Community RPG Codex GOTY 2023: Results & Cool Graphs

[lycanwarrior]

But Jagged Alliance 3 isn't an RPG.

But neither is Elden Ring, which got Codex GotY award as well.

I'd say JA3 is at least closer to being one at least.

Overall I'd agree with JA3 being at the top, with Rogue Trader 2nd IMHO.

Will get the Solasta DLC sometime later this year.

 

[raeven]

Also:

View attachment 46963

And well deserved.

 

[Modron]

Who the fuck would give negative votes to Caves of Lore!?

It's pretty easy to look up all the data is right there: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet...zCi-lAqiVEgM5aREVbedVFLym8/edit#gid=389156911

1 out of 5

Hellraiser
racofer
BING XI LAO

2 out of 5

Anubioz
Longes
Karwelas
Alienman
Tatzelwurm

3 out of 5

covr
ghostdog
Scruffy
Don Peste
Foxtrix
Angelo85
sser
Grauken
Baron Dupek
Agesilaus
GloomFrost
Rick'
Sentinel
Stavrophore
MpuMngwana
Falksi
Catacombs
Frank Capicoli
Strange Fellow
Tweed
Ryzer
Inhabitants of Khorinis
notpl
General Kenobi
Nemelex

 

[Tavar]

Seeing Colony Ship on place three makes me happy. I expected it to do worse given how many retards shit on the game in the dedicated thread. I'm surprised that JA3 did so well especially given the rather low player count. However, JA3 is clearly the better GOTY than BG3, so well done everyone.

 

[Yosharian]

Who the fuck would give negative votes to Caves of Lore!?

It's pretty easy to look up all the data is right there: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet...zCi-lAqiVEgM5aREVbedVFLym8/edit#gid=389156911

1 out of 5

Hellraiser
racofer
BING XI LAO

2 out of 5

Anubioz
Longes
Karwelas
Alienman
Tatzelwurm

3 out of 5

covr
ghostdog
Scruffy
Don Peste
Foxtrix
Angelo85
sser
Grauken
Baron Dupek
Agesilaus
GloomFrost
Rick'
Sentinel
Stavrophore
MpuMngwana
Falksi
Catacombs
Frank Capicoli
Strange Fellow
Tweed
Ryzer
Inhabitants of Khorinis
notpl
General Kenobi
Nemelex

 

[Yosharian]

Caves of Lore is a really fantastic game

 

[Darth Roxor]

very nice, the top three are games i rated 2, didn't play and 2 respectively, exciting year

 

[Darth Roxor]

 

[Lord of Riva]

I'm really happy to see the codex pulling through, so much for BG 3 definitely winning GOTY, great going guys.

 

[Russia is over. The end.]

At least it's not BG3. Saved by some random shit.

 

[Oreshnik Missile]

proud member of the "voted 1/5 for bg3 despite not having played it" crowd checking in
you're welcome

i know you fuckers would have made it goty if not for us

Same here. BG3 players should kill themselves.

 

[Lord_Potato]

But Jagged Alliance 3 isn't an RPG.

The people have spoken and decided it is.

 

[Falksi]

Loving the placement of Starfield, Forespoken and FF16.

Gonna spread on social media now to upset some normies.

 

[ERYFKRAD]

BG3 players should kill themselves.

As should the weirdos who shat on Caves of Lore.

 

[Russia is over. The end.]

proud member of the "voted 1/5 for bg3 despite not having played it" crowd checking in
you're welcome

i know you fuckers would have made it goty if not for us

Same here. BG3 players should kill themselves.

49% of the dex would be dead. The air would become clean, the discussions fresh, smart and to the point. Such dreams, never to be made reality...

 

[Lagole Gon]

Whoops. I didn't rate World of Horror. Eh, I would probably give it 3 anyway.

Also, motherfuckers, buy Lights Going Out. It's much better than Ride Like a Wind. And I really want to get the third part.

 

[Lord of Riva]

very nice, the top three are games i rated 2, didn't play and 2 respectively, exciting year

You really think JA3 is as "good" as demon Lord reincarnation?

 

[Darth Roxor]

yes, got a problem with that, punk

 

[Paul_cz]

JA3 is an RPG. Much more than JA2 was. It is quite close in its design to something like Wasteland 3, which is also RPG.

Also, it was my GOTY, so I am glad it won.

BG3 was great too for the most part, but I just enjoyed JA3 more.

 

[Lord of Riva]

yes, got a problem with that, punk

DLR was, really, really bad. Just surprising to me.

 

[Darth Roxor]

i ragequit demon lord after about an hour, and i also ragequit the ja3 demo after about an hour; one is a failed wizardry lookalike, the other a failed jagged alliance lookalike

yes, i think the same rating is appropriate for them

 

[Falksi]

The Yakuza games released last year stand out as a big miss.

 

[Lord of Riva]

i ragequit demon lord after about an hour, and i also ragequit the ja3 demo after about an hour; one is a failed wizardry lookalike, the other a failed jagged alliance lookalike

yes, i think the same rating is appropriate for them

fair I did the same with DLR.

 

[Lagole Gon]

Cheer up Swen!

 

[Yosharian]

Rating JA3 a two, what the hell