Paul_cz
Arcane
- Joined
- Jan 26, 2014
- Messages
- 2,175
I never understood what the whole fight is about. Why can't people like Witcher 3 without insisting that it's an RPG, which it really isn't. The game is really fun and I have hundreds of hours in it, but I wouldn't call it an RPG - both combat, equpment and character build are superficial to the point that they serve as distraction from the two main activities, exploration (often guided through "witcher senses") and dialogue, where the C&C usually is.
Whether something is an RPG depends on how you define it (yes the dreaded "what is an RPG" discussion, yeaaah). To me the most important component of RPG being an RPG is choices and consequences with interactive dialogue + player agency followed by character progression and customization. Witcher has lot of the former and slightly less of the latter, but enough to be generally considered RPG, just like KOTOR, Vampire Bloodlines, Deus Ex and many other 3D classic RPGs that are considered RPGs without anyone disputing it for some reason.
Again, it is fine if you think it's an action game or whatever, but don't be surprised when others disagree.