Gregz
Arcane
And give us back our custom avatars!
Oh, wait they're all gone.
Maybe it should be a random script that'll give you a different number of sub forums depending on when you load the page, can call it roguelike.
A vote for "Go back to the two forums" is a vote for Hitler.
ARPG and "normal" RPG should be enough. Old titles (pre-1990) wouldn't get enough action to justify their own space, and would probably give some incline since they're likely to be closer to the ideal of pcrpg.
I immensely dislike tags. I use an extension to block them from showing at all.