Yeah, what's up with that? And then she gets pissed at us for trying to guess what the fuck she wants?Seriously, would it have killed Skekrum to do something like shake her head slightly in a "No" if she really did not want us to go?
What I'm saying is that none of this is even mentioned in the A choice at all. A isn't us pretending to stay with Aphrodite only to sneak out later - it is actually staying with her on your own free will (or what's left of it) in preference to Sekhenun, and also abandoning our mission. What you are proposing is option E - lying to Aphrodite, then trying to get back to the ship before it sets sail. Which probably wouldn't work once Aphrodite gets her claws in us. Plus we kind of suck at lying in the first place and it goes out of our character.A effectively means to succumb to whatever control she's placing on us and breaking our deal with Sekhenun. This is totally out of character for Ean - he is a man of his word, and is always loyal to his allies. Yes, Sekhenun might help us escape later - but what if she wont? After all, she's already pissed at us, and now we abandon her and the deal we had for a first piece of immortal ass that we come across? And a pretty manipulative piece of ass might I add - the moment she sees us, she imminently uses her abilities on us?
The problem is that acting in a way that we thought was in-character fucked us over last time. What was that we said before: Ean is a man of action, so we ought to go on an ill-advised visit to the goddess because Sekhenun was twitching her face at us in a weird way? Acting in-character doesn't mean being a fucking idiot. Being honorable is all well and good, but we can't be completely truthful and honorable regardless of the circumstances. Ean needs to smarten up before he turns into Ned Stark. Ean knows he is basically a mortal now, and he is aware that he is in a difficult position. We've got four choices here, all of them are kinda shitty to be honest. But A is the least shitty choice.
While we may be honorable, Sekhenun is not. She knows how to be tactful and manipulative in the right circumstances, that's how she rose to become a favoured handmaiden in the first place. She'll see our compliance with this situation as exactly what it is - coercion. Being a Gieloth, I'm sure she is quite familiar with the deadly nature of Gieloth court politics that Nabu alluded to. She knows that telling the truth is a bad idea in a lot of situations, and that sometimes you need to play the courtly game - you have to bow and scrape and be subservient to those more powerful than you, so that you can make your move when your enemy least suspects it.
I'm not saying A is a great choice, but it will buy us some time. Aphrodite's presence caused the voices to stir within Ean's mind again, and I think that allowing us a small boost of power (so we can be a better slave for her, of course) could prove to be her undoing.
What I'm saying is that none of this is even mentioned in the A choice at all. A isn't us pretending to stay with Aphrodite only to sneak out later - it is actually staying with her on your own free will (or what's left of it) in preference to Sekhenun, and also abandoning our mission. What you are proposing is option E - lying to Aphrodite, then trying to get back to the ship before it sets sail. Which probably wouldn't work once Aphrodite gets her claws in us. Plus we kind of suck at lying in the first place and it goes out of our character.
Maybe we can get treave to confirm what choice A actually entails, but I doubt it is what you think it is.
So you are voting A to avoid pissing off Mehrune, even though A means Mehrune will abandon us here? And you are betting on that Sekhenun will stay behind and delay her mission to help us after we tell her to go fuck herself? At least in choices B or C we also make it clear to Sekhenun that we are still on her side - then if we get forced to stay, she is likely to actually come to our aid. In A we don't even have that - Sekhenun will abandon us on the spot and we will be stuck with this manipulative bitch.What I'm saying is that none of this is even mentioned in the A choice at all. A isn't us pretending to stay with Aphrodite only to sneak out later - it is actually staying with her on your own free will (or what's left of it) in preference to Sekhenun, and also abandoning our mission. What you are proposing is option E - lying to Aphrodite, then trying to get back to the ship before it sets sail. Which probably wouldn't work once Aphrodite gets her claws in us. Plus we kind of suck at lying in the first place and it goes out of our character.
Maybe we can get treave to confirm what choice A actually entails, but I doubt it is what you think it is.
I understand fully well what A would entail. It would mean sticking around, abandoning the mission (which we've already nearly abandoned in the first place by deciding to come here), and submitting to Aphrodite for the time being because we're kinda fucked. We might regain a little bit of our power while she uses us as a puppet. I am hoping that in biding our time and being meek, she will let her guard down at some point, allowing us to either kill her or escape from Cyprus in the future.
It's still much better than C, which is A but worse. Regardless, I think it's worth it to try for a tactful response to appease Mehrune (yes, she is important) and hope that Sekhenun is there to shield our mind if we're in trouble. I am predicting that she'll still be planning her vengeance, but we'll be able to leave the island in one piece.
This.Edit: I'll flop to any option that'll beat A. I'm not partying while Rome burns.