Image

b01d31735e1d5b204a1805e8ae2eb34f52f1e7e7.png

Full Size Image

This example is WIP and is subject to change. To better understand the context make sure to read the final paragraph of the list below.


  • We’ve
    reworked the structure
    of every Ability tree in the game. They now look cleaner and should provide better indication about which tier each Ability belongs to.

  • Most Ability trees now have significantly
    more starting paths
    . This should make early combat more fun and reduce the frequency of situations when players are forced to stockpile points because they run out of Abilities to invest them into.

    a3f51db71db26c726c6ccafcb14aa311c9da464e.gif


  • Some Ability trees have a
    new type of link - a node
    . Nodes indicate that in order to unlock Abilities below them, you’ll first have to unlock every Ability linked to them.

    This change will reduce highly prominent power spikes that are detrimental to the overall balance - you will no longer be able to quickly cherry-pick active abilities while ignoring everything else. Before the rework, the deadly combo of “Incineration” and “Melting Ray” could be unlocked just after putting 2 points into Pyromancy, but now you’ll have to learn all 8 prerequisite Abilities before you gain access to it. To sum it up, expect mages to become less overpowered.

  • At the same time, the
    opening tiers are much more flexible
    - the new system will provide you with more opportunities to grab a few starting Abilities to round up your build, but if you plan to gain access to high-level Abilities, you’ll need to actually invest.

    4f71372047275bdeb18b223e7e9133a195574601.png


  • With the exception of the first tier, Abilities now have
    Attribute requirements
    as an alternative to learning them from treatises. Still, we don’t want the system to be too restrictive, so the requirements are fairly adaptable: as a general rule, you’ll have to invest a certain amount of points into a combined sum of relevant Attributes in any combination you want. For instance, if an Ability requires 6 points invested into Strength or Agility, you can unlock it by putting all 6 points into either Strength or Agility, by putting 2 points into Strength and 4 into Agility, and so on.

    To put it simply, you have a choice between unlocking Abilities on your own by fulfilling their Attribute requirements and searching for a treatise if you want to unlock them earlier or plan to forego Attribute requirements entirely (in case they aren’t supported by your build)

  • In addition to treatises,
    starting Abilities can also be unlocked by trainers
    - for a price, of course. Most trainers are Osbrook and Mannshire NPCs whom you’re already familiar with, which means that you’ll be able to unlock all Ability trees (except for magic and Dual Wielding, the trainers for which are located in Brynn) right from the beginning without specifically looking for a relevant treatise.

  • These changes will elevate treatises back to their intended place as rare and valuable loot. In addition to that,
    treatises are no longer sold by village merchants
    - you’ll have to search for them in dungeons, points of interest, or buy them from designated traders in Brynn. The Mannshire scribe’s stock was also reduced: instead of selling every single book in Aldor, he’ll only have a small selection of tomes that survived the siege.

  • Many passives (as well as some active Abilities) were
    massively reworked
    to increase their usefulness and versatility, making them a better fit for the reworked Ability trees, so don’t be too swift to judge the presented changes.


===============================

Until the next devlog!
 

Teut Busnet

Cipher
Patron
Joined
Dec 31, 2016
Messages
961
Codex Year of the Donut
Aka how we killed the game.

(Meanwhile, players are still awaiting character generator. It's been 3 years and counting.)
Ok, you have implemented 50% of the abilities a player can choose from when building his Character. Do you:


a) finish the other half, so you can then fine tune and balance them afterwards, knowing how they will all affect each other, what is OP, what is fun, etc

b) fiddle around with what's already there for two years while ignoring often requested features and watch your STEAM ratings drop to under 60%

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Tygrende

Arbiter
Joined
Aug 2, 2017
Messages
872
  • a3f51db71db26c726c6ccafcb14aa311c9da464e.gif


  • Some Ability trees have a
    new type of link - a node. Nodes indicate that in order to unlock Abilities below them, you’ll first have to unlock every Ability linked to them.
I don't like this in particular. Just about any solution would be better than forcing people to take multiple abilities they don't want for the sake of getting what they actually want.
 

cyborgboy95

News Cyborg
Joined
Aug 24, 2019
Messages
2,767
https://store.steampowered.com/news/app/625960/view/3078767482782696187

Devlog: Rumor System & Artifacts
8f8e27f6866dc25f59711f8d7d8da35327b1f78d.png


Hello everyone!

The City of Gold is almost here! Before its release on November 18th, we plan to publish one more devlog with a summary of the update’s most important changes and additions. Today, however, we’d like to tell you about two previously unannounced systems.
Rumor System

Rumors are closely tied to the new global map. As you may recall from its designated devlog, the global map will be initially concealed in the fog of war that you need to clear by exploring the world.
The same principle applies to Points of Interest, the location of which will be hidden until you stumble upon them yourself or learn about them from rumors.

Rumors are scraps of the latest news, gossip, and other interesting information, mostly exaggerated and sometimes not matching the reality at all. This mechanic is already partially present in the game: most NPCs can be chatted up to learn their thoughts about recent events, although this feature currently doesn’t have any gameplay applications.

