What are you two dinguses talking about? SotfS was a standard "Game of the Year" edition, a base game with all the DLCs for the price of the vanilla. Plus the core game got some nice make up, additional items and a new boss. That's the best offer in the world for people like me who came late to the party.
It split the PC fanbase because it's a DX11 edition that can't be upgraded to from DX9 unless you pay exactly the amount you spent when buying the game Day 1. Basically it fucked everyone who bought the game Day 1 in the ass because, iirc the initial pricing is literally requiring people to buy the upgrade with the exact same price as its vanilla release, thus it means people who bought the game Day 1 were forced to pay literally twice for what should've been there in the first place. Yes, it's much better thing to offer for those who's late to the party, but for those who bought the game Day 1..... I also vaguely remembering the outrage were caused because they announced it quite sometime after releasing the last DLC, so people literally wasted so much money buying the vanilla game Day 1 + 3 individual DLCs, only to get fucked in the ass with the fact that Dark Souls 2: Better Edition is coming and they aren't getting any discount to get it, and had to pay the exact same full price again.
Same case here with this DS1 remaster. Feels like they want to jump into the remastering a game from 2011 bandwagon with Bethesda. Not to mention they really made it unclear whether there's going to be a discount or not, and what it features really seems like it's not worth it, AND it split the fanbase, too.