Regarding emulation, how do the FPGA atari and amiga emulators compare?
I tried software emulation for atari ST, but it felt off for some reason, compared to running the same games on my old machine. Maybe the controls felt less responsive?
I could never get fully into emulation of old computers I used (C64 and Amiga), except for dosbox/dosbox staging, perhaps because the keyboard is the same, controls, etc for the PC. The C64 has it's own quirks, noises of the drive, screen look and keyboard/controllers. Same with the Amiga, even though it is closer to a PC, has it's drive sounds, look and feel of controls and mouse. Apart from maybe hard drive noises and CD/DVD ROM sounds (lol) old PC's didn't really have a "thing" in the aural sense. Just the visual of a good CRT screen.
With that said, I haven't gotten used to Amiga disk corruption (the C64 disks are all perfectly fine though. Even disks that were heavily abused back in the day, don't have an error anywhere. Strange) where many disks have gone totally useless. I did rewrite a lot of Amiga games back to blank PC disks (after covering the HD hole on them). Not sure what it is, as my PC disk games are also all fine.
A lot of people can't stand the waiting time, disk swapping, etc, but the Amiga isn't too slow with loads (except for a few later games that came on 8+ disks and were clearly meant for an expensive hard drive), and the C64 load times have been massively improved after installing jiffydos, so this lets me enjoy the whole experience. I am also lucky enough to own good monitors for both of these systems (though not a CRT for PC....), and this is a big part of the experience as well for people that used and enjoyed these systems.
I guess the FPGA emulators are like using a silent "insert system". For myself, I can't see them ticking the boxes for what I want, but it depends on what you want out of emulation. If the FPGA could be hooked up to actual working drives, actual correct screens and operate in the exact same way, then they would be good from the standpoint of not worrying about having to do remedial work on old computer parts to keep them going (apart from the drives or screens anyway).