KOi7ZRs.gif


After the CoG update, talking with some characters will actually provide you with valuable information, usually hinting at nearby POIs, which will then be marked on the global map. Different types of Points of Interest will have their own rumors associated with them: you’ll be able to learn about nearby camps, hunting grounds, monster dens, unique locations, distant dungeons, and so on.

Keep in mind that sometimes NPCs will request payment for valuable rumors, so make sure to bring your gold purse when fishing for information. If you fail to learn anything useful on your first attempt, don’t be discouraged - you’ll be able to try again in a few days.

Artifacts

be92a8a1e310d57d992a2f377cf63fb7155a4f36.png


Let’s talk about artifacts, a new type of loot with special properties. Artifacts are powerful relics of both recent and ancient past, some of them even dating back to antiquity. They’re usually imbued with mystical properties and can greatly benefit your character if you’re willing to sacrifice inventory space to carry them around.

Artifacts function as unique items: each of them can only be acquired once per playthrough. You’ll be able to find them in distant dungeons - dangerous locations situated far from settlements. These distant dungeons don’t have contracts associated with them, so you’ll have to either find them on your own or rely on rumors.

f0ab902482c87658f5bbfe8b67e9a0280033ef53.jpg


In the future, we might introduce additional means of acquiring artifacts: you’ll be able to find some of them in special locations, and others - in secret rooms or during quests. But for now, here are some of the artifacts you’ll have a chance to encounter in this update:

Casket with St Wald Relics

f3503bff4a5c53c4d69b4a8204eae4e47fa32624.png


“St Wald, one of the first Aldorian saints, left his mark in history as a great preacher and an implacable enemy of heretics and the wicked. His relics are said to possess miraculous properties, capable of warding off the evil eye and cleansing malicious curses”


Effect:
grants +30% Unholy Resistance and immunity to the “Curse” effect.

Codex of the Triple Hand Order

25ff2d42d474712fdc447d7212ebeea10b359c96.png


“This hefty tome is written in the Order's notorious code which no one has yet managed to crack. It's rumored that this book was blessed by all three Hands of the Host, and that it contains the full history of the Order and every mystery of creation they were privy to…”


Effect:
killing undead or Proselyte enemies has 25% chance to grant “Blessing” for 100 turns.

Nikos of Arpheon's Astrolabe

3b26159991952aa57df1d78ec42aae1683a51fe4.png


“Nikos of Arpheon was perhaps the greatest seafarer known to the world. He was the first one to make a successful voyage around the Continent about a century ago. Even in the eye of Southern storms or amid icebergs of the North, Nikos's unparalleled skill as a navigator allowed him to always keep his ship on the chosen course”


Effect:
can be used on the surface during night time once per day. Upon activation, grants the effect of “Clear Vision” for 2880 turns, boosting Crit Chance, Accuracy, Vision, and Bonus Range.

Blessed Aquamanile

9b3d66589874b688da6cca6735d91b8f5f580db8.png


“A bronze jug in the form of a lion, expertly crafted on the Bronze Isles by an unknown master. Somehow this aquamanile found its way to Aldor, where it was blessed by the Archtheurgist of the High Hieron himself to serve as an eternal source of water to those dying of thirst - whenever emptied, it miraculously refills itself”


Effect:
can be used once per day. Upon activation, sates 50% Thirst and also replenishes 25% Health and 15% Condition to each body part.

=============

That’s all for now. Until the next devlog!
 

Wayfinder

Ink Stains Games
Developer
Joined
May 31, 2017
Messages
30
Ok, you have implemented 50% of the abilities a player can choose from when building his Character. Do you:


a) finish the other half, so you can then fine tune and balance them afterwards, knowing how they will all affect each other, what is OP, what is fun, etc

b) fiddle around with what's already there for two years while ignoring often requested features and watch your STEAM ratings drop to under 60%

In reality a) would rather sound like "finish the other half of the abilities in an initially flawed form, while realizing they still have to be redone in a very different way, so it would take even more time to rework them later". Is it really that difficult to grasp that ability progression doesn't exist in a vacuum and can't be just "fine tuned afterwards"? It's one of the core systems of any RPG, tightly connected with other game-defining stuff like player power scaling, enemy power scaling, content distribution and so on, and so on. Delaying the much needed rework before "finishing everything else" basically means you'll also need to revisit and rework said "everything else".

I don't like this in particular. Just about any solution would be better than forcing people to take multiple abilities they don't want for the sake of getting what they actually want.
Except it already worked liked that with the endgame abilities locked behind several other abilities you need to learn first. That's how ability skill trees work in general, it's hardly a novel concept in role-playing games.

If you want some good stuff you need to invest, yes, and considering most abilities are designed to heavily synergize with one another taking a few passives along the way is hardly a heavy toll for that.

If anything, it creates more build variety because of new branched starts and easier multiclassing.
 

