Mark.L.Joy
Prophet
- Joined
- Sep 11, 2016
- Messages
- 1,284
And Skyrim wins
In what way do Daggerfall dungeons feel “natural”? Cellars in Morrowind feel like cellars, not like a Kraken orgy that got caught up in a volcanic eruption and preserved for all eternity like those dudes at Pompeii. Like, it is a reasonable opinion that Daggerfall dungeons are better than Morrowind, but more natural they aren’t.
Also
Wizardry 8 is far superior to Wiz7
FTFY
not talking about cellar-dungeons (these aren't natural at all) but talking about real dungeons. they are caves that got inhabited by skeletons/necromancers/monsters etc. you can get lost in them - just like you can get lost in caves in real life. the dungeons in Morrowind+ are what caves would look like, which have been built for tourists in DisneyLand.
Our currently prestigious top-70 is at risk of being polluted/diluted/supplanted, which list will show up on a Google search
But first we would need a poll asking if this thread needs a poll.This thread should've been a poll.
It's an arcade game, but weaboo people want to push their fucking agenda. Filthy.Can we stop pretending that Dark Souls is an RPG in this thread? Please? I can't stand this much decline...
This can be solved more easily by giving the game a +50% modifier if it was released for DOS, and a -50% modifier if it had a console release.older games at a disadvantage.
Nationalist polacks did it.The fact that people put games like Witcher 3
Gays and trans on coke did it.D:OS
The Weaboo did it.and Dark Souls.
The fact that people put underrail above Wiz7-8, Krondor, World of Xeen and ToEE is indicative of the absolute state of decline we're in.
Or maybe people should stop classifying action games as cRPGs because this is retarded.So maybe having action-RPG's.
We can do one list of all-time greats, and then several lists of the RPGs broken down into categories.Would be cool if there were subcategories this time.
I think Dark Souls is a fine game but have a hard time comparing it to Wizardry 7. Or to compare Deus Ex to Dark Sun. Both fine games but hard to put in the same box.
So maybe having action-RPG's, isometric RPG's, strategy RPG's, jRPG's etc in separate sections would be helpful. The hard part would be defining in which subgenre a game would fit (I'm sure a lot would fit in more than one).
Next year it will be 5 years since we did this... seems like December/January is a great time to do it again. This way we can all play the September madness games and check Underworld Ascendant.
I was thinking of using the same system, any feedback?
We did 2012-2016 RPGs last year already: http://www.rpgcodex.net/content.php?id=10535
The fun thing about doing this is to see how modern RPGs compare to older titles, see how Witcher 3 or D:OS rank alongside Fallout: New Vegas, Gothic and other older games.