Xi
Arcane
"but it had a bit more depth to it"
No, it didn't. Outside fo the warrior special attack all melee combat is spam the attack button, guzzle some buttons, and retreat/flee if overhwelmed by numbers or uber boss 9early/mid game as late game is just one huge joke). DD2 combat has more depth as at least you had more actual options.
I agree. DD1 was pretty simplistic, but it captured the illusion of disbelief quite well. What else matters? It worked.