New total ranking adjusted for mondblutianism
[new rank] [name] ... [NSP] ... [ranks won or lost]
1 Jagged Alliance 2 … 54.3 … 12
2 Fallout 1 … 43.9 … 0
3 Wizardry 8 … 40.6 … 17
4 Planescape: Torment … 38.4 … -3
5 Grimoire: Heralds of the Winged Exemplar … 36.3 … 17
6 Fallout 2 … 31.6 … 0
7 Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura … 30.9 … -3
8 Vampire: The Mascarade - Bloodlines … 29.5 … -3
9 Wizardry VII: Crusaders of the Dark Savant … 29.1 … 20
10 Baldur's Gate 2: Shadows of Amn … 28.7 … -7
11 Pool of Radiance … 26.1 … 15
12 Deus Ex … 15.9 … -4
13 Dark Souls … 15.7 … -1
14 TES III: Morrowind … 15.3 … -4
15 Fallout: New Vegas … 14.9 … -8
16 M&M IV-V: Xeen … 13.5 … 23
17 Gothic 2 … 13.1 … -8
18 Age of Decadence … 11.8 … -7
19 Pathfinder: Kingmaker … 10.9 … -5
20 Underrail … 10.2 … -4
21 RoA II: Star Trail … 9.6 … 21
22 M&M II: Gates to Another World … 9.2 … 45
23 Betrayal at Krondor … 9.1 … 2
24 Dark Sun: Shattered Lands … 8.3 … 10
25 Shadowrun: Dragonfall - Director's Cut … 8.3 … 3
Here is a separate list that excludes the shameful scumbags like myself who did not give at least (selected on the basis of the fanboy method above). 1-pointers are excluded because your pity point is insulting. The max points given by a single user for those five games is 15 (from mondblut and Dorateen). In total, 107 codexers have at least some 'thal in them and gave 2 or more points to these games.
Formula: as above. You might want to exclude the top 5 because they are reference points.
[rank] [name] [relative gain]
1 Jagged Alliance 2 … 50.9
2 Wizardry 8 … 37.9
3 Grimoire: Heralds of the Winged Exemplar … 36.4
4 Wizardry VII: Crusaders of the Dark Savant … 29.1
5 Pool of Radiance … 24.4
6 M&M IV-V: Xeen … 10.8
7 M&M II: Gates to Another World … 8.9
8 Pools of Darkness … 6.5
9 RoA II: Star Trail … 6.3
10 Wizardry VI: Bane of the Cosmic Forge … 4.6
11 Ultima Underworld I: The Stygian Abyss … 3.8
12 Dark Sun: Shattered Lands … 3.5
13 Kenshi … 3.4
14 Shadowrun: Dragonfall - Director's Cut … 2.6
15 Betrayal at Krondor … 2.4
16 Knights of the Chalice … 1.9
17 Dark Souls II … 1.2
18 The Temple of Elemental Evil … 1.1
19 M&M VII: For Blood and Honor … 1.1
20 Fallout 2 … 1
21 System Shock 2 … 0.9
22 Divinity: Original Sin … 0.9
23 Dungeon Master … 0.9
24 Arx Fatalis … 0.6
25 TES II: Daggerfall … 0.5
26 Elminage: Gothic … 0.5
This is /pol/ level autism, and I salute you.I'm making the new gluten-free prestigious Codex Top cRPG, almost done page 1, it's going to take some time, even with the discarded sub-human votes.
As a side note, i'm gathering the NSP scores on piece of paper (required for the new rating)
Best NSP ratings so far
Worst NSP ratings
- Goral 0.56
- mushaden 0.44
- fantadomat 0.36
- Lady Error 0.32
- Tigranes 0.24
- GabrielMP_19 0.24
- majorsoccer (troll post) -3
- Ulfhednar 0
- Nano 0
- Ventidus 0
I lost all hope in felipepe's polls for a several years already (and sometimes, I just missed them).I'm a bit disappointed in the turn-up for this vote.
Fowyr said:Nah, there is just too many newfags on the Codex whose first cRPG was BG2 or, God forbid, Oblivion and who never played anything older. IncendiaryDevice 's polls are very elucidating in that regard. Aethra Chronicles is one of the best shareware RPGs of 90s, but was played only by Andhaira, mondblut, octavius, V_K and handful others.
So you cooked the votes to have different result huh...
...
..
.
Interesting~
So you filtered the votes to have different result huh...
...
..
.
Interesting~
I fail to see Arcanum here, mate. Vote fraud!Temporary scores (page 1 )
Fallout 1 0.6+0.4+0.64+3.6+1.92+1.2//+0.48 = 8.84
Planetscape: Torment 0.6+1.8+0.6+0.48+0.48+0.32+0.96//+0.64 = 5.88
Wizardry 8 0.16+2.88+0.48 = 3.52
Underrail 0.36+0.4+0.48+1.2 = 2.44
Fallout 2 0.48+0.6+0.2+0.6+0.48 = 2.36
Wizardry 7 0.96+0.96 = 1.92
Might & Magic 6 1.8
Grimoire: Heralds of the Winged Exemplar 1.6
Vampire the Masquerade Bloodlines 0.72+0.56 = 1.28
Gothic 1 0.6+0.64 = 1.24
I never said any fraud. Strike a nerve?So you filtered the votes to have different result huh...
...
..
.
Interesting~
It's not fraud if you get the results you want
Do I win anything?Worst NSP ratings
- majorsoccer (troll post) -3
- Ulfhednar 0
- Nano 0
- Ventidus 0
Do I win anything?Worst NSP ratings
- majorsoccer (troll post) -3
- Ulfhednar 0
- Nano 0
- Ventidus 0
I fail to see Arcanum here, mate. Vote fraud!
So single character RPGs go straight outta window, such as:Isometric party-based
The point of that? E.G., I don't play any blobbers and weeb shit, so my votes in these categories would be completely worthless. Similar situation for the time periods - what's the point of voting for the game one didn't play?Everyone would be allowed to vote in every category but would also be allowed to only vote in one, no shame is admitting you never player any game pre 94, any blobber or any JRPG (lucky you).
No Underrail
No AoD
No Fallout 1 (AI companions != party)
The point of that? E.G., I don't play any blobbers and weeb shit, so my votes in these categories would be completely worthless. Similar situation for the time periods - what's the point of voting for the game one didn't play?
Nothing, I just can't fucking read. Vote in any category, but only in one, that makes sense.What are you complaining about exactly here ?
Most party-based games could be soloed. I never ever had any companions in Fallout 1 - they are useless trash, and rarely had any in Fallout 2 - they are better there, but I'm not a fan of babysitting them and the game is too easy if you have direct control. Funny, for me Fallout 1 and 2 is always single-character isometric.Underrail, The Quest, AoD, etc. are quite the weirdos, they deserve a proper category but they're clearly not in the same one as the isometric party-based ones.