sstacks and anyone else who thinks Valerie’s shield looks implausible: it’s modeled after a real late medieval design, the Talhoffer dueling shield. There’s plenty of cartoony stuff in Pathfinder but the shield is legitimate.
From a 16th century manuscript recounting a 15th century duel:
Autism overpowering me... must resist...
From a 16th century manuscript recounting a 15th century duel:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/871b9/871b97ad3b6cbaf28931f311f4dc6ca302f267b8" alt="thott-duel.jpg"
Autism overpowering me... must resist...