Incline GOTY 2023 Games List discussion

[Lord_Potato]

felipepepe Twiglard Infinitron Guys, thanks for adding Heads Will Roll: Reforged. Now I can vote with peace of mind!

 

[Jedi Master Radek]

Good luck to everyone who votes. Like always I am behind with games, but when I will do a catch up I will have a handy guide thanks to you all

 

[Cohesion]

If BG3 wins it's joever for codex.

 

[Viata]

If BG3 wins it's joever for codex.

Why? It's not like previous GOTY threads didn't have some bad (or all bad) games on TOP 3. If anything, it just shows that despite complain about triple A games, most codex user still prefer to play triple A games.

 

[Cohesion]

If BG3 wins it's joever for codex.

Why? It's not like previous GOTY threads didn't have some bad (or all bad) games on TOP 3. If anything, it just shows that despite complain about triple A games, most codex user still prefer to play triple A games.

We had a lot of nice indies. If BG wins that must mean people here value production values more than anything else and we've become another reddit / resetera.

 

[Viata]

We had a lot of nice indies.

Yes, but unless all the X people that played a given indie game and gave it a 5, the games with most votes are still the ones winning. For every 1 user that played "x game", more than 20 users played BG3. Just compare the number of posts every indie game thread has with the number of posts every "game from some big dev" has and also how many threads each of those games get. At the end of the day, despite indie games been far more interesting nowadays, more so the cRPG ones, many users still prefer good 3D graphics. It's sad, but it is what it is.

 

[Catacombs]

So to celebrate this unique and wildly anticipated time of the year:

or this?

#2 for sure

 

[Cohesion]

So to celebrate this unique and wildly anticipated time of the year:

or this?

Add some slain trannies and/or redditors at his feet.

 

[OSK]

I don't see FIFA, Madden, nor Forza Horizon 5. WTF.

 

[Ryzer]

I don't see FIFA, Madden, nor Forza Horizon 5. WTF.

Not enough space to fit all the DLCs in.

 

[Tyranicon]

The poll is up already? Gave my only 5s to Caves of Lore and Jagged Alliance 3 (which imo was more of a 4.x, but whatever, I rounded up).



Best of luck, hoping for an upset.

 

[felipepepe]

Ok, newspost is live, let's fucking go: https://rpgcodex.net/forums/threads/rpg-codex-2023-goty-vote-now.149626/

 

[Viata]

First time I had more than 0 games to vote, sadly all the games I voted I have not played last year, but when they were first released on consoles.

 

[Lord_Potato]

For the first time I actually have lots of games to vote for - I completed 5 games from 2023 and played another one long enough to grade, despite not finishing it.

 

[AlwaysBrotoMen]

Horrible font and spacing with unreadable color Please change it

 

[Viata]

Horrible font and spacing with unreadable color Please change it

It's to match the effort some devs spent making those games.

 

[GloomFrost]

Rogue Trader and JA3 are absolute 5! Made this year for me. Caves of Lore was an unexpected surprise. Some nice DlCs like Heavy Duty and King of Nothing. Diablo 4 provided a relatively satisfying single player campaign. While Colony Ship was a pure disappointment. All and all not a TERRIBLE year for RPG genre. As Harrim from Kingmaker used to say "Could have been worse. And will be, definitely will be."

 

[Viata]

While Colony Ship was a pure disappointment

Could you explain why? It's one of the few games released last year that I want to play.

 

[BosanskiSeljak]

If BG3 wins it's joever for codex.

Why? It's not like previous GOTY threads didn't have some bad (or all bad) games on TOP 3. If anything, it just shows that despite complain about triple A games, most codex user still prefer to play triple A games.

We had a lot of nice indies. If BG wins that must mean people here value production values more than anything else and we've become another reddit / resetera.

It was always like that, 2019 top RPGs list makes it it very clear

 

[Cyberarmy]

Gave 5s to Jagged Alliance 3, SpellForce: Conquest of Eo and The Last Spell. All of those games surpised me TBH and had really fun with them all.
Legends of Amberland II: The Song of Trees, Lies of P and Remnant 2 are the other ones I had really fun but they don't deserve 5s IMHO.
So many small indie games, so little time. I miss my days in collage where I had all the time in the world...

 

[Edgetard]

I rated BG3 a one I did my part will the rest of you do the same

 

[Taka-Haradin puolipeikko]

View attachment 46661

Needs more parrots.

 

[lukaszek]

Needs more parrots.

funny thing, my prompt was pretty minimal. I assume that keyword was 'flag' that did result in a lot of freedom

 

[Nifft Batuff]

I don't see FIFA, Madden, nor Forza Horizon 5. WTF.

They don't have romances.

 

[Lord_Potato]

I gave 5s to Phantom Liberty, because it was a very good addition to CP2077, Space Wreck and Heads Will Roll: Reforged, because cool indies need all the visibility they can get!

4 to Colony Ship, which was okay, but less than what I expected.

3 to Starfield (aggressively mediocre) and Knights of the Cross. I'd give it 2 if not for the setting based on Polish historical novel from 1897; on the other hand if it was not based on this novel most likely I wouldn't play it at all.