Teut Busnet

Cipher
Patron
Joined
Dec 31, 2016
Messages
961
Codex Year of the Donut
Ok, you have implemented 50% of the abilities a player can choose from when building his Character. Do you:


a) finish the other half, so you can then fine tune and balance them afterwards, knowing how they will all affect each other, what is OP, what is fun, etc

b) fiddle around with what's already there for two years while ignoring often requested features and watch your STEAM ratings drop to under 60%

In reality a) would rather sound like "finish the other half of the abilities in an initially flawed form, while realizing they still have to be redone in a very different way, so it would take even more time to rework them later". Is it really that difficult to grasp that ability progression doesn't exist in a vacuum and can't be just "fine tuned afterwards"? It's one of the core systems of any RPG, tightly connected with other game-defining stuff like player power scaling, enemy power scaling, content distribution and so on, and so on. Delaying the much needed rework before "finishing everything else" basically means you'll also need to revisit and rework said "everything else".

I don't like this in particular. Just about any solution would be better than forcing people to take multiple abilities they don't want for the sake of getting what they actually want.
Except it already worked liked that with the endgame abilities locked behind several other abilities you need to learn first. That's how ability skill trees work in general, it's hardly a novel concept in role-playing games.

If you want some good stuff you need to invest, yes, and considering most abilities are designed to heavily synergize with one another taking a few passives along the way is hardly a heavy toll for that.

If anything, it creates more build variety because of new branched starts and easier multiclassing.
Your 'Prologue' came out in June of 2018.

What I find 'difficult to grasp' is that you would need over three fucking years to create half of a 'not flawed' - and not even very substantial - skill tree.

Were you responsible for handing out car permits in the USSR?
 
Last edited:

Tygrende

Arbiter
Joined
Aug 2, 2017
Messages
872
Except it already worked liked that with the endgame abilities locked behind several other abilities you need to learn first. That's how ability skill trees work in general, it's hardly a novel concept in role-playing games.

If you want some good stuff you need to invest, yes, and considering most abilities are designed to heavily synergize with one another taking a few passives along the way is hardly a heavy toll for that.

If anything, it creates more build variety because of new branched starts and easier multiclassing.
No, it didn't work like that before, the scale was different. It wasn't necessary to pick 4 different skills of the same tier to just unlock the next one.

If anything, it has strong potential to cause less build variety - more builds will end up samey because they are forced to pick the same abilities to unlock other abilities. I will abstain from judging the actual implementation until I actually see it in-game though. It's not like I have any reason to believe it's coming any time soon.
 

jackofshadows

Magister
Joined
Oct 21, 2019
Messages
4,545
If anything, it creates more build variety because of new branched starts and easier multiclassing.
Are you taking your audience for morons or something? It literally goes the other way around. Both in terms of build variety and multiclassing.
 

Wayfinder

Ink Stains Games
Developer
Joined
May 31, 2017
Messages
30
Your 'Prologue' came out in June of 2018.

What I find 'difficult to grasp' is that you would need over three fucking years to create half of a 'not flawed' - and not even very substantial - skill tree.

Were you responsible for handing out car permits in the USSR?
Maybe when you'll find out that skills were far from being the only priority and Prologue was merely a proof of concept prototype it'll get easier for you to grasp it as well. Like, you can download the old Prologue and see what (everything) was changed and was added since then. Should really help.
But yeah, how dare the devs take feedback to revise and improve something.

No, it didn't work like that before, the scale was different. It wasn't necessary to pick 4 different skills of the same tier to just unlock the next one.

If anything, it has strong potential to cause less build variety - more builds will end up samey because they are forced to pick the same abilities to unlock other abilities. I will abstain from judging the actual implementation until I actually see it in-game though. It's not like I have any reason to believe it's coming any time soon.

You are not required to pick 4 different skills in every single tree to progress further. The GIF in the devlog is just an example of a skill tree that has the whole first tier noded - because the Massacre is one of the best stances in the game and the Execution is the best non-magical single-target nuke. But that's not how every branch works. Check out other screenshots, the only other skill trees that does that are 2-handed maces and 2-handed axes for the similar reasons. All other branches are much more freeform which makes dabbling in them for non-specialized characters easier.

Here's the Pyromancy, for example, to demonstrate:

pyro.gif


Yes, getting Inferno requires you to master almost everything else (which is lore-friendly and balanced considering the immense power of this spell), but you have more options at the start and getting to a certain tier III spell isn't locked behind all other previous tiers.
In the current build you need to learn Fire Barrage and Blaze before unlocking, say, Ring of Fire or some pyromantic passive as a melee or hybrid char; now it has more entry points which actually increases the number of possible combinations. After all, character building in Stoneshard rather comes from combining several skill trees than having various ways to level up a single one.

Are you taking your audience for morons or something? It literally goes the other way around. Both in terms of build variety and multiclassing.
Read the devlog and check the screenshots again, it's definitely not my issue.

Char creation when
Literally the next thing we'll start working on after the global map alongside with new magic.
 

As an Amazon Associate, rpgcodex.net earns from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top Bottom