Zorba the Hutt
Arcane
- Joined
- Dec 14, 2012
- Messages
- 1,865,753
I don't have to look, i was there, i voted for KotC. Knights of the Chalice is one of the best translations of d&d ruleset into computer game ever made - and it lost because of not-so-prestigious individuals who (obviously because of their bad taste in games) voted DA:O. Take it as you wish. I, as a codexer, wasbutthurtashamed because of this. And still am. Also i feel a little less presigious since then .
Yes, still can't believe DA:O beat KOTC.
http://www.rpgcodex.net/forums/index.php?threads/rpg-of-the-year-2009.38358/
I voted DA
Whatever, voted for Dragon Age.
Only played DA out of all those games, so DA.
Dragon Age, both on its own merits, and because the notion that someone might like it causes simpletons to have kittens, which is enjoyable in itself.
It has been a slow year couple of years.
Only played DA and MoW, and DA wins that by a long shot.
Out of this lot I played Drakensang, Risen and DA.
Drakensang was crap.
Risen was good old G2 and I liked it a lot.
But in the end I voted DA because of its scope and lenght.
Dragon Age.
ENCHANTMENT!
dont see the results as disappointing. any codexer whose opinion is worth jackshit was pleasantly suprised by DA even though nobody went as far as claiming it the best game ever..... the rest is the meme-morons who simply want to show their hardcore, oldschool attitude ignoring that most of them were still pissing their pants during the golden age of cRPGs , know them only from hearsay & GoG and cant even tell apart an action-adventure from a proper cRPG.
there might be a few exceptions like skyway
Not sure who VD voted for:
A lot of titles, not much to choose from:
Knights of the Chalice - the best TB crawler since ToEE. Possibly even better than ToEE.
Risen - pretty good, Chapter 1 - brilliant, "game" of the year, overall it falls short. The latter chapters are dumb hack-n-slash. It's still a pretty good game, but...
Dragon Age - far from perfect, but very enjoyable and has plenty of role-playing options. Tactical combat doesn't hurt either.
I thought DA was the KC option