Lol, you are insane if you think the combat is janky, it's amazing. My only problem with it is those dudes that have red/blue attacks, there is not enough time to respond to them on higher difficulties, but otherwise it's a glorious combat system.
Lol wtf. The games combat is smooth but is completely brain-dead and gets old 3 hours in. How the fuck do you call this combat amazing? Play some real videogames nigga.
This is the kind of retard that encourages shitty studios to make Souls-like games. Oh, I need something new constantly, how about a new Boss that has 2,000,000 hitpoints and can kill my entire family with one fart? Please developers, make it happen, tell me which hoops I have to jump through to beat this thing! I like obeying orders like a dog.
What? But I dislike every souls game after Dark Souls 1.
GoT combat is shit because there's 5 enemy types - shield, dual sword, spear, sword, armored, bow niggas (am i forgetting anyone?), providing very little variety. It's shit because the AI falls into a repetitive behaviour where it will force-dodge/block any attack after your 3-string combo, and once you realize this, it's over - the illusion of dynamic combat is completely gone, you know that once you mash square 3 times it's time to go on the defensive because the AI will block your next attack, and the repetitiveness starts being aggravating. It's shit because from the outset half your moveset is worthless, and the more upgrades you get the more irrelevant they become as new moves provide insane powercreep. It's shit because a big feature of combat (the stances) are effectively irrelevant.
Shit combat can still be enjoyable for a while but it falls apart once the honeymoon period illusion is gone.
If you enjoy it you enjoy it (try the new assassins creed you might like them) but damn don't call it great. It's lazy and clearly not the focus of the game. (can't believe you're the same retard that shits on rdr2's combat and praises this lol)